Hittite Anatolia (1700-1200 BC) produced the most extensive textual corpus of cult festivals of antiquity. Festivals are also reflected in several archaeological datasets. Both sources are highly relevant to the study of cult practices and religious experience. However, they have never been the object of a systematic comparative investigation. The project The art of the stage in Bronze Age Anatolia (2023-2025) hinges on the analytical integration of texts and images within the framework of current anthropological perspectives on the sensory environment. We plan to explore the role of Hittite festivals as ‘total social facts’ (M. Mauss), creating deeply affective atmospheres. In doing so, we pursue a multiproxy approach, ie, we use multiple lines of proxy evidence simultaneously in a coordinated theoretical framework. The focus is on two intersecting case studies, the festivals of the sacred city of Arinna attested in the Hittite textual record, and the material remains at the site of Alacahöyük (Turkey) which, considered in their broader context and comparative perspective, provide highly representative datasets.
The research program is multiscalar, with three main objectives built on each other: (1) a parallel analysis of the cuneiform texts on the cults of Arinna and the material remains connected with religious activity at Late Bronze Age Alacahöyük, (2) the development of a methodology for the combined study of Hittite written and material evidence and its digital management, with particular regard to terminological interoperability and the analysis of spatial and temporal aspects, and (3) an interdisciplinary reconstruction of Hittite festivals in the city of Arinna and at the site of Alacahöyük. The planned outputs include critical editions of the festivals of Arinna, a detailed reappraisal of the Sphinx Gate of Alacahöyük, an open digital archive for the combined analysis of textual and visual evidence, and a comparative, anthropologically informed analysis of the religious festivals at Arinna and Alacahöyük. Outreach modules targeting education and research will produce a scale model of the Sphinx Gate at Alacahöyük and graphic information panels, to be realized by middle and high schoolers within a dedicated pedagogical program pursued in collaboration with the Museo Orientale Umberto Scerrato and the NPO Maestri di Strada (Naples).
Project Das Corpus der hethitischen Festrituale. Staatliche Verwaltung des Kultwesens im spätbronzezeitlichen Anatolien (German Academy Programme; Philipps-Universität Marburg, Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg, Akademie der Wissenschaften und der Literatur Mainz)
Graduiertenkolleg 2844 Inszenierung religiöser Atmosphäre in antiken Kulturen (Philipps-Universität Marburg)
Maestri di Strada ONLUS, Naples
View/download here the programme
View/download the book of abstracts
The concept of ‘atmosphere’, initially developed within the fields of phenomenology and aesthetics and later applied to other disciplines such as architecture, sociology, human geography, and theology, is now beginning to be employed also in the study of the history of religions. The historian of religions Martin Radermacher suggests understanding atmospheres as “the realized sensory, affective and semantic potential of socio-spatial arrangements”, that facilitate semantic attributions, reduce complexity, and stabilize social and communicative systems (Religion und Atmosphäre, 2024, 18, our translation).
Of particular interest for applying the concept of atmospheres to the study of past civilizations is the approach proposed by the German philosopher Gernot Böhme, where atmospheres are examined from the perspective of the production aesthetics, or, in Platonic terms, of τέχνη φανταστική. In this way, they are related to the paradigm of the ‘art of the stage’: the design of spatial, material and sensory arrangements aimed at eliciting, under specific conditions, certain sensations in participants (for a concise account, see his paper The art of the stage set as a paradigm for an aesthetics of atmospheres, 2013). The potential for applying this approach to ancient cultures is highlighted by today’s developments exploring sensory dimensions, cf. the spatial, somatic, affective, or material ‘turns’, and by new data and perspectives from disciplines such as anthropology, ethnoarchaeology, archaeobotany, archaeomusicology, visual studies, performance studies, and festive studies. A particularly fruitful area for exploring atmospheres in the ancient Near Eastern world, including in Hittite Anatolia, is the cultic sphere, for which an extensive and rich corpus of textual and material sources is available.
The project The Art of Stage in Late Bronze Age Anatolia aims to contribute to the reconstruction of Hittite religious atmospheres through the dual case study of the cults of the sacred city of Arinna, as known from written sources, and the Sphinx Gate at the site of Alacahöyük. The conference seeks to present the main findings achieved within the project while situating them within the broader context of the ancient Near East, and to place the chosen case studies and methodological approach in dialogue with other case studies and perspectives.
January 21/2025, 17:00-18:30
Institutional greetings
17:30 Keynote lecture
Ignazio Buttitta (Università degli Studi of Palermo),
Analizzare il simbolismo festivo: una prospettiva storico comparativa (Analyzing Festive Symbolism: A Historical-Comparative Perspective)
January 22/2025
10:00-12:30 Morning session: The visual evidence. Chair: Elena Rova (Ca’ Foscari University of Venice)
10:15-10:35 Dirk Paul Mielke (University of Münster), Hittite relief pottery: content, contexts and significance
10:45-11:05 Clelia Mora (University of Pavia), Miniature reproductions of stage performances?
11:35-11:55 Tayfun Yıldırım (Ankara University), New thoughts about the scenes depicted in the Alaca Höyük reliefs
12:05-12:30 Round table. Discussant: Marina Pucci (University of Florence)
15:00-18:00 Afternoon session: The textual evidence. Chair: Michele Cammarosano (University of Naples L'Orientale)
15:15-15:35 Andrey Shatskov (University of Naples L'Orientale), The reconstruction of the text of the Great Festival of Arinna (CTH 634)
15:45-16:05 Charles Steitler (Akademie der Wissenschaften und der Literatur Mainz), Arinna and the Formation of the Itinerant AN.DAḪ.ŠUM Festival
16:30-16:50 Adam Kryszen (Philipps-Universität Marburg), Autumn in Arinna. Religious Topography in Hittite Texts
17:00-17:30 Round table. Discussant: Massimo Maiocchi (Ca’ Foscari University of Venice)
17:30-18:00 Conclusion and Hands-On Session with KWANZA! digital tool
Chair: Giovanna Gambacurta (Università Ca’ Foscari Venezia) / Alessandra Gilibert (Università Ca’ Foscari Venezia)
9:30-9:45 Introduzione
9:45-10:05 Elena Rova (Università Ca’ Foscari Venezia), Never-ending images or chunks of images: which story do ancient Near Eastern seal images tell us? Immagini infinite o spezzoni di immagini: che storia ci raccontano i sigilli dell'antico Vicino Oriente?
10:15-10:35 Michele Cammarosano (Università di Napoli L’Orientale) / Alessandra Gilibert (Università Ca’ Foscari Venezia) / Elisa Girotto (Università Ca’ Foscari Venezia) / Renzo Orsini (Università Ca’ Foscari Venezia) / Andrey Shatskov (Università di Napoli L’Orientale), L’arte ittita dello spettacolo: come integrare fonti visuali e fonti scritte con Kwanza!
10:45-11:05 Massimo Maiocchi, Sull'importanza di leggere le scene narrative mesopotamiche nella lingua che le ha prodotte: alcune riflessioni sui sigilli di epoca sargonica
11:35-11:55 Giovanna Gambacurta (Università Ca’ Foscari Venezia), Luca Zaghetto, Il linguaggio dell'Arte delle situle tra Oriente e Occidente: appunti di metodo
12:05-12:25 Elisa Rossberger (Freie Universität Berlin)
12:35-13:00 discussione: Giovanna Gambacurta, Alessandra Gilibert
Mostra Fabulae - Museo di Storia Naturale e Archeologia di Montebelluna
14:20 treno per Montebelluna - 19:20 rientro a Venezia
Ore 9.00
Saluti istituzionali e introduzione
Ore 9:15. Presiede Gioele Zisa
Sebastiano Mannia, Università degli Studi di Palermo - Michele Cammarosano, Università degli Studi di Napoli L’Orientale - Alessandra Gilibert, Università Cà Foscari Venezia, Presentazione del Progetto PRIN 2022 The art of the stage in Bronze Age Anatolia. Reconstructing Hittite festivals using texts, images and comparative cultural anthropological evidence
Ore 10:00 Michael Jursa, Universität Wien, La messa in scena dell’incontro con il divino nella Babilonia dell’età del ferro
Ore 10:30 Lorenzo Verderame, Università degli Studi di Roma La Sapienza, Tempo e spazio nella celebrazione del capodanno babilonese (akītu)
Ore 11:30 Annunziata Rositani, Università degli Studi di Messina, La misurazione del tempo a Sippar durante il periodo paleo-babilonese: aspetti storici e religiosi
Ore 12:00 Angelo Colonna, Università degli Studi di Pisa, Scenari e riti festivi nell’Egitto protodinastico: paesaggi, performance, società e memoria
Ore 15. Presiede Rosario Perricone
Ignazio Buttitta, Università degli Studi di Palermo, Lo studio dei calendari festivi alla luce del metodo storico-comparativo
Ore 15:30 Alessandro Lupo, Università degli Studi di Roma La Sapienza, I calendari indigeni mesoamericani e il cristianesimo: una lunga storia di conflitto, fraintendimento e persistenza
Ore 16:00 Fabio Mugnaini, Università degli Studi di Siena, Festa e patrimonio. Tradizione e politica del festivo in Toscana
The research involved a re-examination of the excavation reports and iconographic studies on the Sphinx Gate. Over forty sculptures were catalogued and digitally redrawn based on superimposed past drawings and photographs. Topographical plans and elevations of the monument and the site were digitally traced based on published excavations reports and studies. This work permitted testing possible reconstruction of the monument’s original appearance. Work on the topographic maps helped study the monument in relation to other buildings and features (e.g. springs), in the course of history. New hypotheses emerged regarding the meanings of the scenes. Acrobats and musicians may have staged mythic episodes, for example, those related to the hunting scenes. A nude youth could have been involved in an initiation ceremony into the royal bodyguards. The “Hathoric” sphinx type may be connected to the cult of groundwater, in relation to the presence of springs at the site. The block with the charging bull may have featured hollow cup marks on its top and possibly served as the base of a statue. Emphasis was placed on the prominent role of the royal guards in the ceremonies and visual account. The plant in the hunting scene could be the Fritillaria imperialis.
The critical edition of the Great Festival of Arinna comprises a total of 49 fragments. The festival was performed in Arinna and extended over three days, during which the king and queen visited several temples—among them those of the Sun-goddess, the Storm-god, and Mezzulla—and held the Great Assembly. Although the full text cannot be reconstructed, the surviving fragments describe animal sacrifices and offerings to various sacred loci, ceremonies performed at temple entrances and on the roof of the Sun-goddess’s temple, as well as preparations for the Great Assembly and libations to the deities. Certain rituals appear to have been repeated, likely at different locations. Moreover, the recurrence of the Great Assembly’s elements at both the beginning and the end of KUB 20.76+, with only minor variations, suggests that the Assembly was held twice during the Great Festival of Arinna, most probably on two consecutive days.
The Kwanza! system (a Luwian imperative meaning both ‘draw!’ and ‘write!’, from the Indo-European root *Kwels-) provides a framework for producing, managing and querying structured datasets combining information from both visual and textual evidence. It is developed by Renzo Orsini in collaboration with the Naples & Venice project teams.
The conceptual-logical adopted in the system uses rules-constrained Descriptions, which are made up of Descriptors drawn from a Descriptors Dictionary.
By combining the two core relations of specialization and context, adopting a formal yet simple syntax, supporting uncertainty in data, and enabling easy data entry, the Kwanza! system offers both great flexibility of application and the sophistication needed to capture and query complex relational structures – something not achievable with simple tag-based systems, yet without the rigidity and complexity of ontologies.
The outreach module Un presepe ittita ('A Hittite Nativity Scene'), coordinated by Laura Noviello, involves fourth-grade pupils from the Istituto Comprensivo 83° Porchiano Bordiga in Naples–Ponticelli, in collaboration with the ONG Maestri di Strada and EST - Educazione Sogno Territorio (Giovanna Castiello, Francesca Cirella, Fortuna Esposito, Cira Maddaloni).
One of the most distinctive features of Hittite culture is its extraordinarily rich variety of religious celebrations and their unique atmospheres. These festivals were sometimes represented through miniature depictions, which provide a fascinating point of comparison with the Neapolitan art of the nativity scene. Building on this parallel, the project aims both to introduce participants to the world of the Hittites and to actively engage local students through hands-on creative and craft activities.
The programme includes theoretical sessions, led by Hittitologists, music archaeologists, and master nativity artisans, designed to provide historical, archaeological, anthropological, and design context, as well as practical workshops, in which students will work with expert craftsmen to create a “Hittite Nativity Scene” — from shaping the scenery to modelling the figures.
The main goals are to:
– Foster understanding of Hittite culture and its festive traditions through archaeological, iconographic, and textual sources while involving schoolchildren in a multidisciplinary learning experience alongside researchers and specialists;
– Promote a cultural dialogue between Hittite festive imagery and the Neapolitan nativity art;
– Engage local students in an educational and creative process that brings together history, archaeology, and craftsmanship.