Rating: 4 out of 5
PRIOR to its divisive ending, I have to rate Mike Flanagan's Carrie remake among the best TV shows of 2026.
It turned something that initially seemed highly unnecessary into something extremely relevant, taking the themes inherent in Stephen King's novel and updating them for the social media generation.
In doing so, it turned the idea of what constitutes the horror of the Carrie story firmly on its head. In Flanagan's mind, Carrie White is the victim. She's the innocent who is corrupted; the beacon of hope and good turned bad by the evils of the world around her.
Flanagan brought nuance and depth. He found beauty in the unlikeliest of places, while putting forward ideals we should all aspire to.
Yet he also confronted the reality of growing up and navigating those challenging teenage years in the modern era, while examining the conflict between good and evil, and the sometimes fine lines that can blur the distinction between both.
First published in 1974, Carrie marked King's debut novel. It immediately captured people's imaginations for the way it dealt with themes including bullying and coming-of-age, and of not conforming to societal norms. It has also been described as a revenge tragedy.
A film followed two years later, directed by Brian De Palma and starring Sissy Spacek and Piper Laurie. It became an instant classic and is still widely considered to be the definitive screen version by many (especially when compared against the 2002 made-for-TV remake and the 2013 film update, starring Chloe Moretz and Julianne Moore).
But Flanagan's TV series, which is available to stream on Amazon Prime, doesn't seek merely to copy. It has something to say.
Which is also why the climax of the series (now revealed to be the first of a possible three) was so disappointing in so many ways. But we'll come to that....
The successes are what makes Carrie worth talking about - and most definitely worth tuning in for.
The story follows Carrie White (Summer H Howell) after she is found by the police hiding in a 'praying closet' with her mother, Margaret (Samantha Sloyan), following the death of her father in an accident.
She is subsequently monitored by social services, who insist that she be sent to the local High School as part of the effort to see that she is integrated into society.
But she quickly stands out as someone who is different and made to feel an outsider, despite being kind, curious and desperate to find out more about the world. One of her classmates, Chris (Alison Thornton), becomes her chief tormentor, by either exposing her innocence or exploiting her naivety, often goading many of her classmates into joining in with the humiliations that ensue.
The worst of these is the long iconic shower scene, in which Carrie experiences her first period, and is terrified and confused. Here, Flanagan depicts a truly harrowing sequence, as a blood-stained Carrie is videoed and jeered by her peers, as she attempts to remove the menstrual blood from her trousers, while they throw tampons at her and shout "plug it up, plug it up". It sends shivers... the horror stemming as much from the knowledge that this kind of thing is happening in real life (humiliation by video and subsequent social media sharing).
Carrie does subsequently attract the sympathy of another class favourite, Sue (Siena Agudong), who wrestles with her conscience, but her growing desire to be accepted places her at odds with her mum, whose devoutly religious beliefs often cloud her own judgement (especially in the way she delivers punitive punishments on her struggling daughter).
All the while, there is something possibly supernatural growing inside of her - a telekinetic power that if provoked, could quite literally unleash hell.
Flanagan's series actually opens in the aftermath of the notorious prom scene that is synonymous with Carrie, as the few survivors give witness statements to the authorities, creating a healthy sense of foreboding that also nods to the many that may think they know the direction the story is heading.
It then flashes back through the events that led to the massacre. But its strength as a series doesn't so much lie in ticking all of what you know efficiently, but rather in finding ways to surprise with scenes that you definitely won't have been expecting. In doing so, it cleverly invites a wider conversation about some of the issues surrounding the world, and the difficulty of growing up in it, today.
The first episode also includes a simulated classroom shooting incident that terrifies Carrie, but which creates a consternation in her mum. It thereby offers a horrific insight into the spectre of mass shootings that lingers over every classroom in America, opening a debate about what constitutes the right approach in terms of preparing children for experiencing such a possible scenario.
It's a clear sign of the times - as well as a scary reminder of just how much has changed for young people finding their way in life.
And it could even be strategically placed, given that Carrie's eventual 'revenge' could be viewed as a metaphor for a mass shooting event. There's certainly a sense of foreshadowing, much in the same way that the blood depicted during Carrie's shower scene [a fellow pupil even smears it on her cheek] is also a taste of what's to follow.
Put together, both scenes create a sense of horror, especially for older viewers/parents and/or traumatised children, that feels far more chilling than any of the supernatural elements the book and subsequent films are more renowned for. This is the stuff of everyday nightmares.
But while certainly dark, the show also finds heart in unexpected places. One of the most powerful moments in the whole series comes during the second episode, as Carrie is put before the school's guidance counsellor Peter Morton (played memorably by Tim Bagley) for an exchange that should be held up as a beacon for all counsellors and/or Sencos on how to be truly empathetic.
It has previously been revealed that Morton is gay and struggled to find acceptance among his own peers, so he relates to Carrie's struggles as someone who has felt ostracised himself. But what follows is truly magical. The two bond over a shared love of reading, reciting each other's favourite literary quotes to each other. These include 'we need never be ashamed of our tears', from Charles Dickens' Great Expectations, 'nothing is so painful to the human mind as a great and sudden change' from Frankenstein and - my own favourite, and the one that resonated with Morton in particular, 'I know you'll be kind, and clever, and bold. And the bigger your heart, the more it will hold. When nights are black, and when days are grey, you'll be brave, and bright, so no shadows can stay. And become anybody that you'd like to be. And then I'll look at you, and you'll look at me, and I'll love you whoever you've grown up to be', from The Wonderful Things You Will Be by Emily Winfield Martin.
In those two beautifully written minutes, there's love, compassion and inclusion - and it's worth watching Carrie just to experience that moment alone.
But throughout the eight episodes of this first season, there was so much to enjoy and think about, not least the nuance and complexity that could be found in every performance.
Howell, especially, deserves praise for making Carrie so different from previous incarnations, tapping into an innocence and joy at being finally let loose in the world that allows audiences to easily root for her. It makes her suffering all the more tragic and her subsequent rage and revenge all the more understandable. It's also a clever performance in the way that it winks towards the power that is lying dormant - she's at first scared by it, then embracing of it, as she slowly realises the power and control it brings her.
Sloyan is equally terrific as her mother... again, moving away from past performances that have sought mostly to cast her as a straight-forward villain. Here, there's a sharply observed mix of religious fervour and deeply caring and loving mother. As the former, there's insight into how she got there, courtesy of flashbacks to a controlling and conspiratorial husband; while in the latter, there's elements of the warrior that lies in every mother, often ferociously advocating on her daughter's behalf and butting heads with the high school hierarchy over policy, teaching practice and lack of protection for Carrie.
The dynamic between mother and daughter is another huge part of the success of the series. Both are hugely compelling characters.
But the support is great too. We've already mentioned the tremendous empathy that Bagley brings to his counsellor, but there's a strong performance from Matthew Lillard, as the headteacher who is hopelessly out of his depth, trying to placate everyone without really grasping the nettle and dealing properly with anyone. His looks of exasperation, especially when presented with Margaret White, are priceless.
And Thornton is tremendously wicked as Chris, even when attempting to shed some light on her own insecurities and personal hurt. The show does a good job in not over-simplifying any of its villains, even though it doesn't ask you to actually feel sorry for them. Chris is a product of her environment... fully aware of her social status, both as a cheerleader for her social media followers, and as a teenage girl in her own right. She is struggling to come to terms with her parents' separation, a bullying father and the recent knowledge that he won't be able to afford to pay for her preferred choice of higher education - a blow to both her ego and her own opportunities.
But here the show tackles wealth and inequality... the effects of privilege over poverty.
And it provides a tremendously potent platform for analysing the dangers of social media, of misinformation, and of abuse that's left unchecked. Carrie isn't the only victim in this regard. Every student is targeted at some point by a malicious account, created by Chris, known as Carrie Red. But so too are the teachers.
In another of the series' memorable and chilling arcs, Carrie's form tutor, Seth Peist (played by Rahul Kohli) is exposed as having an affair with one of the students and subsequently takes his own life after being hounded by his peers. While the allegations here are proven to be truthful, there are many similar ones that aren't.
Here, again, Carrie invites a wider conversation around issues such as the abuse of power and position, and the effects of bullying upon mental health. These are hot button issues. And they aren't trivialised or sensationalised. But rather presented in a thought-provoking way.
Of course, Carrie wouldn't be Carrie without the supernatural horror, but it's arguable that this is the least successful part of the show. Scenes involving Carrie experimenting with her powers, and sometimes even using them, have more of an X-Men/superhero quality rather than anything overtly worrying or scary. The series is about Carrie's empowerment. But there could also be a mounting sense of dread.
This also affects the finale. When Carrie does unleash her powers at prom, having been covered in a bucket of pigs' blood, it's somehow not as terrifying as I had been expecting. This isn't helped by providing Carrie with enablers, including an astral-projecting emissary named Emaline (Thalia Dudek), who serves as a friend, and who guides the use of her powers during the bloody climax.
But it's in the various machinations of the climax that the show ultimately goes wrong. I didn't mind that Carrie survived. It didn't dilute the tragedy surrounding her arc. But the decision to extend the show's life beyond one series, and to introduce an underground group of supernatural manipulators, felt unnecessary and more in keeping with the modern need to create franchises, or to needlessly stretch things out.
Flanagan has proven himself an astute writer-director, particularly of Stephen King's works (see also The Life of Chuck), but here I felt he let himself, the show and its characters down. A one and done had the potential to carry more impact and really lean into the tragedies at play, if not so much the supernatural horror.
But even though it failed to stick the landing, Carrie still has to rate as a tremendous success. It's intelligent, articulate and quite often emotional. It's brilliantly performed, stylishly directed and - in its very best moments - boasts scenes that either provoke a much wider debate or offer hope to fellow strugglers who may not always feel seen.
Related TV content