Arranged topically for modern subjects and then geographically for ancient places, this page contains links to history, chronology, geography, economics, material culture, and ethnicity.
Ligonier Ministries - Reformed Theology - ligonier.org - Organization founded by R.C. Sproul.
Livius.org Articles on ancient history - livius.org
Archaeological Atlas of Antiquity - vici.org - Interactive map of archaeological sites.
Asimov Online - asimovonline.com
"Religion in Asimov's Writings" - Short article by Michael Brummond.
Asimov's Guide to the Bible: The Old and New Testaments (1981, pdf) - holybooks.com - Archive
"Nightfall" (1941) - uni.edu - Archive - Highly acclaimed short story by Isaac Asimov.
"The Relativity of Wrong" - hermiene.net - This essay shows some of Asimov's wit and perhaps the strength of his thoughts. To sum up, with scientific knowledge the question is not whether it is right or wrong, but how wrong is it, and is it good enough for the purposes it is being used? The sciences aren't about truth but truth-likeness. In a word, Verisimilitude.
"The Last Question" (1956) - Archive/multivax.com - Humanity to god and back again.
The Complete Robot (1982) by Isaac Asimov - las.illinois.edu - Collection of short stories about robots and robotics.
Jenkins’ Spoiler-Laden Guide to Isaac Asimov - asimovreviews.net - Reviews of nearly all Asimov's books and short stories, by a Christian no less.
Stoicism: Index - throughablogdarkly.blogspot.com - Reflections on stoicism and modern society by someone who checks all the boxes of 'Secularism'.
Is Atheism Irrational? - bigquestionsonline.com - Kelly J. Clark - "The higher up one is on the Autism Spectrum, the more likely one is to be an atheist."
Differences Between a Psychopath vs Sociopath (2015) by John M. Grohol, Psy.D. Archived original. Updated - psychcentral.com - Christianity provides the grounds for hypocrisy. Atheism provides the grounds for sociopathy. The psychopath may be the perfect combination of the two.
Humanist Manifesto II - americanhumanist.org - “An expression of a living and growing faith” signed by Isaac Asimov among others.
"The Humanist Manifestos (1933, 1973, 1999)" - First Things March 2000 by J. Budziszewski
“Among the Disrupted", (2015) by Leon Wieseltier - Leon Wieseltier helps layout the ground of humanism.
THE NON-ELITE: A BRIEF MEDITATION ON THE NATURE OF ATHEIST HUMANISM - rjosephhoffmann.com - by R. Joseph Hoffmann, an apparently elitist humanist.
Transhumanism (2004) by Francis Fukuyama - philosophy.as.uky.edu
"God in the machine: my strange journey into transhumanism" (2017) by Meghan O'Gieblyn - theguardian.com - Transhumanism has all the trappings of a religion.
McNamee, M. J., & Edwards, S. D. (2006). Transhumanism, medical technology and slippery slopes. Journal of medical ethics, 32(9), 513–518. https://doi.org/10.1136/jme.2005.013789
Once God is out of the equation, politics is the highest 'good', which is why it is so often seen by 'secularists' as a replacement for religion.
"The Charisma of Adolf Hitler" by Laurence Rees - youtube.com - Talk given at the University of Maastricht in 2012. Is the big difference between Communism under Stalin and National Socialism under Hitler merely the charisma of the leader?
What Modern Socialists Don’t Want You To Know About Hitler (2024) interview with Dr. Rainer Zitelmann - youtube.com - The Nazi's didn't call themselves "Nazi". They properly called their movement National Socialism and meant it. "Drawing from his book “Hitler’s National Socialism,” Rainer explains how Hitler’s economic policies blended the planned economy of Stalin’s Soviet Union with social Darwinist beliefs, attempting to harness the benefits of competition toward the single-minded objectives of the state."
The Enchantment of the Arab Mind (July 7, 2025) by Hussein Aboubakr Mansour - mosaicmagazine.com -
"The Islamist was not, in origin, a traditionalist. He was a post-leftist, often born of the revolutionary state, educated in its schools, and fluent in its slogans—but disillusioned by the collapse of its ideology. What he sought was not restoration of pre-revolution but a continuation of the modern saga of revolutionary political salvation, now understood in the existential language of belonging. The Islamist critique of alienation, of Western decadence, of historical fragmentation, all echoed the Heideggerian diagnosis of modernity as the forgetting of Being. The Islamist project wasn’t about a return to Sharia, but the sacralization of a world cleansed of inauthenticity, an existential project to recover the essence of the Muslim self and civilization."
How the Elite rigged Society (and why it’s falling apart) (2025) by David Brooks - youtube.com
The Defining Moment of ARC 2025 by Glen Scrivener - youtube.com - Eloquent and searching commentary of David Brooks' speech by a Christian evangelist.
Why JD Vance Will Lose His Culture War (2025) by Brendan Miller - youtube.com - (34:13) Brenden Miller shows there is a method to the madness, but also that the method of Trumpism is still madness. Links to all Vance footage and other video sources used.
The euro was a big mistake, and Greece is paying the price - vox.com
Enlargement and the euro are two big mistakes that ruined Europe - ft.com
Nobel economics prize winner: ‘The euro was a mistake’ - euractiv.com
Joseph Stiglitz: 'The EU's monetary union was the mistake' - telegraph.co.uk
Experts Agree: The Euro Was A Mistake In The First Place. Now, To Abolish It Perhaps... - forbes.com - Yes, even the uber-Progressive and religious Keynesian Paul Krugman insists it was a mistake.
Europe’s Rising Far Right: A Guide to the Most Prominent Parties - nytimes.com - Shows the mixture of anti-Euro and protectionism in nationalistic parties.
The Future of Woke w/Eric Kaufmann (2024) by Coleman Hughes and Erik Kaufmann - youtube.com (1 hr 10 mins) - Nuanced politically center and center-right discussion.
Crash Course on Critical Race Theory - theologymom.com
What Is Critical Race Theory, and Why Is It Under Attack? By Stephen Sawchuk (May 18, 2021) - edweek.org - Center left summary of CRT.
Cantu, E. & Jussim, L (2022). Microaggressions, questionable science, and free speech. Texas Law Review.
Religious Landscape Study: Atheists - pewforum.org
"The Reproductive Benefits of Religious Affilliation" (2009) by Michael Blume - blume-religionswissenschaft.de - Chapter 8 of E. Voland, W. Schiefenhövel (eds.), The Biological Evolution of Religious Mind and Behavior, The Frontiers Collection, DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-00128-4_8, Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2009
"How Is't With Thy Religion, Pray? Selection of Religiosity Among Individuals and Groups" (2015) by Michael Blume - Chapter 3 in The Attraction of Religion, Pages 63-71. Slone, D.J., Van Slyke, J.A. (Eds.): Bloomsbury.
Will your grandchildren be Jews? - simpletoremember.com - Population projections for American Jews. Only the Orthodox and Ultra-Orthodox will be identifiable as Jews in 4 generations.
Why the Amish Population Is Exploding - citylab.com - "The number of Amish people in the U.S. has doubled in the last 20 years, and the sect is spreading across the United States."
The Problem of Christians Becoming Atheists - randalrauser.com - Conversation with John Marriott on Christianity and atheism based on his book, A Recipe for Disaster.
The Solution to Christians Becoming Atheists (Part 2) - Focus people to a "Mere Christianity" basing necessary beliefs primarily on the creeds rather than esoteric scripture interpretations.
The Hidden Truth About Our Collapsing Birth Rates (2024) Mads Larsen - youtube.com - Norway is down to 1.4 children per female. This will cause a generational decrease of 1/3 and an increasingly older population, leading to economic and social decline. Mads Larsen may be the most patient man alive. He understands the personal attacks against him, and canceling is the norm at the beginning of a debate. He believes that if he perseveres, the discussion will eventually reach rationality.
OPPORTUNITY, RESPONSIBILITY, AND SECURITY: A CONSENSUS PLAN FOR REDUCING POVERTY AND RESTORING THE AMERICAN DREAM (2015) - brookings.edu, also from aei.org - 15 expert researchers from across the political spectrum look at poverty.
The Backstory of the AEI-Brookings Poverty Report (2015) by Jonathan Haidt - heterodoxacademy.org Archive
The AEI/Brookings report: How did we do it? (2015) by Lawrence Mead - aei.org
Chapter 2: The Facts - The most celebrated part of the report is this chapter. Primarily implicates generational poverty with the rise in single-parent families.
Chapter 3: Family - The main fix.
The Google Memo: What Does the Research Say About Gender Differences? (2017) by Sean Stevens - heterodoxacademy.com - Collection of relevant research to the Google Memo on diversity, which caused the immediate firing of its author, James Damore.
"Retrospectives: Eugenics and Economics in the Progressive Era" by Thomas C. Leonard - princeton.edu - Journal of Economic Perspectives, Volume 19, Number 4, Fall 2005, Pages 207–224 - Excellent summary highlighting "race suicide" and how eugenics was so attractive to progressives of the time.
"American Immigration, Fertility, and Race Suicide at the Turn of the Century" by Miriam King and Steven Ruggles - hist.umn.edu - Journal of Interdisciplinary History, xx:3 (Winter I990), 347-369.
Image Archive on the American Eugenics Movement - eugenicsarchive.org
Eugenic Sterilization Laws - Creation of sterilization laws from Harry Laughlin's model.
Kennedy-Shaffer, L. (2023). Teaching the Difficult Past of Statistics to Improve the Future. Journal of Statistics and Data Science Education, 32(1), 108–119. https://doi.org/10.1080/26939169.2023.2224407
"Harry Hamilton Laughlin (1880-1943)" by Rachel Gur-Arie - embryo.asu.edu
The Pivot of Civilization by Margaret Sanger (1922) - gutenberg.org - Introduction by H.G. Wells.
G.K. Chesterton was one of the early opponents of eugenics
"Lecture 36: Eugenics and Other Evils" by Dale Ahlquist - chesterton.org
Eugenics and Other Evils by G. K. Chesterton - gutenburg.org
GK Chesterton "Our Notebook" The illustrated London News 1909 September 18th - iln.org.uk - Article influenced Gandhi who had it reprinted.
The surprising downsides of being clever - bbc.com by David Robson
The Nobel Disease: When Intelligence Fails To Protect Against Irrationality - skepticalinquirer.org
“Body art, deviance, and American college students” - drjkoch.org - Koch, Jerome R., Alden E. Roberts, Myrna L. Armstrong, and Donna C. Owen. 2010. Social Science Journal 47(1): 151-161.
Select Publications & Papers - rutgers.edu
Cantu, E. & Jussim, L (2022). Microaggressions, questionable science, and free speech. Texas Law Review.
Will your grandchildren be Jews? - simpletoremember.com - Population projections for American Jews.
Jewish Concepts: The Seven Noachide Laws - jewishvirtuallibrary.com - Seven laws derived from Adam and Noah that apply to all of humanity.
Do Not Deny God
Do Not Blaspheme God
Do Not Murder
Do Not Engage in Incestuous, Adulterous, or Homosexual Relationships.
Do Not Steal
Do Not Eat of a Live Animal
Establish Courts/Legal System to Ensure Law Obedience
There Never Will Be a Palestinian State. So What’s Next? (2025) By Elliott Abrams - ideas.tikvah.org
Ecstasy and Amnesia in the Gaza Strip. (Nov. 6, 2023) by Shany Mor - mosaicmagazine.com - A compelling thesis that brings into focus the impossible relationship of the Palestinians with Israel.
The Failed Concepts That Brought Israel to October 7 (Oct. 7, 2024) by Shany Mor - mosaicmagazine.com - A look at the evils within and without. Responses: Evelyn Gordon, Rafi DeMogge, Gadi Taub, Cole S. Aronson and Avi Bell, and Amnon Lord. Final response: The Policies of October 6 Kept Israel Safe—Until They Didn’t
What Is “the Jews”? (2023) by Joshua Abramson Cohen - bostonreview.net - Review of Daniel Boyarin's book The No-State Solution: A Jewish Manifesto. "Daniel Boyarin makes the seemingly paradoxical proposal that in order to end Zionism, Jewishness should be defined as nationhood."
Freeland League - heldring.com
Michael C. Astour: A Biographical Essay by James J. Weingartner - siue.edu PDF - Michael Astour was a highly influential and respected Near East historian with an interesting and often tumultuous life prior to his academic years.
also related Harvard Can’t Fight Dirty if Its Hands Aren’t Clean (3/27/2025)
Why Dostoevsky Loved Humanity and Hated the Jews (2023) by Gary Saul Morson - mosaicmagazine.com - An essay uncovering the stereotypes and prejudices of the literary giant.
WHAT WE BELIEVE ABOUT ISRAEL - centerforisrael.com - A healthy position statement relating "Gentile" Christians to Jews and Messianic Jews. References:
Gentiles and Jews in Christ - Ephesians 2
Romans 9:3-5 - For I could wish that I myself were cursed and cut off from Christ for the sake of my people, those of my own race, the people of Israel. Theirs is the adoption to sonship; theirs the divine glory, the covenants, the receiving of the law, the temple worship and the promises. Theirs are the patriarchs, and from them is traced the human ancestry of the Messiah, who is God over all, forever praised! Amen.
Romans 11:23-29 - As far as the gospel is concerned, they are enemies for your sake; but as far as election is concerned, they are loved on account of the patriarchs, for God’s gifts and his call are irrevocable.
1 Corinthians 7:17-20 - Nevertheless, each person should live as a believer in whatever situation the Lord has assigned to them, just as God has called them. This is the rule I lay down in all the churches. Was a man already circumcised when he was called? He should not become uncircumcised. Was a man uncircumcised when he was called? He should not be circumcised. Circumcision is nothing and uncircumcision is nothing. Keeping God’s commands is what counts. Each person should remain in the situation they were in when God called them.
Paul as Jew and directions for gentiles - Acts 21:17-26
Banning Israeli Food Truck in Philadelphia Jun 23, 2021 by Dr. Yvette Alt Miller - aish.com - Modern anti-Semitic act with a discussion of the difference between the new anti-Semitism and legitimate criticism of Israel.
The Best Israel Conversation You've Ever Heard (2025) by Major Andrew Fox and Triggernometry - youtube.com
Hamas Efforts, Assisted By UNRWA, To Seize Control Of Humanitarian Aid Entering Gaza Strip (2024) - memri.org - How UNWRA and Hamas collaborate on aid distribution. Why doesn't UN security guard UNWRA aid distribution? Hamas needs to control the aid to stay in power, and UNWRA is happily complicit in the survival of Hamas.
Hamas’s Human Shield Strategy in Gaza (2025) by Andrew Fox and Salo Aizenberg - henryjacksonsociety.org PDF - "Since 7 October 2023, the UN has issued 367 reports that are filed under the subject of “Gaza Strip”. A search of these reports reveals that the UN has rarely acknowledged and never asserted the use by Hamas of “human shields”. The phenomenon of “human shields” has only been mentioned four times, in each case in only a single sentence, as either an “allegation”, an Israeli “claim” or an unverified “report” that this practice occurred. The UN has never dedicated a single paragraph, let alone an entire report, to analysing how Hamas has fought the war in Gaza."
Hamas Casualty Reports are a Tangle of Technical Problems (April 2025) by Professors Lewi Stone and Gregory Rose - henryjacksonsociety.org PDF - "The two Hamas casualty data offices, the MoH and the GMO, generated different narratives that regularly contradicted each other, as we show. In effect, they allowed Hamas to convey very different versions of the war, as needed. The GMO painted a lurid picture of indiscriminate killing of women and children by Israel, supposedly supported by the MoH but often inconsistent with its datasets."
Questionable Counting: Analysing the Death Toll from the Hamas-Run Ministry of Health in Gaza (December 2024) by Andrew Fox - henryjacksonsociety.org PDF - "This report raises serious concerns that the Gaza MoH figures have been overstated. The data behind their figures contains natural deaths, deaths from before this conflict began and deaths of those killed by Hamas itself; it contains no mention of Hamas combatant fatalities; and it overstates the number of women and children killed."
Gaza Demographics and UNRWA - ChatGPT 7/28/2025 PDF
ChatGPT Coming to Terms with True Gazan Starvation = 147 - 7/29/2025 PDF
Media Bias - from the original fry, Perplexity AI, 8/10/2025 PDF
Refried Gazan Starvation - Perplexity AI 8/13/2025 PDF
While we are at it, Shany Mor is a breath of fresh, crisp moderation in this increasingly divisive and polarized world. Finally, someone who can eloquently and consistently demonstrate thinking beyond the bumper sticker. Collected here are some links and essays:
The Golan Heights and the Depths of Hypocrisy (2019) - tabletmag.com - The ‘norms’ invoked to challenge Israel’s claims to the Golan are selectively applied, totally contradictory, and would actually invalidate Palestinian territorial claims. Other than that, they make perfect sense.
The Return of the Peace Processors (2021) - mosaicmagazine.com
Response: Stuck on the Wrong Road to Peace (2021) - Final response to two responders - Michael Doran and Michael Koplow.
Maybe Shocked, But Not Surprised (Oct. 16, 2023) - medium.com
Ecstasy and Amnesia in the Gaza Strip. (Nov. 6, 2023) by Shany Mor - mosaicmagazine.com Print. - A compelling thesis that brings into focus the impossible relationship of the Palestinians with Israel.
A Special Dictionary for Israel (2024) - mosaicmagazine.com Print.
The Failed Concepts That Brought Israel to October 7 (Oct. 7, 2024) by Shany Mor - mosaicmagazine.com - A look at the evils within and without.
Catholic Encyclopedia of 1917- newadvent.org - A subtle, comprehensive and interesting snapshot of the world from the Catholic point of view - after papal infallibility, but before the resolution of the Vatican State, and well before the liberalizing chaos unleashed by Vatican II.
The Fathers of the Church - newadvent.org - Collected works of the Church Fathers, Church Councils and some of the Christian apocryphal works.
Theopedia - theopedia.com - Encyclopedia of Theology written from Evangelical view point.
On Genesis: Two Books on Genesis Against the Manichees and On the Literal Interpretation of Genesis: An Unfinished Book - English translations of two early books by St. Augustine. The second of which builds the theme in Galileo's Letter to Princess Christina.
Voddie Baucham: The World, the Flesh, and the Devil (2015) - youtube.com - 58:31 mins - Presentation of the Gospel based in the Reform tradition using Ephesians 2.
Ligonier Ministries - Reformed Theology - ligonier.org - Organization founded by R.C. Sproul.
Orthodox Church in America - oca.org
Volume II - Worship, The Sacraments, Funeral - oca.org
"Here a God, There a God: An Examination of the Divine in Ancient Mesopotamia" (2013) by Michael Hundley - academia.edu Altorientalische Forschungen 40 (2013) 1, 68–107 - Presents an "Aspective model" of diety.
"In fact, there is no simple answer to even the most basic question: what is a god?"
Mesopotamians themselves make little attempt to systematically unravel its complexities. As such, modern scholarly attempts to do so in some ways go against the grain of ANE thinking and thus are somewhat artificial.
For them, inconsistencies, which may simply result from the limits of human cognition, are far preferable to consistent yet consistently restrictive categories. In other words, for them, it is better to allow the deity to be practically limitless even if that limitlessness baffles the mind than to confine the deity to the limited boundaries that are a necessary product of the human mind.
2 gods in a single name: "It is probable that in combination the first deity is “described as like, or equivalent to, or incorporating the qualities of, the second god; Assur-Adad, in other words, should probably be understood to mean, Assur in the form in which he resembles Adad (probably as a storm god) and not vice versa”
General Considerations on Main Concerns in the Religion of Ancient Mesopotamia (2000) by Pietro Mander - academia.edu S. Graziani ed., Studi sul Vicino Oriente Antico dedicato alla memopria di Luigi Cagni, Istituto Universitario Orientale, Dip. Studi Asiatici, Series Minor LXI, Napoli 2000: vol 2 pp. 635-664 - A consideration of Sumerian religion by axis: An, Enlil, and Enki would be on the vertical axis with the temple cities of Nippur (Enlil) and Eridu (Enki) forming a North-South axis across Ninhursag. The sun, moon, and planets - all perceived as major gods - provide an East-West axis.
Gods and Scholars: Mapping the Pantheon in Early Mesopotamia (2011) by Gonzalo Rubio - academia.edu
(p. 105) Early Dynastic Sumerian and Semitic mix from Ebla (ARET 5.6 i 6–ii 2) and Abū Ṣalābīḫ (IAS 326 i 8–13):
‘Prince Ea, god of rejoicing, burning light, ierce shining, splendor (?) of Apsû, leader among the Anunna gods’.
Ancient DNA Is Rewriting Human (and Neanderthal) History - theatlantic.com - 2018 interview giving the new basics. 9000 ya, farmers replaced hunter-gatherers in Europe. 5000 ya people from the steppe above the Caspian Sea move into Europe and replace much of the earlier population.
What ancient DNA says about us - newhumanist.org.uk - Reich said, “I expect that no intellectually elegant and emotionally satisfying molecular explanation for behavioural modernity will ever be found." - author: "...he is saying that the famous search for “the gene that made us human” is futile."
Monotheism of the Ancient Hebrews: Evolved, Invented, Stolen or Revealed? - jewsforjesus.org
Monotheism - jewishvirtuallibrary.org - Explores the idea of monotheism and how it uniquely differs from both polytheism and pantheism.
"Religious Evolution" by Robert N. Bellah - hartfordinstitute.com - American Sociological Review, Vol. 29, No. 3 (Jun., 1964), pp. 358-374
"The Evolution of Religion" by Charles Mathewes - the-american-interest.com
"Hunter-Gatherers and the Origins of Religion" by Peoples, Duda, & Marlowe - ncbi.nlm.nih.gov - A study inferring back to the religious characteristics of hunter-gatherers finding that, "the trait “high gods” stands apart, suggesting that belief in a single creator deity can emerge in a society regardless of other aspects of its religion."
Forms of God, Forming God: A Typology of Divine Anthropomorphism in the Pentateuch (2011) - academia.edu - Knafl, Katherine. Inadequacy of Immanent and Transcendent categories, pgs. 22-23:
All four sources (and H), reflect a belief that God can locate either in heaven or on earth and none are concerned with the philosophical problem that to assert divine presence in one locale is to imply divine absence from another (if God is on earth, he cannot be in heaven) or that God is “wholly other” and therefore has nothing in common with earthly existence.
The Homeland: In the footprints of Early Europeans - homeland.ku.dk - Map timeline showing date and location of certain ancient people keyed to certain anthropologically defined groups.
Map of Nubian Complex occurrences in Northeast Africa and Arabia. Distribution of Nubian Complex sites and findspots are depicted, as well as MSA/MP sites with human remains. To account for shoreline configuration ∼100 ka, sea level is adjusted to −40 m below present levels. (Figure 1, Rose et. al., 2011)
First Peoples | PBS | Out of Africa (2015) Jeff Rose - youtube.com (8:09) - Oman research finding Nubian points along an internal Arabian river basin instead of along the present-day coast.
Rose et. al., (2011) The Nubian Complex of Dhofar, Oman: An African Middle Stone Age Industry in Southern Arabia. PLOS ONE
Nubian Complex sites include: Jebel Urayf (1), Jebel Naquah (2), Nazlet Khater (3), Abydos (4), Makhadma (5), Taramsa Hill (6), Sodmein Cave (7), Kharga Oasis (8), Bir Tarfawi (9), Bir Sahara (10), Abu Simbel (11), Jebel Brinikol (12), 1035 (13), 1038 (14), Sai Island (15), Gorgora Rockshelter (16), K'One (17), Hargeisa (18), Shabwa (19), Wadi Wa'shah (20), Aybut Al Auwal (21), Aybut Ath Thani (22), Mudayy As Sodh (23), and Jebel Sanoora (24)
"Out of Arabia" and the Middle-Upper Palaeolithic transition in the southern Levant (2014) By Jeff Rose, Anthony Marks - Academia.edu
AKA: Ur-Schatt River Valley
New Light on Human Prehistory in the Arabo-Persian Gulf Oasis (2010) by Jeffrey Rose - core.ac.uk CORE Reader PDF - The author hypothesizes that people from the more arid hinterlands descended into Gulf Oasis as the earth's sea water became locked up in glaciers during the last ice age. It is in this oasis present from ~75,000 to ~8000 years ago and the following crucible of its flooding over 3000 years that farming combined with urban culture as people were forced north into the more arid Mesopotamia. Even apart from the hypothesis, Rose presents a readable summary of generally accepted research.
Incredible Human Journey, Episode 1, Arabia Sequence (BBC Worldwide Edition) (2009) Jeff Rose - youtube.com (9:42) UK Version - Segment of The Incredible Human Journey with Rose's hypothesis of Out of Africa and into the Gulf Oasis.
Map of southwest Asia depicting exposed landscapes during the Last Glacial Maximum as well as ancient and modern drainage systems. Numbers indicate Pleistocene and Early Holocene sites. (Figure 2, Rose, 2010).
Banning, E. (2023). Paradise Found or Common Sense Lost? Göbekli Tepe’s Last Decade as a Pre-Farming Cult Centre. Open Archaeology, 9(1), 20220317. https://doi.org/10.1515/opar-2022-0317 - Makes the argument that Göbekli Tepe is a village early in the hunter-gatherer-to-farming transition in contradiction to first interpretations as a purely ceremonial center. Therefore hunter-gatherer vs. sedentary farming dichotomies are inappropriate as also the fad of the common interpretation of religion.
Also known as Shengavitian, Karaz, Pulur, Yanik, Early Transcaucasian, and Khirbet Kerak
Paléorient, 2014, vol. 40, n°2. The Kura-Araxes culture from the Caucasus to Iran, Anatolia and the Levant: Between unity and diversity. - 14 articles on the Kura-Araxes
Rethinking the Kura-Araxes Genesis (2014) - persee.fr PDF Antonio Sagona
"The Chaff-Faced tradition [early 4th mill. BC] reflected the pre-Uruk connections that ran along a north-south axis, extending from Syrian-Anatolian borderlands around the Van basin through the Southern Caucasus all the way to Maikop. This far-flung system was no doubt driven by the search for metals and semi-precious stones to cater to the tastes of the emerging elite." (pg. 40)
"Turning to the bearers of the Sioni tradition, we find that they had little major effect on societies beyond their heartland in the Southern Caucasus. Theirs was a native tradition concentrated at a small number of sites." (pg 41)
Chaffed-Faced ware can be found with Sioni ware in various proportions.
KA I complex "emerged ca 3500/3400 BC sharply and decisively from this cultural milieu, comprising a strong mix of Syro-Mesopotamian influences and local developments." (pg. 42)
The Early Trans-Caucasian Culture in Iran: Perspectives and problems (2014) - persee.fr - Geoffrey D. Summers, Paléorient Année 2014 40-2 pp. 155-168
It is unlikely that Godin Tepe is one of the earlier ETC site. Fixing of chronology is very uncertain due to few secure radiocarbon dates.
4200 kya event? "Although the answer is no, it is perhaps not completely inconceivable that the break between ETC II and III seen at Yanik Tepe, and postulated at Haftavan Tepe and elsewhere, might be some reflection of this major, widespread, natural event."
ETC immigration in the Urmia Basin and central Zagros Mtns. is to abandoned or new sites around 3000-2900 BC. The speculation is that ETC migration took place during the "Uruk collapse" and that collapse was related to wider disruption than just Mesopotamia proper.
One of the open questions is contact with existing populations. There is no evidence of violence, nor is evidence of any associations at all.
ETC "did not possess formal developed religion centred around temples and priesthoods, as was the 3rd millennium norm in Mesopotamia and North Syria."
No destructions ending the ETC have been reported from the Urmia or Van region. It appears sites were deserted.
The spatial organization of craft production at the Kura-Araxes settlement of Köhne Shahar in northwestern Iran: A zooarchaeological approach (2020) - journals.plos.org - Samei S, Alizadeh K (2020) PLoS ONE 15(3): e0229339. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0229339 - Evidences showed an absence of an entrenched social hierarchy:
No one structure stands out.
Locally organized workspaces. No evidence of top-down control of the workspace.
Household appears to be the base unit of production.
"These economies underwent a major shift in the early third millennium BCE, a period that is contemporaneous with the habitation of KSH IV–V. In this period, the first KA settlements were abandoned and new settlements were founded in formerly unoccupied areas within the southern Caucasus [83,84]. This shift was accompanied by the appearance of a mosaic of local ceramic styles that replaced the more uniform material culture of the earlier KA tradition [83]."
Chapter 9: Explaining the Kura-Araxes (2017) - google.com or Academia.edu - Mitchell S. Rothman in Fitful Histories and Unruly Publics
Soviet archeology following the socialist archeology of V. Gordon Childe limited the scope and collection of artifacts due to its preconceived conclusions.
"Publishing a small sample of typical artifacts was therefore sufficient. Ecofacts such as plant and animal remains were not so important. Certainly, publishing the full details of collections was unnecessary. Some in the Soviet Bloc over-layered this artifactual analysis with a Soviet Marxist viewpoint, ultimately derived from Morgan and the anthropological Progressivists as adopted by Marx and Engels. Change was essentially about the transition from the classless society of tribal peoples to the tributary and then capitalist property-owning classes of the state."
Early Bronze Age migrants and ethnicity in the Middle Eastern mountain zone (2015) - pnas.org - Mitchell S. Rothman PNAS July 28, 2015 112 (30) 9190-9195 >>
(Figure 1, Rothman 2015)
The Genomic Formation of South and Central Asia - biorxiv.org -
Figure 1 -
Figure 2 - Modeling Results - Showing Anatolian and Iranian farmers mixing in an Iran C Cline that heavily contributes to Steppe EMBA Cline around 3000 BC of which the Yamnaya and Afanasievo are genetic offshoots. The EMBA Cline heavily contributes to the Steppe MLBA Cloud (c. 2300 BC).
Figure 4 - A Tale of Two Subcontinents - Simultaneous expansion of Near East agriculture East and West with time contours. This is happening parallel to the East and West expansion of Yamnaya pastoralists.
In Honor of Ernest R. Lacheman on His Seventy-fifth Birthday ..., Volume 2 - books.google.com - Two articles mention Hamazi:
Astour, Michael Semites and Hurrians in Northern Transtigris: "Hamazi was located not in northern Iran but close enough to the Sumero-Akkadian heartland to be included in the Sumerian King List as the seat of a dynasty, inserted between the Second Dynasty of Kish and the Second Dynasty of Uruk."
Is There Evidence of Abraham's Revolution? - chabad.org
Archi, A. (2015). A royal seal from Ebla (17th cent. B.C.) with hittite hieroglyphic symbols. Orientalia, 84(1), 18-28.
-Damu is common in the name-giving of Ebla of the 3rd millennium, and which was still in use in the dynasty of the early second millennium (21)
15th century Hurrian Epic of Freeing, "And with them I will tell of the young lady Ishara, skilful in speaking, a goddess renowned for (her) wisdom."
damu is the term for "blood" and "kin" in Ebla, rather referring to the god Damu.
Seven out of the last ten kings had a name with -Damu. 24 out 51 "sons of the king", and 9 out of 31 "dsughters of the king" of the last three kings have names with -Damu. (22)
Cities in the Book of Joshua - wikipedia.org - The book of Joshua lists nearly 400 different cities and towns in the areas the tribes of Israel were taking. This table compiles information about them.
High-precision radiocarbon dating and historical biblical archaeology in southern Jordan (2008) - pnas.org - Chronology establishing Solomon's mines as being active well before and during the time of Solomon in contradiction to minimalist assumptions. Thomas E. Levy et al. PNAS October 28, 2008 105 (43) 16460-16465; https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0804950105
The Iron Age Pottery from Khirbat en-Nahas, Jordan: A Preliminary Study - levlab.ucsd.edu -
Sea Peoples - wikipedia.com - Good summary of names and records for the Sea Peoples.
Ancient DNA sheds light on the genetic origins of early Iron Age Philistines (2019) - advances.sciencemag.org - Philistines sample from Ashkelon likely came from Crete (“Crete_Odigitria_BA”) or Sardinia in the early Iron Age, but mixed with the existing population to the point that the European portion of the Philistine genetic signal was no longer detectable in the later Iron Age population. In comparison, LBA samples matched 60% Levant_ChL and ~40% Iran_ChL as expected. The Iran_ChL admixture is an increase over EBA.
Iron Age 1 samples mitochondrial DNA: T2c1c, H92, I1, T1a1. Y-DNA: J, R1.
Iron Age 2 samples mitochondrial DNA: H2c, H4a1c, JT. Y-DNA: BT, L.
Discussed at: Indo-european.eu,
Khirbet Qeiyafa in the Shephelah - academia.edu - Colloquium papers regarding the Khirbet Qeiyafa excavation which has several finds that have challenged minimalist interpretations of archaeology. Khirbet Qeiyafa was an Iron Age IIA fortified borderland city that only existed for about 50 years before destroyed. By location it should be Philistine given that it is only 12 km from Gath - the largest Philistine city of that time - but there are several markers showing that it is not. It could be Judahite or another unprovenanced group. The casemate style wall construction could only be compared to later Judahite or Edomite construction making this the earliest Iron Age attestation of an organized kingdom such as that described in the Bible with Saul and David. A large sherd of pottery with Proto-Canaanite writing may or may not be in Hebrew, but it is in some Hebrew like dialect closely related to Canaanite. Some observations:
Two model shrines that would house a goddess idol are also much discussed. At least one of these shrines would be for Inanna/Ishtar. Are these shrines the biblical Asherah?
A Finely Resolved Phylogeny of Y Chromosome Hg J Illuminates the Processes of Phoenician and Greek Colonizations in the Mediterranean - Supplemental text From Discussion:
"First, there is little evidence of sudden diversification between 15 and 5 kya, a period of likely population increase and pressure for range expansion, due to the Agricultural revolution in the Fertile Crescent." - That is, Hg J did not migrate with the farmers very much 9000 years ago.
"Second, within each subclade, lineages currently sampled in Turkey do not show up as preferentially ancestral." - That is, there is quite a bit of mixing of J within Anatolia.
"Of the internal clades, only J1-M267 and J2b-M12 displayed the same growth phase at approximately 5 kya." - Growth and expansion primarily during the Bronze Age.
"The increase in frequency and radiation of the J1-P58 lineage is evident in the clustering of subjects from Middle East and Western Arabian Peninsula in this clade." - Corresponds exactly to Shem. They regard this as a marker for Phoenicians.
"The ages of the three lineages [within J2a-L397] (2.0–3.0 kya) are compatible with the beginning of the Greek colonial period, in the 8th century BCE." - Greek branches found in Italy, Cyprus, and Crete.
Genetic origins of the Minoans and Mycenaeans (2017) by Iosif Lazaridis et al. - nature.com - Discussed by indo-european.eu, sciencemag.org -
"This analysis showed that all Bronze Age populations from the Aegean and Anatolia are consistent with deriving most (approximately 62–86%) of their ancestry from an Anatolian Neolithic-related population (Table 1). However, they also had a component (approximately 9–32%) of ‘eastern’ (Caucasus/Iran-related) ancestry. It was previously shown that this type of ancestry was introduced into mainland Europe via Bronze Age pastoralists from the Eurasian steppe, who were a mix of both eastern European hunter–gatherers and populations from the Caucasus and Iran; our results show that it also arrived on its own, at least in the Minoans, without eastern European hunter–gatherer ancestry. This ancestry need not have arrived from regions east of Anatolia, as it was already present during the Neolithic in central Anatolia…"
Ancient Mesopotamia: This History, Our History - mesopotamia.lib.uchicago.edu - Interactive learning with museum artifacts.
The Oracc Project List - oracc.museum.upenn.edu - ORACC stands for Open Richly Annotated Cuneiform Corpus which are several projects with translating and understanding all the varieties of cuneiform texts: Sumerian, Akkadian, Ugaritic, etc.
Ancient Mesopotamian Beliefs in the Afterlife (2014) by M. Choksi - ancient.eu
"The Tribe as a Unit of Subsistence: Nomadic Pastoralism in the Middle East" by Emmanuel Marx - American Anthropologist (1977)
The Flood Story, Segment D - Zi-ud-sura is settled "in an overseas country, in the land Dilmun, where the sun rises." That would be on the East shore of the Persian Gulf - Elam or Marhashi.
The Early Transcaucasian phenomenon in structural-systemic perspective: Cuisine, craft and economy (2014) - Understanding Kura-Araxes Culture with relationship to Uruk.
The key problem that hampers understanding this relationship is "the deep and unexplained conservatism" in material culture and social organization of the Kura-Araxes. Why did they not assimilate Uruk's culture?
Maybe it is the other way around. The Uruk culture maybe the outlier. As Joshua Mark notes:
...advances of Mesopotamia’s Early Dynastic Period differed from Egypt’s in significant ways, notably in that Mesopotamia – even under the rule of Sargon or later empires – was never the cohesive ethnic or political entity Egypt was and the kinds of cultural development cited for this era were not as uniform as they were in Egypt. The city-states of Sumer were, for much of their history, each independently governed – not united under the reign of a single king as in the case of Egyptian government – and so a city like Uruk or Ur might have developed some important cultural advance which was not shared – at least not readily – with others.
Was Eridu The First City in Sumerian Mythology? by Peeter Espak - academia.edu
Zaina, Federico (2020) The Urban Archaeology of early Kish: 3rd Millenium BCE Levels at Tell Ingharra. OrientLab Series Major Vol. 5 https://www.orientlab.net/pubs/
The Sumerians: Their History, Culture, and Character (1963) by Samuel Noah Kramer - oi.uchicago.edu - A readable introduction to Sumerian culture and texts by one of the leading Sumerian translators, with many comparatives to biblical topics pointed out.
Hebrew Shem = Sumer, pgs. 297-299
Ancient Near Eastern gods Enki and Ea: diachronical analysis of texts and images from the earliest sources to the Neo-Sumerian period (2006) by Peeter Espak - dspace.ut.ee (pdf) - Source page - Technical but readable Masters dissertation, 157 pages.
(28) ki(g) in Enki could be understood as "favour," "benevolence" or "love". Several Enki and West Semitic El equivalences and parallels.
(31- ) Ea etymology if Sumerian is literally "House of Water." Probably Semitic origin from the proto Semitic root *hyy "to live" used to describe spring fed or running water.
(38) "Sumerian Enki and Semitic Ea can not be seen as denoting a divine concept from a certain exclusive area or linguistic group. Rather they are concepts in continuous development and change and the main core of their nature is represented in some way or another in every religion of wider Near East and bordering regions."
(66) "A bilingual lexical list from Ebla mentions Enki after Enlil. Enki is translated as hayyu(m)."
(73) Me is symbolically associated with trees. "trees, orchards; the me-s of Ea." In the greater context it appears the goddess of writing Nisaba has stacked written tablets upon each other so that they symbolically represent trees of written divine command - the me-s of Ea.
SHINAR. (1906) By: Emil G. Hirsch, George A. Barton - jewishencyclopedia.com -
Sources of Early Akkadian Literature (SEAL) - seal.huji.ac.il - A Text Corpus of Babylonian and Assyrian Literary Texts from the 3rd and 2nd Millennia BCE.
Ishtar and Izdubar (1884) by Leonidas Le Cenci Hamilton - sacred-texts.com - Early translation of the Izdubar/Gligamesh epic with embellishments and reconstructions before further texts were found.
The Chaldean Account of Genesis (1876) by George Smith - sacred-texts.com also amazon.com - Account of the Izdubar/Gilgamesh epic from the main person responsible for finding it.
The Sargon Geography from Mesopotamian Cosmic Geography By Wayne Horowitz, pgs. 67-95 - books.google.com - Huge relation of place names including Edom and Moab. Believed to have been compiled from older sources in the first millennium BC.
Map of the Assyrian Empire - jewishvirtuallibrary.org - Useful map of max extents with vassals and viceroys.
https://oi.uchicago.edu/sites/oi.uchicago.edu/files/uploads/shared/docs/ancient_records_assyria1.pdf -
https://oi.uchicago.edu/sites/oi.uchicago.edu/files/uploads/shared/docs/ancient_records_assyria2.pdf -
Babylonian Topographical Texts online (BTTo) - oracc.museum.upenn.edu/btto/
UNESCO: Babylon -
Pedersén, O. (2011). Excavated and Unexcavated Libraries in Babylon. In E. Cancik-Kirschbaum, M. Ess & J. Marzahn (Ed.), Babylon: Wissenskultur in Orient und Okzident (pp. 47-68). Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110222128.47
‘KASSITES’ by Ran Zadok in Encyclopaedia Iranica Online - referenceworks.brillonline.com - Realistic summary of what is known about the origin of the Kassites.
Ran Zadok. ‘KASSITES’. In Encyclopaedia Iranica Online, edited by Trustees of Columbia University in the City of New York. Accessed May 10, 2023. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/2330-4804_EIRO_COM_1514.
"Amarna Ša-an-har-ra, Ša-an-ha-ar (from Mitanni and Alashia), Hittite Ša-an-ha-ra(-az), Egyptian Śngr, Old Testament Šnʿr < *Šamǵara (Old Babylonian gentilic Samharû), presumably a Kassite tribe, gave its name to Babylonia while it was occupied by the Kassites."
Canaan
Persia
Roman
http://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/home.html
Sexidecimal System
Jordan River Valley
The Walls of Jericho: An Alternative Interpretation
http://www.biblewalks.com/Sites/JordanJericho.html
Gilgal Argaman - biblewalks.com
Ancient DNA Is Rewriting Human (and Neanderthal) History - theatlantic.com - 2018 interview giving the new basics.
What ancient DNA says about us - newhumanist.org.uk - Reich said, “I expect that no intellectually elegant and emotionally satisfying molecular explanation for behavioural modernity will ever be found." - "...he is saying that the famous search for “the gene that made us human” is futile."
http://www.biblewalks.com/index.html
http://archlgy.haifa.ac.il/staff/zertal.htm
Modern Israel and Palestine
"The Nakba Obsession" by SOL STERN - The Palestinian national narrative is the biggest obstacle to peace in the Middle East. City Journal, Summer 2010
Qumran
http://www.biblewalks.com/Sites/Qumran.html
Gezer
http://www.biblewalks.com/Sites/Gezer.html
http://www.telgezer.com/
http://www.hadashot-esi.org.il/report_detail_eng.aspx?id=1820&mag_id=118
Quest for Solomon's Mines - pbs.org - Excavations and finds at Khirbet en Nahas and Khirbet Qeiyafa showing evidence of 10th century Israelite and Edomite culture.
Tour Egypt - Highlights: Who was Tut?
Ancient Egypt by George Rawlinson - wikisource.org - (1886)
Climate Change, Nomadic Pastoralism and Astronomy at Nabta Playa, Southern Egypt
Recent environmental change and prehistoric human activity in Egypt and Northern Sudan
"Egyptian Monotheism" by E.A.W. Budge- www.sacred-texts.com - Chapter in TUTANKHAMEN AMENISM, ATENISM AND EGYPTIAN MONOTHEISM (1923). A monotheistic consideration of Egyptian religion.
The Celestial River: Identifying the Ancient Egyptian Constellations - sino-platonic.org PDF - relation of Egyptian constellations to Greek Constellations. Virgo is associated with a mother goddess.
The Expulsion of the Hyksos and the End of the Middle Bronze Age: A Reassessment in Light of Recent Chronological Research - researchgate.net - Höflmayer, Felix. (2019). Advocates High (older) Bronze Age chronology for Egypt based on carbon dating. This seems to preclude the "academic tradition" that Middle Bronze destruction was an effect of the expulsion of the Hyksos. Destruction would rather be the result of the campaigns of Thutmose III or some other cause. ->
Year 11, second month of the harvest season. Heliopolis was entered. The first month of the inundation season, 23rd day, the commander (?) of the army (?) attacked (?) Zaru [Tjaru]. 25th day, it was heard that Zaru was entered. Year 11, first month of the inundation season, third day. Birth of Set; the majesty of this god caused his voice to be heard. Birth of Isis, the heavens rained. - last entry of Rhind Mathematical Papyrus
“From where came the Hyksos and where did they go”, in: M. Marée (ed.), The Second Intermediate Period (Thirteenth - Seventeenth Dynasties): Current Research, Future Prospects, OLA 192, Leuven 2010: Peeters, 139-181. - academia.edu - Avaris was a harbor, first for trade and then later the mooring of the Egyptian Navy. Trade, primarily through the harbor, is the attraction that brought Levantine people to the area from the times of the Old Kingdom. Egypt's main trade partner was Byblos and the bulk of the evidence points to Northern Levant and Syria as the cultural source of the Hyksos leaders.
A papyrus in the Brooklyn Museum 61 from the early Thirteenth Dynasty documents the presence of Asiatics in Egyptian households, even in provincial areas of Upper Egypt. From the same papyrus we also know that these Asiatics received Egyptian names but that their original names continued to be recorded. With their new names, they became quickly assimilated and could even have careers at the palace and in the administration; most of them blended in with the native Egyptians. 62
the majority of imports from the MB I phases in Tell el-Dab'a originated from the northern Levant. 86 In the transitional period of MB I to II (Phase F, c. 1700 BC), there were also increased imports from southern Palestine, but still these did not match the volume of northern imports at that time.
Probably the Egyptians already identified the North Syrian storm god [Baal-zephon/Hadad] with Seth in the late Twelfth Dynasty.
New Renderings of Egyptian Texts: II. The Expulsion of the Hyksos. (1918) - jstor.org - Gunn, B., & Gardiner, A. (1918) The Journal of Egyptian Archaeology, 5(1), 36-56. doi:10.2307/3853549 - An early article on the Hyksos with all the evidence as of 1918 and a number of speculations that haven't turned out true.
http://carlos.emory.edu/PDF/Classroom_TUTorial_Names_of_Tut.pdf
Akhenaten and the Amarna Period By Dr Kate Spence - bbc.co.uk
“The Topography of New Kingdom Avaris and Per-Ramesses”, in: M. Collier and S. Snape (eds.), Ramesside Studies in Honour of K.A. Kitchen, Bolton 2011: Rutherford Press , 23-51. - academia.edu - Excellent summary of the topography and layout of the Hyksos capital and later of Ramses II.