8/17/26 "West Side Story" 2021
7/10 Stars, Favorite Quote: "All my life, it's like I'm always just about to fall off the edge of the world's tallest building. I stopped falling the second I saw you." Do they say the title of the movie within the movie: No
It's incredibly hard to review this movie. While the movie itself was good, I feel like problems start to arise when comparing it to the 1961 version. Spielberg doesn't have a lot of experience directing musicals, so a lot of the scenes are shot like action sequences, which was pretty interesting but sometimes didn't really work. For instance, Spielberg has a habit of stuffing scenes with extras that, in my opinion, don't really need to be there. In this film's version of "America", they go all throughout the city and have hundreds of people join in and take verses. In the original movie, they got that energetic performance by just letting the scene be. Spielberg tends to go wide on a lot of shots, and it just takes away from the choreography. They try to ground this movie in reality, which I see how that would be a good idea, but the more fantastical elements of the original film seem lost. It's crazy how the 60s one seemed to be more experimental than this newer one. For instance, instead of transporting Maria and Tony to their own dream ballet, surrounded by stars and other lovers, they're shoved behind some bleachers. Instead of the dance disappearing behind Tony as he walks the streets of New York singing out Maria's name, now he's just on a basketball court where the lights turn on. Speaking of Tony, Ansel Elgort doesn't really seem to give a lot in the role. He sings fine, but his acting felt kind of stiff, especially against the powerhouses of Rachel Zegler, Arianna DeBose, and Mike Faist. This movie does have a plus for having all the actors sing their own parts and not need dubbing, but I feel like it's not worth the loss of the beauty and color of the original movie. Every time I watch the 60s one, I always, without fail, start crying at the end, whereas here I didn't shed a tear.