Return to your Final Draft Notes and look for the evidence that matches the patterns on which you've based your claim.
Let's say you want to use the evidence you collected from pages 1 and 2. You have to determine what in your notes is evidence, and what is analysis that you've naturally done as you read or during the discussion about the text.
In this case, you added the actual evidence, "the teachers didn't like me," during the discussion when you provided a quote to support your original conclusion that he is smarter than everyone (which was your analysis as you read). So that quote would be the kernel of your first CD.
When working with a novel or a play, your best bet is to organize evidence chronologically and to make sure you have a balance of details from the beginning, middle and end of the story.
Why?
Because in order to understand one thing, you need to know what came before. And when you’re thinking about characters you have:
motivation → conflict → change.
Theme (or the meaning of the story) is developed over time and is built off of the characters developing (or not).