Embedded Files
Silence strategy happens when members deliberately withhold meaningful input during official meetings because consensus was arranged privately beforehand. What looks like smooth efficiency is actually prearranged agreement.
Why It Matters
Strips deliberation of its educational and persuasive value.
Prevents the public (or minority members) from hearing the reasoning behind decisions.
Creates the appearance of harmony while masking division or manipulation.
Tell-Tale Signs
Little to no debate before major decisions.
Members nod or vote in silence with minimal explanation.
Questions raised by outsiders receive vague, pre-scripted replies.
Examples Across Levels
Local: A neighborhood board adopts a new spending policy unanimously, with zero discussion.
State: Legislators give one-line statements, signaling votes already whipped.
Federal: Party caucuses predetermine votes, leaving floor debate as ceremonial.
Countermeasures
Encourage or require members to briefly state reasons for their votes.
Adopt rules that protect the right to debate each substantive motion.
Use minority reports or dissenting statements to ensure perspectives enter the record.
Related Patterns
Google Sites
Report abuse