Cancel Culture
In her editorial, Hallie discusses the dangers of "cancel culture," running rampant in today's online world and having real-life consequences.
In her editorial, Hallie discusses the dangers of "cancel culture," running rampant in today's online world and having real-life consequences.
Canceled. Irrelevant. Ostracized. Done. All words used to describe the situation of dozens of celebrities and influencers alike. After publicly making a mistake, these people are shunned, blocked, and cast out. This culture has ruined careers and relationships, but still continues on. The question is: should cancel culture be canceled?
Getting canceled is a process. Although it varies, most stories follow the same timeline. First, a person with some kind of voice or platform makes a mistake. This can range from an offensive joke, use of slurs, or discrimination to serious legal allegations. Next, social media posts blast this person, often using hashtags like “cancel insert person's name” or “justice for insert community or person who was hurt”. Often, following this public callout, an official apology video is released. These apology videos can include crying, genuine remorse, and a sincere promise to do something about it. Other videos have shown giggling and empty words, digging a deeper hole for these people. Sometimes, apology videos are enough to salvage a career, but it seems that, more often than not, people have already canceled them in their head. A mass unfollowing and blocking ensues and, soon, the platform that this person stands on is diminished to a fraction of the size. Although it seems somewhat lengthy, this is a swift and destructive process that often hurts more than just the canceled person.
Social media influencers constantly live in fear. Worried about saying something accidentally offensive or wearing and supporting the wrong band or company, influencers critically analyze what they post, when they post, and the captions and hashtags they use. However, reasons for cancellation have moved outside of what these influencers decide to post. Fans are quick to snap pictures and videos of them out in the world trying to lead normal lives, which does not always play out well. Pictures can be misinterpreted, intentions twisted, and feelings hurt. Influencers have been grilled, time and time again, for not feeling comfortable with taking pictures, having quick conversations, or just being nervous to meet fans. In an article by National Review, they say, “We believe in private life, that people are entitled to their own associations and opinions (even bad ones!), and entitled to make their own mistakes, too — and that, barring some direct connection to work life or extraordinary circumstance, that none of this is the concern of the little platoons of finks lurking down in human resources.” These influencers, who are often still in high school or in their early twenties, are not allowed to lead normal private lives without criticism.
As mentioned above, these influencers are young. They have brand new and unique situations as they create a wide variety of content for millions of followers, often leaving them exposed and vulnerable. Social media gives people the opportunity to put the very best and modified versions of themselves out. They get to hand pick how the world perceives them. People often forget how young these influencers are, and that they are still developing and learning. Everyone makes mistakes. No one is exempt from this, especially teenagers and young adults. However, most teenagers get to make these mistakes with only their close circle, learn, apologize, grow, and leave it behind. This is not the case for these influencers. They are making the exact same mistakes as their peers, but do not receive the same amount of grace and understanding. Popular comments include: “You should know better than this” when, in reality, they are right where all teenagers are reaching maturity.
Although this trend of cancellation is extreme, it does not go without its upsides. Many influential people have been canceled for valid reasons. Serious crimes have been committed that hurt people deeply that fans are not willing to put up with. However, some of these people are incredibly talented and have left a huge cultural impact with their career. In a SNL Weekend Report, Pete Davidson dove into cancel culture in a funny but mature way. Davidson says, “Pretending these people never existed is maybe not the best solution.” Not only is it not the best solution, but it is also not realistic. We can not pretend that these people did not do good, make people happy or just exist.” Davidson goes on to say, “The rule should be that you can appreciate their work, but only if you admit what they did.” People like Henry Ford were incredibly racist, but made an immeasurable impact on our society. If we cancel everyone who makes a mistake and refuse to consume their media or products, we will soon be left without anything to enjoy.
One of the most relevant Buddha sayings is as follows: “Holding onto anger is like drinking poison and expecting the other person to die.” This culture we have created generates even more fear and negativity in today’s society where it feels like they already reign. Forgiveness, grace, and understanding should be the core focus, not searching for a chance to bring someone down. Cancel culture has grown deep roots very rapidly, but there is still time to cancel this culture.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hlzAhIl482c
https://www.nationalreview.com/2020/06/cancel-cancel-culture/