Youth Data Collection

The resources on this page include different ways to collect data from youth regarding their experiences with failure and getting "unstuck." They were created through conversations among members of our community. We encourage you to reflect upon the youth data collected throughout the PD cycle and/or within Workshop 3 and Workshop 4 as part of video reflections.

Summer Camp Concept Map

Youth are asked to draw lines to words or phrases that they did during summer camp. These include: (a) make connections, (b) solve problems, (c) think creatively, (d) learn from failures, (e) discover, (f) share, (g) try, and (h) wonder. Youth are also asked to write a sentence or two about why they circled the items they circled. (Created by: The Bakken Museum)

Whole Group, Small Group, or Individual Reflection

A set of questions to pose at the end of a session regarding experiences with failure or have a place for youth to post responses. Examples include: (a) When did you struggle and how did you overcome it? (b) Was that a new strategy for you or was something you knew how to do already? (c) Who felt like they learned a new strategy today? Raise your hand. (d) What was a frustrating moment you had at camp? (e) When was a time things didn't go the way you planned in a project?  (Utilized by: The Tech Interactive,  Scott Family Amazeum, & Montshire Science Museum)

Three groups of educators sit at different tables, working and discussing.

Failure in Making Youth Assessment

This assessment includes several sets of questions that can be used in its entirety or individual sets of questions. Questions are framed around (a) failure mindset, (b) problem solving strategies, and (c) emotional responses to failure (Created by: Science Museum of Minnesota & Alice Anderson)

Unstuck Poster

Create a list of what to do when you are stuck. We suggest this be created by the youth and educators at the beginning of the making activity. This becomes a living document that can be added to throughout the activity, whether this be a drop-in session, a workshop, or a week-long camp.  If a week-long camp, youth can add a dot at the end of the day to note which strategies were used. Use a different color dot each day. See images below. (Created by: Montshire Museum of Science & Scott Family Amazeum)

Poster with 5 strategies listed (Change your plan, Change your goal, Change your materials, Learn a new skill, Ask for help). Each strategy has between 2-10 stickers.
Getting Unstuck strategies for July 13, yellow and red stickers.

July 13

Getting Unstuck strategies for July 14, blue stickers added to previous chart.

July 14

Getting Unstuck strategies for July 15, heart stickers added to previous chart.

July 15

Youth Data Consideration

There are things to keep in mind when collecting data from youth such as ethics and privacy.  We have provided some guidance with this document, including sample assent and consent forms.