When textbooks, kits, and programs come before faculty members, it can be easy to fall back into old habits of choosing instructional resources based on personal preferences.
By establishing a scoring rubric that has your curriculum guide in mind, the faculty can feel more confident in selecting a resource that will provide a means to execute the curriculum guide.
What is the Gateway Evaluation Process?
Gateway 1 is all about alignment with the curriculum guide that the faculty created.
Does the resource attend to the philosophy, learning targets, and direction that the school wants to go?
Make sure the scoring rubric has values for each of the sections. If the program passes or partial passes, it moves on for evaluation in Gateway 2. If not, kill the evaluation.
Gateway 2 is about the level of rigor and depth of learning that is built into the program. This gateway also examines the assessments that are built into the program as well.
Does the resource attend to the rigor, depth of learning, and assessments needed to show that rigor and depth?
Make sure the scoring rubric has values for each of the sections. If the program passes or partial passes, it moves on for evaluation in Gateway 3. If not, kill the evaluation.
Gateway 3 is the gateway that teachers gravitate towards to early in the evaluation if they do not have a gateway approach. It addresses usability and support tools resources for both teachers and students. It is important but should be examined after establishing that the program aligns to curricular goals and provides for the desired rigor, depth of learning, and assessments.
Does the resource provide additional support materials in user-friendly forms for both teachers and students?
Make sure the scoring rubric has values for each of the sections. If the program fails, kill the evaluation. If it passes or partial passes, the faculty can then consider the adoption of the program.
This is a simplified version of a scoring guide for program evaluation.
The Gateway Evaluation Process is based upon the process from EdReports.org. Sample rubrics can be located on this website. Faculties may consider simplifying them for their purposes, attending to their curricular goals.
Mrs. Melanie Giddings
for the Commission for Lutheran Schools
2022