Restorative justice is a philosophy that maintains that all members of a community have a collective responsibility to develop and sustain positive relationships in order to prevent harm from occurring, and that when conflict does occur, it should be addressed in a way that focuses on the harm caused, rather than on the rule/law that was broken. Restorative justice says that those who are most affected by the incident must have a say in how the harm is addressed and repaired (Alternatives Youth Organization).
A whole school approach requires commitment and involvement from all stakeholders in all areas of school life. While a whole school approach is needed to transform school culture, this guide focuses on the role of the teacher in that transformation. Even if there isn’t buy-in yet from all the stakeholders in your school, beginning to implement a restorative approach at the classroom level can have a powerful impact on students’ interactions with one another.
As awareness of the existence and impact of the school-to-prison pipeline has increased in recent years, traditional discipline practices have been subject to much scrutiny. Students of color are being suspended and expelled from our nation’s schools at an alarmingly high rate. More than 25 percent of Chicago Public School students have been suspended at least once in their school careers. Despite the frequency with which traditional discipline procedures are utilized, there is no clear evidence that they make schools safer or have any lasting positive effect on student behavior.
Clear and convincing evidence shows a critical need to change the way in which schools manage student discipline. Research shows that exclusionary practices, such as suspension and expulsion:
Have long-term negative effect on student achievement;
Disproportionately impact students of color; and,
Are associated with lower test scores, decreased graduation rates, and increased incarceration rates later in life.
In response to chilling statistics on the rates at which students of color, particularly African-American boys, are being suspended and expelled from our nation’s schools, community groups and advocates have embraced restorative justice as a powerful solution.