Claim #3 - Remarkable Deeper Learning

West Bath students communicate their learning clearly and effectively for a wide variety of audiences.

West Bath Students strive to communicate their thinking and learning effectively to a wide variety of audiences. Communication occurs in multiple ways for a variety of purposes: through persuasive writing, public presentations to educate and/or inform, public presentations to educate and/or persuade, public services announcements, and through celebration passages. Through the recursive process of writing, students are engaged with deeper learning, as students are required to think critically, they synthesize complex ideas and consider multiple perspectives in their writing pieces or presentations, they are able to understand how the work that they are doing connects to real-world issues, needs, and lives, and students ask and respond to questions that promote critical thinking and inquiry. Additionally, the communication process is courageous, embracing a process of risk taking, growth, and revision. Effectiveness is measured via rubrics and exit tickets, public response, and whether or not the communications resulted in action.

Persuasive Writing

One aspect of communication is the ability to write effective persuasive letters. Students learn that in a persuasive letter, they must be able to communicate their point concisely, share information about why their point of view is important, and convince the reader that this perspective and any action needed is necessary. One way to determine the effectiveness of persuasive writing is whether or not action was taken as a result of the letter.

West Bath students have utilized persuasive letters as products of expeditions and case studies numerous times over the several years of partnership. In earlier expeditions, persuasive letters were included with products, encouraging community members to plant flowers to save pollinators, or to buy locally to support Maine industries. While the letters are compelling, the effectiveness of these letters could not be measured. In more recent expeditions, persuasive letters were directed to a specific audience, such as the school principal, land owners, or the school board. The effectiveness of the students' communication could then be measured by actions taken.

Second Grade Persuasive Letters to the Community Requesting Help to Save the Bees (2014)

savethebeesletter-elijah.pages.pdf

Fourth Grade Persuasive Letters to the Community Requesting for Residents to Buy Locally (2014)

persuasive letter.pdf

First Grade Persuasive Letters to School Principal Requesting a Trash Can on the Playground (2016)

SWBS_OFFICE18082214580.pdf
SWBS_OFFICE18082214590.pdf

Third Grade Persuasive Letters to Target Landowners Requesting Permission to Install a Bat House (2017)

bat letter.pdf

In addition to targeting the audience more specifically, growth in quality of the student writing is evidenced over time, which increases effectiveness of communication. In the 2017 third grade letter, the student has a strong opening paragraph, and gives 3 reasons to support his opening request, along with 3 facts to support each of his 3 reasons. He ends with a closing that summarizes his purpose. The sample letter is clear and compelling, and was effective in that the bat houses were installed.

Public Speaking - When Speaking is the Purpose to Educate or Inform

Celebrations of Learning

West Bath School holds two Celebrations of Learning per year. The winter celebration, at the conclusion of the first set of expeditions, is focused on process and reflection, and provides students with an opportunity to hear feedback on their work. The spring celebration is culminating, and provides students with an opportunity to present and be docents of their work. Classrooms are set up so that visitors move through stations as though they are following the steps of expeditions. At the completion of the student presentations, visitors will have experienced the full expedition. Students spend time planning, preparing for, and rehearsing the content that they choose to deliver at their station, and following the celebration, reflect on their ability to communicate clearly.

Kindergarten Rehearsal for their First Celebration of Learning - Winter - 2016

MVI_1376.MOV

Fourth Grade Rehearsal for Celebration of Learning - Winter 2016

IMG_3340.MOV

In order to communicate effectively, students need to know and understand their content well enough to share the information they have learned and answer questions correctly, they also need to use strong speaking, fluent voices, make eye contact, and reference their display materials while they speak. In the two clips, the kindergarten student who is presenting for the first time, relies on questions cues from visitors to help to get him started with his presentation, while the fourth grade student, who has presented at several celebrations, is able to speak fluently and without the need for note cards.

All visitors at the Celebration of Learning leave exit tickets to provide feedback on the student presentations. Additionally, students reflect on their presentations, and debrief as a class how well they did explaining their content and utilizing their presentation skills. This information then informs changes that need to happen for the next public presentation to enable their public communication to be even more effective in the future. West Bath's Celebrations of Learning are not just an event that happens at the end of an expedition. The presentations themselves are a process of student learning, as they self-assess and reflect, striving towards higher quality work and higher quality presentations.

Visitor Exit Tickets from Kindergarten Celebration of Learning Presentation - (Spring 2018)

worm feedback.pdf

As stated above, following the public presentation, students review the exit tickets left by visitors to determine how effective students were with communicating their knowledge. In the case of the kindergarten class, students also determined their effectiveness of persuading their visitors to not squish worms, putting their learning to use, foster responsibility and improve their communities. Using the exit tickets (left), students were able to celebrate the facts that visitors took away with them, and tally their effectiveness of changing the squishing behaviors of their visitors to help to keep our worms alive and contributing to the garden!

Another example of the deeper learning process in action in relation to the Celebration of Learning can be seen with the reflective cycle below. The students reviewed the exit tickets that visitors left from their spring 2017 Celebration of Learning to better understand information that they effectively shared with visitors, to celebrate warm feedback, and to hear areas in which students could improve their presentation skills. Some of those areas where they received feedback were to speak louder and slower, to make better eye contact, and to stay on topic while presenting. The first graders then summarized the exit tickets as part of their debrief, which helps to create a plan for improvement for the next opportunity they have to present.

Visitor Exit Tickets from First Grade Celebration of Learning Presentation (Spring 2017)

first grade feedback.pdf

First Grade Student Debrief of Celebration of Learning Presentation (Spring 2017)

first grade debrief.pdf

Learning Wheel in Action


Because students are continuously on the learning wheel, it is practice that they continuously review feedback in order to set goals and make plans for improvement. The artifact on the right is the class debrief after the spring 2018 Celebration of Learning. The student debrief shows that the exit tickets provided evidence that students spoke clearly, loudly, and used eye contact. These were three areas this same group of students had identified as goals in spring 2017 in the debrief above! Additionally, next steps for improvement have been named.

Second Grade Student Debrief of Celebration of Learning (Spring 2018)

"West Bath's Celebrations of Learning are the best I've ever seen. It is like you are taking a mini-class in every setting you enter. Students share information in a confident, professional, and clear manner. It is impressive. To me, that ability is synthesizing complex ideas and transferring knowledge." - Sara Brown, EL Education School Designer

Fourth Grade Panel Presentations at The Green Crab Working Summit

On June 6th and 7th, the fourth grade students participated in panel discussions at the Green Crab Working Summit, funded by the New Hampshire Sea Grant. As part of the promotional material for the event, students were filmed while on field work, as they developed an understanding of ways local restaurants can utilize this invasive species.

gcws_program_final_060118.pdf

The two-day working summit agenda included speakers from chefs to educators to scientists, cooking demonstrations, round-table discussions, and opportunities to make connections and strategize. This summit was an opportunity to learn from each other, network and strategize on how best to mitigate the impacts of this invader. In addition to presenting in front of a live audience, students distributed the green crab brochures they had created to help to meet the goals of the conference. Effectiveness of their communication through both their public speaking and their brochures was evidenced by the unsolicited email from Marissa MacMahan, lead scientist from Manomet.

masterCopy.pdf

Growth in Public Speaking Video Productions - Kindergarten to Fifth Grade

We spend the first trimester of kindergarten learning about EL Education best practices for learning. We learn terminology for effective students and spend weeks exploring the West Bath School's 6 character traits. The Kindergarten Class of 2018 created a video to inform incoming kindergarten students about our Code of Character. Each student described how a character trait could be demonstrated around the school, wrote that description multiple times, performed and then narrated their description. To create this video, the students labored over voice control, speed, and clarity of their description. This is the first experience many of these students were expected to revise a task multiple times.

kindergarten video.pdf

Fifth Grade Fishbowl Video

IMG_2353.MOV

By the time the children reach fifth grade, they are able to express higher order thinking skills through their discussions. The students were each assigned a different stakeholder in the Revolutionary War to persuade their peers toward that stakeholders perspective on the war through a research based, unrehearsed conversation using fishbowl protocol. This shows growth over time from kindergarten students who are reading their composed sentence to fifth graders who use research to engage in a professional roundtable discussion.

Public Speaking - When the Purpose is to Educate and Persuade

Fifth Grade Boat Building Open House

Students hosted an open house at the Maine Maritime Museum Boat Shop to share their boat building experiences, learning, and the skiffs to date. Students prepared speeches to share with the crowd, explaining what the boat shop experience had meant to them as learners and citizens. The purpose of the open house is to provide a forum for the community to build an understanding of the program, ask questions of the students, and hopefully to develop support for continuing the boat building program in the future. As a result of the effective speaking and communication of the students at the open house, the School Board of Directors approved funding for the program for the next school year at their very next meeting.

Coastal Journal Article - Boatbuilding Open House

boat building article.pdf

Fifth Grade Student Boatbuilding Open House Speech

"I have interviewed many high school students. These fifth grade students were some of the most knowledgable and articulate students I've ever interviewed." - Jason Pafundi, Coastal Journal

Second Grade Expedition - Placing West Bath on the Map (2016)

In the second grade expedition of Placing West Bath on the Map, students need to develop an understanding of what makes up a country, a state, and a community, and how counties, states, and communities are recognized. Case studies led students from large studies of counties, to a focused study of the state of Maine, to an in-depth study of our local community. As an outcome of their expedition, the students wanted to create a product that put West Bath School, the heart of the town of West Bath, on the map, and proposed that they install a new school sign. The students spoke to the school board of directors, asking for support for their project. Additionally, they spoke to the Parent Teacher Organization, requesting additional financial support. Demonstrating effectiveness of communication, both the School Board of Directors and the Parent Teacher Organization granted the request of the students. The School Board Chair thanked the students for taking the time to stand up and advocate for something they believed in.

Second Grade Letters Presented to the School Board

School Board letters- new sign -1-25-16.pdf

Minutes from the Student Presentation at the School Board of Directors Meeting

wbsau minutes 2-3-16.pdf

The New School Signs

Fifth Grade School Board Presentation - Chewonki

As part of the fifth grade expedition, West Bath students participate in a 3 night, 4 day camping trip at Chewonki Foundation. Through this experience, students develop background to support the guiding question, How can I alter the environmental impact of my choices on places that are important to me? Additionally, the goals of the trip are participate in citizen scientist work on human ecology and environmental systems, and develop team building, survival, and estuary/ecology skills. Following the experience, the fifth grade students develop a presentation to present to the School Board of Directors to demonstrate that the experience is valuable and to ask that they continue to support it.

Student Developed Power Point for the Presentation to the School Board

CHEWONKI school board.pdf

School Board of Directors Minutes Outlining the Student Presentation

wbsau minutes 12-6-17.pdf

5th Grade Chewonki School Board Presentation

As a result of the students' presentation, the School Board of Directors agreed to fund the experience for another year.

Public Service Announcements

The purpose of a Public Service Announcement (PSA) is to provide free information with the goal of changing the public's attitudes and behaviors towards a social issue. Throughout West Bath's relationship with EL Education, communicating social issues for the purpose of promoting ideas and the common good has been a regular facet of expeditions. As was our experience with persuasive writing, early expeditions, while focused on interesting topics, did not always have the PSAs focused on the right audience, as with the New Meadows Estuary Propaganda postcards. This was not a topic that engaged the general community, and did not truly contribute to the common good. A later sample of a PSA, focused on saving our beloved local beach from erosion, was more meaningful in content, but the work was not high-quality enough to distribute. The final PSAs in this sample, created in 2018 by the Summer Stem students, were created in partnership with the Maine Audubon to help to save the piping plovers. Maine Audubon had expressed the need of having brochures to post and distribute at beaches, giving our students a real authentic audience for the PSAs.

Third Grade New Meadows Estuary Propaganda (2013)

In 2013, after observing the New Meadows Lake behind our school, students questioned whether the body of water was correctly named. They noticed that there were marine plants and animals within the lake and conducted a series of salinity studies. The students learned that in fact, New Meadows Lake contained salt water and was incorrectly named. The students created propaganda postcards, in attempt to generate attention and to being a groundswell to have New Meadows Lake renamed to New Meadows Estuary.

SWBS_OFFICE18082310100.pdf

Second Grade Popham Beach Erosion Persuasive Letters and PSAs (2016)

PophamBeachOpinionWriting.pdf

In 2016, as part of a second grade expedition, "Mystery at Popham Beach," students researched about the erosion at Popham Beach in Phippsburg, Maine. Students wrote persuasive letters to the visitors of Popham Beach about the current erosion issue because they wanted to save a favorite local beach. In the letters they gave suggestions of ways people can help the affect erosion has on the beach we love. Students then created PSAs to post on the Popham Beach bulletin board which is located at the entrance of the path to the beach.

Summer STEM Club (2018)

As part of the 2018 Summer STEM Club, the students created flyers and brochures for the Maine Audubon to inform the public about the Piping Plover. The piping plover is an endangered shorebird that migrates to Maine's beaches for nesting. Maine Audubon needed current flyers for posting at Maine's beaches and brochures to hand out at educational programming. The students were able to work alongside Maine Audubon's Piping Plover team of biologists. The primary grade students created flyers while the upper elementary grade students made brochures. These PSAs informed the public about the identification of plovers, why they migrate to Maine, how to protect them, and a scientifically accurate drawing of the piping plover.

Franklin Flyer.pdf

Student Step-Up Speeches

Each June, our out going 5th grade students are encouraged to write and submit a speech to share during step-up, regarding how their time at West Bath has influenced them as a person and student. Students are selected to read their speeches during our closing ceremony at the end of the year. All of the speeches included are samples of effective communication, as they respond to the prompt, are personal, contain a message, and have closings that let the listeners know that the student is headed off to do great things. However, the progression of speeches over the years are also evident. The most recent student speech included demonstrates effective communication by being written as an extended metaphor, and by linking her West Bath School experience with some of the critical aspects of her EL Education.

SCN_0002.pdf


The speeches below show the growth over time in regards to student communication. All meet the criteria of effective communication. However, you will see that the first connects with the audience at an emotional level and walks the audience through some of the outcomes of his experience as a student. The second sample shows the progression of linking the students' personal experience to school goals. The third sample is the first time that we see an extended metaphor as an exit speech - her school experience as it relates to the butterfly life cycle.

SCN_0002 (dragged).pdf
SCN_0002 (dragged) 2.pdf
SCN_0002 (dragged) 3.pdf