Guiding question: Climate Change: Human Activities VS Natural Climate Variations?
Time Estimate: 45 minutes
Purpose: This lesson explores the ongoing debate between climate scientists and certain politically aligned groups regarding the primary causes of climate change. Students will learn how to evaluate their claims and support their arguments with evidence.
Overview: This lesson begins by introducing the key debate on the primary causes of climate change—human activities versus natural variations—as discussed by different groups. Students are then given four evidence cards and guided to analyze them by answering related questions. After interpreting graphs or texts and responding to the accompanying questions, students will connect each evidence card to the claims it supports or contradicts, justifying their reasoning with CER .
Design Principles:
Data analysis
Argumentation
Background Knowledge: Greenhouse effect and its connection to global warming
Safety: N/A
Time Estimate: 45 minutes
Unit Connections:
Teacher material
Student material
Materials: Teacher slides: 1.2 Climate change: Human activities VS natural climate variations?
Review lesson 1.1 and remind students of The greenhouse effect and its connection to climate change.
Introduce some current controversial debate on causes of climate change between climate scientists and some politically aligned groups (Slide 1).
Assign 3-4 students into small groups and ask them to interpret the provided evidence card#1,2,3,4 and answer questions along with each card(Slides 2-3)1.2 Evidence cards and questions for printing.
Reasoning with evidence (Slides 3-7)
The teacher summarizes two claims from the introductory text in the student worksheet
Claim 1: Human activities are the primary cause of the temperature increase over the last 100 years.
Claim 2: Natural processes are the main reason for the rise in temperature during the past century
Ask students to work in groups and draw supporting/ contradicting arrows between the evidence card and two claims and justify their arrows with CER.
Invite two groups to present their reasons
Teacher's demonstration and explanation of some answer examples (Slide 8).
🗣️ Discourse opportunity: Teacher presenting
🗣️ Discourse opportunity: Small group discussion
🗣️ Discourse opportunity: Small group discussion and whole class presentation
✅ Design principles -Argumentation.
🗣️Discourse opportunity: Teacher presenting
Background Knowledge
1.What is climate change and what causes it?
Climate change describes significant, long-term changes in Earth's temperature and weather systems. While natural factors like solar fluctuations and volcanic activity have historically influenced climate patterns, human activities (burning of fossil fuels like coal, oil and gas) have become the dominant cause of climate change since the Industrial Revolution (around the 1800s).
When we burn fossil fuels for energy invisible gases are released into the atmosphere. These greenhouse gases—primarily carbon dioxide (CO₂) and methane (CH₄)—act like a thick blanket wrapped around the Earth. Just as a blanket traps body heat to keep you warm, these gases trap the sun's energy, causing our planet's temperature to rise over time. The carbon dioxide in our atmosphere mainly comes from everyday human activities. For example, when we drive cars that run on gasoline or use coal to heat our homes and power our cities, we release CO₂ into the air. Another significant source is deforestation—when we cut down forests, we lose trees that naturally absorb CO₂, leaving more of this heat-trapping gas in the atmosphere. Methane is another powerful greenhouse gas, and it comes from sources like agriculture (especially from livestock like cows and from rice farming) and leaks in oil and gas operations. Though methane doesn’t stay in the air as long as CO₂, it traps much more heat in the short term, making it a major contributor to global warming.
Lesson Timing: This lesson needs preliminary knowledge learned from lesson 1.1.
Student Ideas & Experiences: Students can understand sources of greenhouse gases through everyday examples, such as transportation, home energy use, food production, manufacturing and industry, and so on. These experiences may have been connected in the lesson 1.1. This can reinforce the idea that human activities primarily cause the climate change.
Science Practices: Argumentation. In this lesson, students are introduced two alternative explanations of climate change and corresponding evidence from different sources. Students need to identify the relationships between the claims and evidence by drawing supporting or contradicting arrows and explain how. Integrating Evidence-Claim-Link (ECL) diagram and scaffolding multiple choice questions can help students combine their data analysis with evidence-based arguments construction.
Teaching Cases