| Year | Past Champions | Scholarship Recipients |
| 2018 | Men's - Catenaccio
Women's - Carli Lloyd
| Amou Mumm - RC Stevens
Ryder Gary - RC Central
Maleah Richter - RC Stevens |
| 2017 | Men's - Dirty Smurfs Women's - Team Carli Lloyd | Jacob Nunez - RC Stevens Kassidy Kirsch - St. Thomas More |
| 2016 | Men's - Dirty Smurfs Women's Team Carli Lloyd | Colton Gehman - Hot Springs Grace Baumgarten - RC Central |
| 2015 | Men's - Dirty Smurfs Women's Team Carli Lloyd | Jacob Sperlich - RC Central Makenzi Miller - RC Stevens |
| 2014 | Men's - Dirty Smufs Women's - Team Awesome | Lane Schroeder - RC Stevens Nicci McGuire - RC Stevens
Lexi Pszanka - RC Stevens |
| 2013 | Men's - P.W.U. United Women's - High Schoolers & Has Beens | Josh Burr - Spearfish McKenzie Wolf - RC Stevens
Morgan Weyer-Coates - RC Central |
| 2012 | Men's - Pawn With Us Women's - The Has Beens | Paul Balderramos - RC Central
Dominic Usera - RC Stevens Breanne Baumann - |
| 2011 | Men's - SSDD Women's - Boobs and Boots | Logan Schaefers - RC Stevens Rachel Kostaneski - RC Stevens
Megan Anderson - RC Stevens |
| 2010 | Men's - McKee's Pub Women's - Rushmore Girls | Carly Borr - RC Stevens
Felician Reimann - RC Stevens |
| 2009 | Men's - Reagan's Mainliners | Ryan Keohane - RC Central
Aaron Foss - RC Stevens |
| 2008 | Men's - | Chris Sabrowski - RC Central Brittany Oehlerking - RC Central |
| 2007 | Men's - | Connor McKee - RC Stevens Ariel Diamond - RC Stevens |
| 2006 | Men's - | Tyler Eisler - RC Central Lisa Johnson - |
| 2005 | Men's - | |
| 2004 | Men's - | |
| 2003 | Men's - | |
| 2002 | Men's - | |
| 2001 | Men's - | |
| 2000 | Men's - Runners Shop | |
| 1999 | Men's - Runners Shop | |
| 1998 | Men's - Billings | |
| 1997 | Men's - Rockers | |
| 1996 | Men's - Rockers | |
| 1995 | Men's - Rockers | |
| 1994 | Men's - RC United Men | |
| 1993 | Men's - RC United Men | |
| 1992 | Men's - RC United Men | |