Thatcher Park
Kaden Borgman, Savannah Summerskill, JJ McCrandall, JJ Houseman
Kaden Borgman, Savannah Summerskill, JJ McCrandall, JJ Houseman
We are studying the health of Crockery Creek at Thatcher Park. Thatcher Park is a public park located in our town of Ravenna. It is a very popular park in the area. This creek is mostly sand with a lot of vegetation on the shores. Rocks are scattered on the shore and throughout the creek. Potential sources of pollution could be caused by suburban runoff, rain, and sediment runoff, or maybe septic tanks that are not working in the area. This park is also located in our small downtown, which could have left over industrial runoff.
We tested the water for pH, conductivity, salinity, and total dissolved solids. We also tested for E. coli and collected macroinvertebrates. The methods we used to collect data were to test the stream water for E. Coli using the left, right, and center method. We gathered our macroinvertebrates by checking leaf packs and moving rocks in the water, to gather sample insect populations. The water quality tests were conducted using a PCTS Testr 50. We used a turbidity tube to determine the turbidity levels. We used a GeoPack flow meter to determine the stream flow of the creek. While onsite, we wrote down the data that we collected in our field books, then we returned to the classroom and imported it into a Google form, which filled out a plot chart for us to show our data with both present and past dates.
We analyzed the data by having Dr. Buday explain what the good ranges are and some reasons changes could have happened. The claim my group has made is that the reason the E. coli levels are lower in the spring vs the fall is because the water is cooler, and the E. coli grows better in warm water. The reason that we get more macroinvertebrates in the fall is that the water is warmer and the bugs are more active, which makes it easier for us to locate them as they move.
Questions we still have about the health of our stream site include:
Are fish and insect populations increasing, decreasing, or staying the same over time?
Does the E. coli data have anything to do with the weather and season, or even the temperature around the stream?
Why is the population of the scud so high in our stream?
The temperature has stayed the fairly consistent on all testing dates, besides 4/28/25 when it jumped up very high.
The conductivity stayed in the mid-range the whole time, but it appears to be slowly increasing.
The salinity has stayed very consistent and is in a safe range. Early in our testing schedule, there were two very high sets, which may have been due to winter salt applications.
The pH has stayed very high throughout testing. We are unsure as to a reason for these results at this time.
The turbidity has been very good and consistent throughout the years.
TDS has been in an acceptable range. We just began testing for TDS this year, so we are just adding data to this category.
E. Coli has decreased over time. This is possibly due to it being spring, better filtering, less runoff or more awareness of area farmers.
The macroinvertebrate counts were not as high as last fall's numbers, possibly due to the spring, and the bugs are just starting to move
The flow rate of our site varies by season, but it appears to be increasing over time.
The water quality rating at this site has varied over time. It started as a 4.5, which is in the "Good" range. However, it spiked to a 7.4, qualifying it as "Fairly Poor.' It has recently returned to the "Very Good" range.
JJ Houseman and JJ McCrandall sorting macroinvertebrates
Savannah Summerskill preparing to collect data and macroinvertebrates
JJ Houseman identifying fish
Kaden Borgman identifying and sorting macroinvertebrates
Takeaways from this data is that the conductivity, turbidity, and pH have all stayed decently similar/the same throughout the three testing seasons. The data we have collected over time shows that our water has been over all of the standard minimums every time, making it unsafe for full-body contact. Finally, the outstanding amounts of salinity in the water during the fall of 2023 testing time, we would like to look into the causes of this more by continuing to review the data during the time of this incident.
Collecting insects
Testing different types of water.
Sorting different bugs
Finished water testing for the day.
Thatcher Park is a public park located in our town of Ravenna. It is a very popular park in the area. We have been testing the water in Crockery Creek that runs through this park. This creek is mostly sand with a lot of vegetation on the shores. Rocks are scattered on the shore and throughout the creek. Through our testing, we have learned that this water exceeds the set standards for full-body contact and partial-body contact. This could be caused by suburban runoff, rain, and sediment runoff, or maybe septic tanks that are not working in the area.
During October, we went to our test sites regularly to collect samples, as well as measurements like water flow, conductivity, salinity, temperature, pH, and turbidity, then we went back to our classroom to turn these samples and data in. The E. coli samples were then taken to Grand Valley State University, where they were examined and the results sent back to us. After receiving the information from them, and the measurements we took, we were able to calculate the quality and situation of the water. During our research, we were able to gain more knowledge about our water and understand how many more aspects impact the water that we depend on daily.
We would like to thank the GVSU Department of Geology for providing us with equipment to take our measurements; Dr. Amanda Buday for her leadership; Brendan from AWRI's WET Lab for helping us conduct E. Coli tests, the Ravenna Conservation Club for paying for our E. Coli testing, and Swanson Pickle Company for buying our waders and dipnets.
To look at the rest of the tests and findings click on the small tabs above this text.