Academic Integrity Violations

Introduction

Academic integrity is one of the foundations of a University. It is important to maintain an atmosphere that consists of morality, integrity, trust, respect, and mutual responsibility. Integrity ensures educational experience and pursuits of knowledge indeed beneficial to the students. Violating academic integrity principles damages the university's reputation and undermines the educational mission and goals [1], and most importantly, Cheating...Really is Cheating Yourself.

WHAT ARE ACADEMIC INTEGRITY VIOLATIONS?

Cheating is the use of unapproved resources [2, 3].

Examples:

  • Copying answers for an exam or assignment using unauthorized materials.

  • Working on an exam even after the time has ended.

  • Viewing test questions before an exam.

Assisting anyone else in violating academic integrity is considered academic dishonesty [2].

Examples:

  • Giving away answers to others during an exam.

  • Completing assignments for someone.

  • Publishing project online so others can see it.

Using someone else's text without attribution is plagiarism [2].

Examples:

  • Summarizing text without reference.

  • Copying text directly from somewhere and using it without reference.

Fabrication or falsification includes unauthorized creation, alteration, or reporting of text/information/data in academic activities such as projects, assignments, exams etc [2].

Examples:

  • Creating fake data, research results, or procedures, or counterfeiting academic records.

  • Changing answers after an exam has been graded or returned.

  • Altering a grade or other academic record.

  • Providing false excuses for absence.

Why do students cheat?

Societal/Family/Peer Pressures

In a study, Thirty (30) instructors and TAs from CCI, UNC Charlotte, were asked why students cheat; Seventeen (17) out of them (about 57%) mentioned pressures for achieving a specific grade and five (5) specifically mentioned societal or family pressures in getting good grades.

Language Barrier and Cultural Difficulties

International students from other countries have to learn a new language and may find it challenging to adapt to the new culture along with the pressures of grading [4].

Lack of knowledge in prerequisite courses

The study mentioned earlier, Twelve (12) out of 30 (about 40%) stated either the coursework being too difficult or unprepared makes them desperate, leading to cheating.

Workload Pressure, Procrastination, Motivational Issues

The study also showed, time or workload pressures and procrastination can lead students to academic dishonesty, as mentioned by 6 participants (20%). Additionally, students may suffer from motivational issues or don’t want to put in the effort by thinking that a course is “not worth their time.”

How to prevent cheating?

Educate Students on Expectations and Acceptability

Educating students about the expectations is very important. The instructors or TAs should clearly demonstrate what is allowed and what is disallowed. To be more precise, students should be educated about the acceptability of different practices in using resources and assistance.

Discourage Cheating

It is very important to design a course in a way that ensures transparent visibility of the students' progress in assignments or group projects. For example, the author in [5] suggested "… we get students to collaborate on assignments or content on a Wikipedia-style server that they can all edit simultaneously. That's been successful. … Because it's online, the students see an evolving project and can see the group members' work. As staff members, we … can see who's doing work and who's not."

Strategies discussed by instructors to discourage cheating [5] included :

  • Heightened awareness of the consequences of cheating

  • Requiring students to commit to abide by academic integrity policies

  • Observing students working

  • Monitoring work

  • Setting staged assessments

  • Making work visible

  • Requiring students to work in groups

  • Oral presentations

  • Interviewing student

  • Making it too risky to cheat

Reduce the Benefits of Cheating

Joyner, in his work, explained that “preventing collaboration on homework was impossible.” Collaboration and suggested considering homework assignments as “a learning opportunity, without the high stakes that would otherwise motivate dishonesty” [6]. He also suggested proctored exams in order to measure students’ abilities and test how much they have learned from the homework assessments.

Make Cheating Difficult

Sheard et al. discussed in [5] “interviewees agreed that the incidence of cheating is greatly reduced in invigilated situations.” Open book exams could be a very good strategy to reduce cheating. Nevertheless, the assessment needs to be designed in a way that the answer “can’t simply [be found] from the internet” [5].

Empower Students

The author in [5] focuses on empowering students “so as to reduce the likelihood that they would resort to cheating or would want to cheat.” So basically, the author suggested supporting students, building relationships with them, and emphasizing learning rather than just grades.

References:

  1. Code of Student Academic Integrity bu UNC Charlotte. https://legal.uncc.edu/policies/up-407#c1, Accessed 9 Apr. 2021.

  2. Academic Integrity Violations. https://www.chapman.edu/academics/academic-integrity/violations.aspx. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021.

  3. Academic Integrity | Student Conduct & Academic Integrity | UNC Charlotte. https://scai.uncc.edu/academic-integrity. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021.

  4. Dante, Ed. “The shadow scholar: The man who writes your students’ papers tells his story.” The Chronicle of Higher Education 12 (2010).

  5. Sheard, Judy, et al. “Strategies for maintaining academic integrity in first-year computing courses.” Proceedings of the 2017 ACM Conference on Innovation and Technology in Computer Science Education. 2017.

  6. Joyner, David. “A holistic approach to academic integrity in a CS1 MOOC.” Proceedings of Learning with MOOCs IV (2017).

Acknowledgement

I’d like to acknowledge Aileen Benedict who wrote the actual chapter in CCI Handbook. Readers can find detailed writing in Aileen's space (link)