Proposal Reviews
Due October 15, 2023
A student you mentor has submitted a conference proposal. The mentor does a basic review using the form below.
General Scoring
Top 25%
Students marked as the top 25% "awards level" will be flagged as award contenders on the conference schedule. The submission reflects:
One or fewer punctuation or grammar errors. No use of first person.
Citations and at least one of the following: source material, inspiration material, references, data collection method.
Use of APA, MLA, or Chicago as appropriate to the subject.
Middle 50%
Most students may fall in this category.Â
Some punctuation or grammar errors.
Citations or at least one of the following: source material, inspiration material, references, data collection method.
Errored but recognizable use of APA, MLA, or Chicago as appropriate to the subject.
Bottom 25%
Students in this category who submit on time may still be accepted to the conference if there is space.
Many punctuation or grammar errors.
No evidence.
No citations. Urls or DOIs only or unrecognizable format for sources.