After the expansion of Yahoo's database and the ability to view complete past team logs, a Pioneer League Hall of Fame was created to honor players with the greatest contributions to each individual manager's teams. The requirements to become enshrined in these Halls of Fame are:
A least four seasons of 100+ points scored for a single manager.
At least 1,000 career points scored for that same manager.
With this in mind, each active manager began his own Hall of Fame in 2021.