Rating: 4 out of 5
WHAT if someone you love confessed to something unspeakable? So forms the premise of Norwegian director Kristoffer Borgli’s The Drama.
What ensues is a hugely ambitious, yet highly intelligent blend of social commentary masquerading as a romantic comedy-drama. Or maybe it’s the other way around. The beauty is that it can be watched either way.
The film, starring Robert Pattinson and Zendaya, was marketed around the idea of “what could she have confessed that could be so awful?”… its trailer refusing to reveal the big talking point.
Yet to properly analyse it, you really need to know what the revelation is. And given the brazenly provocative nature of it, the film still provides plenty to get stuck into and enjoy even when you do.
And besides, concealment didn’t prevent The Drama from garnering notoriety in certain quarters in the US. But we’ll come to that…
As it gets going, the film starts off in the romantic comedy tradition. A boy, Charlie (Pattinson), sees a girl, Emma (Zendaya), in a coffee shop and concocts an awkward plan to speak to her based upon the book she is reading. Although it doesn’t quite go to plan, the two end up dating and it soon become apparent that this was a flashback: Charlie is recalling the key moments in their relationship while attempting to write his marriage vows… and the wedding is a little over a week away.
Charlie and Emma then go to a tasting with best friends Rachel (Alana Haim) and Mike (Mamoudou Athie), during which they get drunk and fatefully dare each other to say the worst things they’ve ever done.
Revelations include locking a ‘slow’ neighbour into a closet deep in the woods and leaving him overnight, prompting a police search (Rachel) and cyber bullying (Charlie). But the big one comes from Emma: as a 14-year-old, she planned a High School shooting, even acquiring the gun. But she didn’t go through with it.
Jaws drop, friendships are shattered and Charlie and Emma’s wedding plans begin to spiral.
But while a large part of what ensues is devoted to seeing whether Charlie and Emma will survive the bombshell and make it to wedded life, Borgli’s film also devotes plenty of time to the issues stemming from the revelation.
Viewers are therefore asked to consider a lot, not least the motivations behind Emma’s initial decision and whether she should be forgiven for even harbouring such thoughts.
The controversy surrounding the film actually stems from that latter point, with gun safety advocates, non-profit groups and even a father whose son was killed in the Columbine shooting [Tom Mauser] criticising it for using a shock value twist in a romantic comedy-drama.
Mauser went further, suggesting that the casting of Zendaya, who is so well known and beloved, both ‘humanises’ the perpetrators of such violence and ‘normalises’ the shootings.
Emma does, in fact, opt against going through with the shootings in the film because of a similar incident nearby that directly impacts her school - the subsequent therapy sessions enabling her to finally be seen by her peers - and for her to connect with them. As a result, she becomes a passionate anti-gun lobbyist (as seen in scenes involving her younger self, played in the movie by Jordyn Curet).
My own personal criticism stems from the sense that the film doesn’t actually go far enough into examining Emma’s motivations. She was bullied, ignored and felt misunderstood. But there’s a narrative surrounding mental health and lack of support that could have gone deeper without condoning the actions of such perpetrators. A failure of care, or even to detect something is wrong... in part due to the continued stigma attached to mental health, perhaps?
The film also takes a look at America and guns without taking direct aim at the gun lobby (a deliberate ploy to invite deeper conversations? Or a kid glove approach that sought to avoid too big a backlash from such a powerful lobby?)
But that being said, The Drama does have some relevant points to make. The fetishisation of guns, for instance, is highlighted via a magazine that is sent to Charlie featuring semi-clad women posing provocatively with firearms, while the gun culture of America is pointed out in conversations that reference past incidents, shooters and victims as well as questioning how many people actually invite thoughts of their own mass shootings without going through with it.
Hovering in the background, meanwhile, is the conflicted, often hypocritical morality of those who cast judgement.
Rachel, for instance, is openly appalled because one of her close relatives was confined to a wheelchair after being involved in a mass shooting. Yet she cannot take responsibility for her own cruelty in her worst act - the humiliation of a ‘slow’ neighbour who could have died as the result of her actions.
She was a bully. So too Charlie, whose confession comes with an uncertainty surrounding the motivations behind his victim’s decision to move away.
And couldn’t it be argued that the bullying actions of those judging could well have led to, if not created, the mindset of those like Emma who may resort to the unthinkable as a way of reacting? In a country without guns, for instance, would some of those who are bullied merely react by taking their own lives?
The Drama doesn’t seek to hold any answers. But it does raise some relevant questions and invites uneasy conversations afterwards, for which it deserves to be applauded even if it maybe doesn’t go hard enough on some of the issues.
It also deserves praise for the way it dissects reaction to the central dilemma, which was integral to Borgli’s thinking when writing the screenplay.
As he has stated: “You don’t instantly fall out of love when something like that is revealed - it creates inner conflict, and you begin to see the true image of what you’ve fallen in love with.
“We all carry parts of ourselves that we keep hidden. Secrets, mistakes, fears - things we worry might change how others see us, even though they fundamentally shape who we are.
“There’s real clarity that comes from living in your truth, but there is also a risk in that. That tension fascinates me.”
As for whether a relationship can survive such a revelation, he continues: “Polite society presents an affluent and privileged existence where violence can creep in unexpectedly. Charlie and Emma have been conditioned not to speak frankly about their issues - they’re simply trying to get through their wedding.
“We’re constantly walking on eggshells over where our moral lines are drawn in our relationships - sharing deep truths with anyone feels risky today.
“Being vulnerable and sharing the difficult parts of yourself, including the struggles and challenges you’ve faced, can be a great bonding experience.”
The Drama stretches this theory to virtually breaking point, really putting Charlie and Emma through the emotional ringer.
But there’s also something truthful in the risk factor of sharing truths, particularly in an era of social media, where so many lives are lived out in the open, awaiting exposure and validation, while continually running the risk of criticism and rejection.
The Drama does a good job in exposing the hypocrisy of a society that expects perfection and the presentation of happiness, while often overlooking, ignoring or invalidating struggle.
The feelings that led to Emma’s decision are given short shrift by the characters who surround her, even though she never carried it out... and even went on to become an anti-gun activist.
But the sense of fear and maybe self-preservation is acute. Can Emma be ‘trusted’ not to return to that mental state again? It’s easier to reject and even vilify than to understand and engage.
Pattinson’s Charlie is at the centre of this. He wants to continue loving Emma. But he becomes obsessed with the what if’s and the what will people think. His decision making becomes hugely erratic, to the point he sexually degrades himself and a co-worker - another issue that the film raises (the power dynamics between men and women).
Borgli throws a lot at his audience, sometimes directly, but often indirectly, challenging them to think and to question. But he also doesn’t lose sight of the two central characters: the will they or won’t they survive the revelation is kept in play until the very end. And even then, he doesn’t wrap things up in a nice tidy bow.
Rather, he exits the movie with a scene that invites the conversation to continue, thereby ensuring that The Drama continues to have a life beyond the end credits. It’s not a film to easily forget. But it is one to be impressed by. And it’s one that successfully provokes you to have an opinion as well as something to say.
Certificate: 15
Running time: 106mins
More 2026 movies