COVID-19 and Mental Health Providers





Author: Amanda Johnson

We must diligently protect patients' mental health as well as the mental health of mental health providers during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Image source: Tim Mossholder on Unsplash

Mental Health Workforce and COVID-19

Many of us have experienced increased stress with the COVID-19 pandemic, leading to more visits to mental health providers. When we think of the COVID-19 impacts on the healthcare system, "frontline workers" are typically thought of first, but there's another part of the healthcare system that is being strained and greatly affected as a consequence of the COVID-19 pandemic. While this page will not necessarily have all of the solutions, the mental health workforce needs recognition and support as we continue navigating this pandemic. The information below highlights the change in mental health diagnoses and symptoms as well as mental health provider use throughout the COVID-19 pandemic with focus on how this has affected mental health providers. Possible strategies to assist the mental health workforce going forward are also suggested.

Image Source: dana.org

"I can't be both a really worried human and a good therapist at the same time."

~Yuki Yamazaki, Psychotherapist (NBC News, 2020)

Prefer PowerPoint with audio or written script over reading the webpage?

Check out this page's summary video or script of the audio below!

Video (4:58m)

COVID-19 & Mental Health Providers (script to video)

COVID-19 and Mental Health Providers

Author: Amanda Johnson

Slide 1: Hello! Thank you for listening. This PowerPoint is designed to be a quick summary of my webpage discussing the impact of COVID-19 on the mental health workforce. This project is part of my Master’s of Public Health course in Environmental Health.

Slide 2: So, let’s start broadly. Many of us feel and know that the COVID-19 pandemic has led to increased stress-kids are out of school, people are out of jobs, we are socially isolated, and so much more. This has led many to seek mental health services and the strain this pandemic has created on the mental health workforce needs to be addressed. While not thought of as the typical “frontline workers,” mental health providers are now under increased pressure.

Slide 3: Let’s quickly talk about some general numbers. Before COVID-19, about 20% of U.S. adults experienced mental health illnesses per year. After COVID-19, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation, 53% of adults are now experiencing negative mental health impacts as a result of the pandemic. The graph on the right side of the slide is one of the many graphs from the Kaiser Family Foundation’s website.

Slide 4: In terms of children and adolescents, prevalence of mental health disorders prior to the pandemic was 13.4%. Now, 40.1% of parents are observing signs of distress in their children and adolescents. The links below are from NPR talks in partnership with Buffalo-Toronto Public Media related to mental health and COVID-19. The first link is for the session on children and adolescents while the second link has their complete list of talks.

Slide 5: We should also spend some time on vulnerable populations and environmental justice. Certain populations are under more stress with the pandemic such as those with prior mental health diagnoses and “frontline workers,” to name a few. With COVID-19, those of color and those with marginalized gender identities needing mental health services are disproportionately being impacted by the pandemic and other events of 2020, such as the death of George Floyd, which is further widening gaps that were present prior to the pandemic.

Now, let’s put on our occupational health lens.

Slide 6: “It is not a matter of if but when the mental health consequences of the threat of disease, grief and loss, economic strain, and social changes resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic will overburden the mental health care system. Similar to calls for frontline workers, mental health providers need protection and support as they tackle the mental health wave of this pandemic and prepare for future events.”

The strain on our mental health workforce cannot be ignored.

Slide 7: Prior to COVID-19, mental health and substance use disorders formed the highest disease burden in the U.S. over all other conditions. With COVID-19, Disaster Distress Hotline calls have risen over 300%. Providers are negatively impacted in a variety of ways including those providers of color seeing increasing gaps to access of already marginalized populations, provider’s own fears about the pandemic, and “telehealth fatigue.”

Slide 8: To start, we can improve the mental health workforce strain by encouraging provider self-care, support groups, webinars, and ensure that those in the mental health workforce have their own mental health providers to support them through these challenging times.

Slide 9: However, while these solutions are good, they are likely somewhat of a “band-aid.” As we say in Public Health, let’s try to move further upstream to make bigger changes.

Slide 10: In moving more upstream, we can expand the mental health workforce-allow students to do telehealth visits, incorporate community members into screening and triage, as well as mobilize digital and artificial intelligence platforms. You could also think about pooling providers into bigger groups to divide the work.

Slide 11: With regard to vulnerable populations and environmental justice, there’s a call that the mental health workforce strain is a public health problem. The two groups need to join together to advocate for changes. Medicare is working on a coalition to improve coverage of mental health visits. Additionally, counseling support could be risk-stratified to be more equitable.

Slide 12: Policy changes are the furthest upstream interventions. We can push for accelerated skill development, job redeployment, incentivizing local job growth, and advocating for universal paid sick leave. We also need continued flexible insurance reimbursement to fund telehealth as well as allowing repayment plans for uninsured individuals to make access more equitable.

Slide 13: I hope you enjoyed this summary and if you are interested in learning more please check out my webpage for many great links and more information. Thank you!

"Society needs a cultural shift to understand that just because therapists aren't in hazmat suits in hospitals or exposing themselves to cashiers at grocery stores, that doesn't make them any less essential in this pandemic."

~Lori Gottlieb, Therapist and Author (NBC News, 2020)

COVID-19 Impacts on Adults

  • Prior to COVID-19, 20% of U.S. adults experienced mental health challenges per year1

  • Early in the pandemic, U.S. adults experiencing mental health challenges increased1

  • As of mid-July 2020, 53% of adults in the U.S. reported negative mental health impacts1

    • Negative impacts included difficulty sleeping, eating, increased alcohol and substance use, and worsening chronic conditions1

COVID-19 Impacts on Children and Adolescents

  • Children experience stress differently depending on their developmental stage2

      • Children from all developmental stages are experiencing high rates of depression, anxiety, and PTSD2

  • Prior to COVID-19, prevalence of child and adolescent mental illness was 13.4%3

  • During COVID-19, 40.1% of parents reported observing signs of distress in their children3

NPR (in partnership with Buffalo Toronto Public Media) held weekly sessions titled "Your Mental Health and COVID-19." Check out this conversation on child and adolescent mental health!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xD8nj9jqG6k

Here's the link to their full list of episodes:

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLBumZ_GCKREFEIfvv-iKVkVyWB-iskfNK

A Word on Vulnerable Populations and Environmental Justice

    • Certain populations have increased risk of mental health issues during the pandemic, including:

      • Those with prior mental health diagnoses

      • "Frontline" workers

    • People of color and people with marginalized gender identities in need of mental health services were already struggling due to the mental healthcare system operating in oppressive ways6

      • Some of these groups have been further stressed disproportionately with the pandemic and other events of 2020, such as the death of George Floyd

        • Following footage release of George Floyd's death, psychological distress symptoms in Blacks rose from 36% to 41%7

Image source: Washington Post

"It is not a matter of if but when the mental health consequences of the threat of disease, grief and loss, economic strain, and social changes resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic will overburden the mental health care system. Similar to calls for frontline workers, mental health providers need protection and support as they tackle the mental health wave of this pandemic and prepare for future events."4

How has COVID-19 affected the mental health workforce?

  • Prior to COVID-19, mental health and substance use disorders combined had a higher disease burden in the United States above that of any other health condition.4

  • With the onset of COVID-19 in March 2020, the Disaster Distress Hotline saw an increase in calls by 338%.5

  • A survey of over 100 mental health providers (licensed social workers, marriage and family therapists, counseling psychologists) in June-July 2020 found4:

    • The pandemic has negatively impacted their ability to provide mental health services given the negative impact of COVID-19 on their own mental health.

    • Providers feel distressed, depressed, anxious, isolated, and fearful

    • Providers are experiencing “telehealth fatigue”

  • Providers of color may feel even further strain as they try to help their communities who are now even further disproportionately impacted5

How do we address the strain on the mental health workforce?

  • We should specifically direct interventions and resources to the mental health workforce, including4:

    • Encourage self-care for those in the mental health workforce

    • Support groups

    • Webinars

    • Stress the importance of those in the mental health workforce having their own mental health provider

Moving Upstream

While the above interventions support the mental health workforce here and now, they are not longer term solutions and put a "band-aid" over a larger problem. In the field of public health, we use the term "moving upstream" to describe finding these bigger solutions.


Image source: Salud America

Improving the Strain on the Mental Health Workforce
(Moving Upstream)

The list below is not exhaustive, but illustrates many possibilities for further upstream interventions.

  • Expansion of the mental health workforce

    • Students can be trained for telephone, online, or mix of in-person and virtual visits to expand the available providers and allow more variability in services provided in the future4

    • Community outreach screening (members of the community/volunteers)8

    • Mobilize digital health interventions4

    • Form larger groups and split workload among all providers


  • Addressing already vulnerable populations and environmental justice4:

    • Form partnership between mental health workforce and public health workforce to improve mental health for all

      • Messaging

      • Education

      • Prevention

    • Medicare Mental Health Workforce Coalition aiming to have certain services billable to Medicare9

    • Risk-stratify crisis counseling support10


  • Policy and employer changes10:

    • Accelerated skill redevelopment

    • Job redeployment

    • Incentivizing investments in local job growth

    • Paid sick leave

    • Flexibility in reimbursement going forward (insured and uninsured)1,5

References

1 Panchal, N., Kamal, R., Orgera, K., Cox, C., Garfield, R., Hamel, L., Muñana, C., & Chidambaram, P. The Implications of COVID-19 for Mental Health and Substance Use. (2020). Kaiser Family Foundation. https://www.kff.org/coronavirus-covid-19/issue-brief/the-implications-of-covid-19-for-mental-health-and-substance-use/#:~:text=In%20a%20KFF%20Tracking%20Poll,was%20included%20in%20KFF%20polling.

2 Marques de Miranda, D., da Silva Athanasio, B., Oliveira, A.C.S., & Simoes-e-Silva, A.C. How is COVID-19 pandemic impacting mental health of children and adolescents? (2020). International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction. 51:101845. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2212420920313479

3 Racine, N., Cooke, J.E., Eirich, R., Korczak, D.J., McArthus, B., & Madigan, S. Child and adolescent mental illness during COVID-19: A rapid review. (2020). Psychiatry Research. 292:113307. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7363598/

4 Fish, J.N. & Mittal, M. Mental Health Providers During COVID-19: Essential to the US Public Health Workforce and in Need of Support. (2020). Public Health Reports. 00(0):1-4. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0033354920965266

5 Madani, D. Coronavirus: Therapists are under strain in COVID-19 era, counseling clients on trauma they're also experiencing themselves. (2020). NBC News. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/therapists-are-under-strain-covid-era-counseling-clients-trauma-they-n1230956

6 Altiraifi, A. & Rapfogel, N. Mental Health Care Was Severely Inequitable, Then Came the Coronavirus Crisis. (2020). Center for American Progress: Disability. https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/disability/reports/2020/09/10/490221/mental-health-care-severely-inequitable-came-coronavirus-crisis/

7 Fowers, A. & Wan, W. Depression and anxiety spiked among black Americans after George Floyd’s death. (2020). The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2020/06/12/mental-health-george-floyd-census/?arc404=true

8 Moreno, C., Wykes, T., Galderisi, S., Nordentoft, M., Crossley, N., Jones, N., et al. How mental health care should change as a consequence of the COVID-19 pandemic. (2020). The Lancet: Psychiatry: Position Paper. 7(9):813-824. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpsy/article/PIIS2215-0366(20)30307-2/fulltext

9 NBCC: COVID-19 Information Page. Medicare Mental Health Workforce Coalition. (2020). https://www.nbcc.org/resources/nccs/newsletter/medicare-mental-health-workforce-coalition

10 Coe, E.H. & Enomoto, K. Returning to resilience: The impact of COVID-19 on mental health and substance use. (2020). McKinsey & Company: Healthcare Systems & Services. https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/healthcare-systems-and-services/our-insights/returning-to-resilience-the-impact-of-covid-19-on-behavioral-health#

Interested in reading more?

"A holistic approach for the US behavioral health crisis during the COVID-19 pandemic." (2020). Coe, E., Crystal, L., Enomoto, K., & Lewis, R. McKinsey & Company.

"Hidden Inequalities: COVID-19's Impact on our Mental Health Workforce." (2020). Youn, S.J., Creed, T.A., Stirman, S.W., & Marques, L. Anxiety and Depression Association of America.

"Ensuring Access to Mental Health Services During the Pandemic and Beyond." (2020). Beck, A. University of Michigan School of Public Health.

"I may not be there yet, but I am closer than I was yesterday."

~José N. Harris

Image source: Chevon Beckley for United Nations Call Out to Creatives on Unsplash