Bring-Your-Own-Brunch 12-1, Open Space Discussion 1-2:30 @ TVUUC
Free child care services provided
View/Add to Calendar - Printable Flyer
January's ForUUm we'll be discussing the Wellness to MAHA Pipeline. MAHA stands for Make America Healthy Again and represents a cohort of the modern alt-right that includes many people who used to consider themselves progressive.
When RFK Jr. teamed up with Donald Trump, he became part of a growing number of health and wellness advocates whose extreme skepticism of modern healthcare, pharmaceutical, and food industries led them to support a movement that promised to upend them all.
We'll explore subjects like:
Vaccine skepticism, 5G, raw milk, fluoridation, and wellness misinformation
How the MAHA movement formed, who are the major influencers
The real problems with our healthcare, pharmaceutical and food industries
How wellness grifters exploit the problems with our healthcare systems
The conspiracy theories that spread when problems go unsolved
The difference between healthy skepticism and contrarianism
Videos and materials are shared for the purpose of inviting participants into open discussion, and are not endorsed by or representative of TVUUC.
Ian Bremmer provides a concise summary of the MAHA movement and the coalition it has brought together around a combination of valid health concerns and pseudoscientific conspiracy theories.
This video explores now far right influencers have adopted the "crunchy mom" hippie aesthetic to promote wellness misinformation, conspiracy theories, and the "trad wife" lifestyle. There are also links to several good articles on this subject in the references.
When you picture QAnon, you probably imagine a guy in a basement with 14 browser tabs open. You probably don’t imagine a yoga influencer in Bali talk-typing about “raising your vibration” between #wellness and #momlife hashtags. And yet - that’s exactly where QAnon found one of its most effective gateways.
This short NBC News piece features interviews with the creators of Conspirituality about the way that QAnon conspiracy theories infiltrated yoga and wellness communities. While the influence of QAnon has waned in recent years, much of the MAHA movement was formed by those who had been radicalized by it.
Naomi Klein's book Doppelganger was one of the first to uncover the phenomenon of far-right wellness conspiracies. She uses the story of Naomi Wolf, another author who she is often confused with, as an example of how these conspiracy theories turn reality on its head, and how this serves the interests of the rich and powerful.
The creators of the podcast Conspirituality (and the book by the same name) are some of the leading experts on the relationship between wellness communities, conspiracy theories, cults, and authoritarianism.
Their back catalog is full of episodes that explore the links between Yoga and wellness influencers, natural healing and herbal medicine grifters, and the authoritarian movements that take advantage of them. They also have a lot of great content on anti-authoritarian spiritual movements.
Here are some episodes that analyze the MAHA movement, diagonalism, neokayfabe, and other fun topics.
Here are a couple of videos that discuss the idea of "Horseshoe Theory" that compares extreme and authoritarian versions of fascism and communism and suggests that they have more in common with each other than they have with neoliberal centrism.
The original definition of horseshoe theory represented a cold war mindset, and predated the 2-dimensional political compass that does a better job of distinguishing between authoritarian and libertarian versions of leftist and conservative ideology.
Many have cited horseshoe theory or diagonalism as an explanation for how so many people who identified as "far left" ended up joining a "far right" movement like MAHA. This seems to describe the "swing voters" in the last election much more than the traditional idea of the "independent centrist" voter.
A theory called brokenism described by Alana Newhouse offers a possible explanation for why those who reject the status quo cannot seem to decide between far-left and far-right solutions. She suggests that they simply see the system as fundamentally "broken" and prefer to support candidates that acknowledge this fact over those who don't, even if they don't offer sound solutions.
Some questions to help get the conversation going!
Do you know people in your life that have gone down the wellness to alt-right pipeline? How did it happen? What issues or concerns were behind this change?
Compare horseshoe theory, diagonalism, and brokenism. How do each of these help explain the wellness to alt-right pipeline? What do these theories get wrong?
What are the similarities between the "hippie" or "crunchy mom" lifestyle and the "trad wife" movement? How are they different?
How do the problems with our healthcare system contribute to the rise in health conspiracies, alternative medicine, and skepticism of evidence-based medicine?
What do the MAHA critics of our healthcare and food systems get right? Which of their proposals do you support?
How does extreme institutional distrust and generalized skepticism lead to reactionary and contrarian positions?
What are your favorite health and wellness conspiracies? COVID denial, 5G, raw milk, vaccine skepticism, Tylenol causes autism, fluoridation, etc.