HOW TO RECOGNIZE STUDENTS PERFORMING POORLY ?
There are a variety of ways to recognize students performing poorly such as their grades or their attendance in class. However, when identifying these students, it is important to try to also identify students at risk of performing poorly by looking for early indicators of poor performance. Even when you are not specifically asked by the instructor to reach out to students, it is important to make note of at-risk students so you can notify the instructor and the student can receive assistance.
One of the primary goals of a TA is to help students to succeed. Recognizing and addressing poor performance early in the semester plays an important role in helping the student to stay motivated to successfully complete the course. Additionally, recognizing students who are performing poorly, or are struggling and may start to perform poorly, early on can help you address the issues before the cause unrecoverable damage to the student’s grade or affect other students’ performance in the class.
Grades
Working with the instructor to establish a minimum grade point average can be a useful threshold for identifying students who are performing poorly.
The TA can quickly utilize the Gradebook tab in Canvas to see which students fall below that threshold and then send emails to them when appropriate.
Class Participation
Students who are performing poorly might be repeatedly missing class or not participating in class discussions.
The TA should determine how many missed classes are cause for concern, particularly sequentially missed classes, to know the threshold for identifying at-risk students.
If the class does not take attendance or utilize assignments such as quizzes or participation activities, TA should keep track of grades or assignment completion to identify poor performance.
Assignment Completion
It is important to work with the class instructor to establish the number of missed assignments, including sequentially missed assignments, that will act as the threshold for identifying students performing poorly in class.
These two numbers could be different, as a student missing multiple assignments in a row could be a strong indicator of an issue than a student who misses the occasional assignment.
Even those these occasional missed assignments can add up and be the cause of concern. As such, it is important to establish the two thresholds to make sure no student who needs help is left behind due to failing to meet the required threshold in time.
Checklist for Identifying Poor Performance
Is the student missing 2 weeks or more of class activities and prep work?
Is the student consistently absent from class?
Has the student’s group reported a lack of participation/ contribution to the group work?
Is the student’s grade point average a C or lower?
When in class, does the student sit quietly and not participate in activities or when asked questions?
After identifying students who are performing poorly in class, or at risk for performing poorly, the TA should first notify the class instructor which students are performing poorly. The instructor may then ask the TA to reach out to the student to try to help them, or they may prefer to reach out to the student themselves.
When first communicating concern about poor performance, it is important to be approachable and non-accusatory. One TA makes the following recommendation about approaching students, specifically during class.
“…[Approaching students falling behind] individually and ask how they were doing in the class, if they had any troubles with something specifically, encourage them to come to my office hours, etc. Sometimes I'd also start discussions about the class format itself and if they had any feedback or if there was something there that made it more challenging for them.”
Another way to communicate concern is via email or Canvas messaging. When the TA is unsure of a student’s email address, they can use the inbox to ensure they send a message to the correct student by selecting New Message -> Your Class -> Student’s Name. Similarly, to when you are approaching the student in person, it is important to remain approachable and non-confrontational as well as seem willing to help and work with the student. A sample template for emailing the student about to communicate initial concerns can be found in the picture. As such, the initial communication of concerns to each student should be customized the communicate the specific behavior that is indicative of poor performance in their situation
Individualizing communication with students will increase the chances of receiving a response as the student is more likely to feel that the TA actually wants to help them and cares if they succeed. Consequently, it is important for the initial communication of concern to be as inviting and non-accusatory as possible so that the student feels that help is being offered and not an acknowledgement of their failures.
Sometimes a student may forget to follow up with the TA or it may take them time to arrange their schedule to attend their office hours. If a student doesn’t respond to the initial email or never shows up to the TA’s office hours but continues to perform poorly, try reaching out to them again via email or by speaking to them in class. They may need to work with the TA to find a custom time to meet with them. A sample email for a follow up email is depicted in the picture. Similarly, to when communicating initial concern, this message should be customized to each student and should reference the concerns expressed in the initial email. Additional concerns can be brought forth in this email to acknowledge a continuation of the concerning performance, however, TAs should be mindful of how many negatives they draw attention to in order to avoid upsetting and alienating the student.
If the student fails to respond to your emails and disregards your requests or attempts in class, communicate this with the class instructor. They may be able to reach out to the student on your behalf. Additionally, both the instructor and you will now be aware that this student may need additional help during class to understand the course material and complete assignments and that one of you should plan on speaking with this student each time the class is working on an activity to address any questions they might have.
Understanding why students are performing poorly plays a key role in helping to address poor performance. When the motivators for poor performance are not related to academic understanding, students may need to utilize other resources, such as the Counseling Center, for help finding solutions to manage their concerns. More information on these resources can be found down below. However, while there are different solutions for poor performance, there are some key actions a TA can do both inside and outside of the classroom to help students improve.
When in the classroom, the primary method for addressing poor performance is by working with the student to answer questions as they complete assignments. However, it is important to avoid drawing too much attention to the student by focusing on them as this can be counterproductive. This can be done during group work or when answering the questions.
Working in groups, can offer an opportunity for students who are struggling to seek help from other students. However, it can also cause frustrations with group members if the student who is struggling is not contributing or attending class. Some general guidelines for helping students who are performing poorly in groups is to encourage them to communicate with their group members about what they are struggling to understand and to encourage the group as a whole to set specific goals for what each group member will accomplish each week.
When answering questions in class, it is important to guide the student to the answer rather than give them the answer. This helps give the student resources that they can use later when they are struggling with a similar problem. Additionally, this helps the student learn through the material and the TA to identify the precise concept they are struggling with.
One way to guide students to the answer is to walk through the problem with the student. After reading the problem, ask the student where they think they would begin. If they aren’t starting in the right spot, point them in the right direction and explain why their starting point wouldn’t work. Continue these same steps by asking the student what they think each subsequent step would be until they have successfully worked through the problem.
During class time, TAs have limited time to spend with each student to address specific questions. If there is a student who is struggling with a major concept or who has a lot of questions, it may be best to encourage them to contact the TA outside of class for help. Students who are struggling can get help from their class TA outside of class through a variety of methods, including office hours, grading, and email.
Office hours are a designated time period for students to seek help from a TA about class material or concepts. This is also one of the primary opportunities for you as a TA to work with students who are performing poorly to help them understand material by adapting explanations to their own learning styles or by utilizing examples that they relate to. For example, visual learners may need a flow chart draw to understand the logic behind a block of code, while an auditory learner may learn better by having the code translated into verbal sentences.
When grading assignments in Canvas with the SpeedGrader, you can leave comments on assignments. These comments can be used to provide brief explanations to students who did poorly on an assignment why they missed points and help direct them to resources to correct their understanding of material. Additionally, these comments can be used to ask students who performed poorly or demonstrated a significant lack of understanding of the material to visit the TA during office hours for help.
Students who are unable to attend office hours, or are uncomfortable attending office hours, may reach out to their TA via Email or question platforms, such as Piazza, if the class is utilizing one. When answering their questions, it is important for the TA to explain concepts and provide links to resources that students can use to further understand the material. This allows students, especially those who are already performing poorly, to develop studying and research skills they can use to solve future problems.
Below is a list of resources provided by UNC Charlotte and CCI to help students who are struggling with concepts or would like additional explanation. These resources are focused on helping students struggling due to academic reasons to improve and understand material. For resources to share with students that are struggling for other reasons, such as personal reasons, refer to Chapter 2- Guiding Students For Success And Well-Being: Relevant For Interacting With All Students. These resources can be shared with the students to offer additional help outside of the TA’s office hours or in class help. Additionally, these resources can help supplement the students’ learning, particularly if one of the reasons they are struggling is because they do not understand material the way it is presented in class.
Undergraduate students can sign up for tutoring at the CCI Tutoring Center for one-on-one help in various CCI classes such as ITSC 1212/13 and ITSC 2214. The list of offered classes and appointment availability can be found at: https://ccitutoring.home.blog.
UNC Charlotte offers a variety of programs, primarily through the University Center for Academic Excellence (UCAE). The programs that are likely to be the most useful to students struggling academically in your course are listed below, a complete list of programs available can be found at: https://ucae.uncc.edu/academic-services. .
The Writing Resource Center offers students, faculty, and staff with assistance with the writing. They can help at any stage of the writing process, including understanding an assignment sheet, drafting an outline, or proofreading a draft. Appointments can be made with the WRC at: https://uncc.mywconline.com.
The UCAE offers tutoring for undergraduate students for specific courses. Students can either make an appointment or reference the drop-in hours at the following link: https://ucae.uncc.edu/academic-support-services/tutoring. Additionally, students can request tutoring for a course they are not enrolled in.
PAL program provides students in supported classes with group study support that is lead by a student who has completed the course selected. Instructions for how students can find the schedule for PAL sessions in supported classes can be found at https://ucae.uncc.edu/academic-support-services/pal-schedule .
The Department of Mathematics and Statistics offers one-on-one tutoring for students enrolled in mathematics courses, regardless of their major. Information about drop-in hours and scheduling an appointment can be found at: https://math.uncc.edu/undergraduate-program-information/tutoring-services.