One of the hardest parts of dismantling racism is addressing when you mess up. Sometimes, you mess up and someone else tells you. But a lot of the time, you mess up and never know you've done harm.
Addressing the harm we do has two parts:
Apologizing when you're told you've done harm;
Becoming aware of the subtle ways you do harm.
As White folks, we need to apologize often because messing up is likely. What does a good apology look like? Franchesca Ramsey (Chescaleigh) is a YouTuber and writer known for hosting the MTV show Decoded (so many helpful videos!). In the video below, she breaks down what a solid, meaningful apology looks like:
In a journal or in conversation with another White person doing this work:
Practice apologizing. How would you apologize for the following situations?
You made a joke about your friend making a mistake and they are offended.
You laughed at a time when a friend shared something serious and personal.
You asked a question you didn’t realize was offensive about your friend's race.
You said something hurtful to your friend, but you heard about it from a different friend.
Imagine you're with friends and one of your friends begins to bully a classmate.
What are three different responses (good or bad) you could have to this situation?
In order to apologize for harm you've caused, you have to be aware you've caused harm. Some harmful behaviors, like the examples in the activity above, are easy to see because they upset or harm someone directly. However, there are other kinds of harm that can be harder to see. Sometimes, harm isn't caused because you acted a certain way, but because you did nothing at all. You had the power and privilege in a situation, but you chose to do nothing with it.
The graphics below explain more about the choices we make to act or not act on our power and privilege:
Match the scenario with the use of power: abuse, complicity, or allyship.
Because White Supremacy Culture is characterized by fear of conflict, we often choose complicity. While complicity isn't actively racist, it does uphold racist systems. The graphics below will help you understand more about how to identify complicity, why it's harmful, and how to avoid it.
Remember that you're only anti-racist when you're taking anti-racist actions. If you choose to stand up to racism one moment you might be anti-racist in that moment, but if you later choose complicity you are no longer being anti-racist. As Dr. Bettina Love states, "A co-conspirator functions as a verb, not a noun." Anti-racism is not an identity or status that you achieve; it is a set of actions you commit to every day.
In a journal or in conversation with another White person doing this work, ask yourself:
What is a situation in which I have been complicit?
Is there a time I didn't speak up when I saw something racist or oppressive?
Is there a policy I know is unfair but I've never said anything about it?
Have I ever simply accepted that I've been treated better because of White privilege?
What could I have done differently?
What feelings made it hard for me to take action?
Complicity is only one of the subtle ways that White folks can cause harm. There are some other predictable mistakes we can make as well.
Some of the behaviors we have to watch out for are:
Cultural Appropriation - using the customs, language, fashion, behaviors, traditions, or practices of a marginalized group to your benefit without acknowledging and learning from the culture
Microaggressions - subtle actions or statements that cause harm because they remind marginalized people of their experiences with discrimination
Performative Allyship - participating in activism for the recognition as a "good person" publicly, rather than to actually improve the world
White Saviorism - participating in actions you believe will rescue BIPOC people from their bad situations, making you the hero
White Fragility - becoming defensive, guilty, or aggressive when your own racism or privilege is pointed out
Validation-Seeking - taking actions to prove that you are a "good" White person and expecting acknowledgement for doing these action and having good intentions
Any of these sound familiar? It's important to make sure you can recognize and prevent these behaviors from harming others. In order to do this, we can use SOS:
Have you ever done any of the following:
Ended a sentence with "periodt" or asked someone to "spill the tea?"
Gotten cornrows on a tropical vacation?
Worn a feather on your head to dress up as a Native American?
Did you know... (Click to reveal!)
The terms "periodt" and "tea" originated in the Black gay community decades ago?
Cornrows are a protective hairstyle for Black hair?
Feathers are a symbol of high honor in many Indigenous communities?
Have you ever done any of the following:
Felt nervous in the presence of a Black man?
Assumed someone spoke a different language because of their appearance?
Made a joke or statement about Asians being good at math or Black people being athletic?
When you post about Black Lives Matter on social media, what are your motivators?
What do you hope to accomplish by posting?
Imagine a you notice a situation where a teacher is treating a Black student unfairly. The Black student has said they want to leave it alone, but you really think someone should report it. What should you do?
How do you react when someone tells you you've done something racist, privileged, or harmful?
Imagine a situation where your White friend says something about Indians that your Indian friend says is offensive. Your Indian friend gets mad and tells your White friend off. What would you do?
In a journal or in conversation with another White person doing this work, ask yourself:
Which of the behaviors above have I done?
Cultural Appropriation
Microaggression
Performative Allyship
White Saviorism
White Fragility
Validation-Seeking
Why do you think you did those behaviors?
What do you need to do to change those behaviors in yourself?
You've spent a lot of time today reflecting on behaviors you might not be so proud of. Don't go into a guilt and shame spiral! Remind yourself that we can only do better when we know better. You know how to apologize where you've done harm and you have a better eye to see when you might be acting problematically.
If this has left you feeling a little emotional, return to the NICE Method:
Name your emotions and what triggered them
Investigate the thoughts that created them
Clarify how you can and will respond
Emerge ready to turn feelings into action
Then, remind yourself that now you can do better!
WEEK 5: OWN UP
Impact: how your action affects others
Intention: how you meant for your actions to affect others
Complicity: being involved in, helping, or knowing about (but not stopping) wrongdoing, like not speaking up against racism
Cultural Appropriation: using the customs, language, fashion, behaviors, traditions, or practices of a marginalized group to your benefit without acknowledging and learning from the culture
Microaggressions: subtle actions or statements that cause harm because they remind marginalized people of their experiences with discrimination
Performative Allyship: participating in activism for the recognition as a "good person" publicly, rather than to actually improve the world
White Saviorism: participating in actions you believe will rescue BIPOC people from their bad situations, making you the hero
White Fragility: becoming defensive, guilty, or aggressive when you own racism or privilege is pointed out
Validation-Seeking: taking actions to prove that you are a "good" white person and expecting acknowledgement for doing these action and having good intentions
WEEK 4: ACT ON IT
Internal Work: the work we do on ourselves to become better people and co-conspirators
External Work: the work we do in our communities and societies to make the world a better place
WEEK 3: PROCESS THE FEELS
White Supremacy Culture: the attitudes, values, beliefs, and ways of being created to justify and uphold racism and keep White folks in power
Decentering: taking privileged groups out of the spotlight to focus on the experiences, feelings, and needs of marginalized groups
WEEK 2: UNPACK YOUR PRIVILEGE
Dominant Culture: groups of people labeled as "normal" in a society because they have the most power to say what's normal because they historically have the power to make the laws
Subordinate Culture: groups of people who don't fit the narrow definition of "normal" created by the dominant culture
Privilege: the benefits people get from holding an identity that is part of the dominant culture
Marginalized: when a group of people is treated as insignificant, powerless, or lesser because of their identity
White Privilege: the benefits White people get simply for being White
Common Decency: the opportunity, kindness, and trust given to privileged people that everyone else should have
Unearned Power: imbalances of power that allow privileged people to get away with harmful actions.
WEEK 1: WHERE ARE YOU?
White Supremacy: the ways that our society is built to create a hierarchy with White folks on top. It is the ways the laws, norms, and expectations of our society put White people first, while harming Black people , Indigenous people, and People of Color (BIPOC).
Oppression: unjust treatment and harm over a long time due to your belonging to a group that has less power.
Interpersonal Harm: hurt done by one person to another.
Systemic Oppression: harm done by systems like laws, institutions (education, medicine, prison), and societal norms
Anti-Racism: actively working to end systemic racism by changing your thoughts, actions, and the society around you
Active Ally: someone who is against racism, mostly in their thoughts and words
Accomplice: someone who is against racism through their actions and behaviors
Co-conspirator: someone who is actively working with BIPOC communities to end racism by taking risks in their daily lives
Talk: Find someone White in your life to talk through some situations you might find yourself in where you'd be tempted to be complicit or fall back on harmful behaviors. Together, brainstorm how you would handle those situations differently as a co-conspirator.
Learn: Check out one of the following: MTV Decoded (videos), Teen Vogue (articles) on racism, NPR CodeSwitch (podcast), or The Power Book by Roxane Gay (book).
Act: Look into getting more involved with making policies in your community. You can do this at your school by finding out how students can get involved in policy decisions (student council, PTA, or contacting your principal). You can also do this in your community outside of school by finding out when and how you can participate in City Council Meetings, School District Council Meetings, and/or local grassroots organizations where you can bring a young voice to the issues coming up in your community. Find a way to be more proactive in your community (and less complicit!).