Cambrian:
Cambrian:
Opabinia is a extinct stem and soft bodied arthropod that existed around Wuliuan stage of the middle Cambrian (505 million years ago). The remains can be found in burgress shale formation in British Columbia, Canada. Opabinia are measured in 7-10 centimetres in body length. They are only one species of opabinia called O.Regalis (Walcott in 1912). There was proposed second species of opabinia called O.Norilica but is considered to be unconfirmed and mostly likely invalid.Â
Opabinia fossils can be found in the burgress shale formation in British Columbia, Canada. It is located near the town of Field in Yoho Community Park and the Kicking Horse Pass. The formation also contains other arthropods and early Cambrian animals such as Anomalocaris, Hallucigenia and trilobites.Â
specimen of Opabinia at the top left or (1)
Harry Blackmore Whittington at the left and Dorothy Whittington at the right standing near the Burgess Pass Trail
Opabinia was first discovered by Charles Doolittle Walcott in 1911 on the burgess shale formation when he found nine complete fossils of opabinia. He described the specimens called Opabinia Regalis in 1912. In 1966 to 1967, Harry Blackmore Whittington surprisingly found good specimen of opabinia which led him to make a descriptive paper on how the animal look in different angles in 1975.Â
 In 1960, Russian palaeontologists found proposed second species of opabinia fossils in the Norilsky region of Siberia. However, Whittington considered the second species to be unconformable due to poor preserve fossils of the specimen and lack of data that helps to confirms the specimen to be second species of the opabinia.
Holotype specimen of Opabinia that displayed at the Smithsonian in Washington, D.C.
long and Opabiniidae is an extinct family group of stem marine arthropod that existed around the Cambrian to the Ordovician (507-475 million years).Â
Opabinia is characterised by its bizarre features: long and monstrous anterior proboscis, five eyes on top of its head, elongate body that covered with wide swimming appendages and tail with overlapping flaps. They use their swimming appendages to navigate around the ocean as they push through the oceans in a wave like motion. Opabinia possesses long vacuum like tube that ends with claw like mouth that contains five spines that are projected forward and backward. It is proposed that its strange proboscis could be flexible enough to move around to inspect around its environment to seek out prey.
Opabinia (top) and Utaurora (bottom) are part of the OpabiniidaeÂ
Proposed mobility of opabinia proboscis
Permian:
Inostrancevia is a extinct genus of large carnivorous therapsids (Proto-mammals, therapsids or Stem mammals) that lived around the Late Permian (around Wuchiapingian to Changhsingian stage, 250 million years ago). Inostrancevia remains can be found in Europe, Russia and South Africa. They were estimated between around 3 metres and 3.5 metres in length depending on the specimens, 15 centimetres for their large sabre-teeth and weigh around 500 kilograms. They are four species of Inostrancevia called I.Alexandri (described by Amalitsky in 1922), I.Uralensis (described by Tatarinow in 1974), I.Latifrons (described by Pravoslavlev in 1927)Â and I.Africana (described by Kammerer in 2023).
Inostrancevia remains can be found in Balfour formation, located on hillsides of Nieu-Bethesda in Eastern Cape, South Africa which also contains other species of synapsids (Charassognathus and Moschorhinus).Â
Lectotype skeleton of Inostrancevia.Alexandri
Skeleton of Inostrancevia.Alexandri
Upper Skull of Inostrancevia.Alexandri
Large canines of Inostrancevia.Alexandri
During the 1890s, Russian palaeontologist Vladmir Prokhorovich Amalitsky discovered fossil skeletons remains of new genus, found on creek in a bank escarpment which is dated from Permian period in Northern Dvina, Arkhangelsk Oblast in Northern European Russia which was most important discoveries in late 19th and early 20th century as Permian fossils were only found in South Africa an India. Amalitsky conducted systemic research with his partner Anne P Amalitsky in Russia which he sent several findings of fossils of unknown animal to Warsaw, Poland in order to study the fossils. The process of collecting fossils on the creek lasted until 1914 due to the start of World War 1, they were taken to the Museum of Geology and Mineralogy of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Amalitsky had to take administrative activities and deal with difficult conditions which hindered his progress of fossil research in his last years before he unexpectedly died in 1917, he was able to collect two complete specimen skeletons of large gorgonopsids called Inostrancevia alexandri which he already proposed its species and genus name before he made a description of animal and, a published posthumously was made in 1922 after his death. The two skeletons were sent to the Instituite of Paleontology of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Despite not mentioning of the animal name origins, The name of Inostrancevia, was to honour of the renowned geologist Alexander Inostrantsev who was Amalitsky teacher.
 In 1927, One of Amalitsky colleagues, Pavel A Pravoslavlev, published the first formal description of the genus in which he mentions about the two known skeletons of Inostrancevia alexandri and several other species of animals that Amalitsky found during his find. However, Inostrancevia.Latifrons was the only recognised distinct species within the genus as it was only based on skulls discovered by Arkhangelsk Oblast which also contained incomplete skeleton from the village of Zavrazhye, located in Vladmir Oblast. In 1974, Leonid Tatarinov described the third species of Inostrancevia called I.uralensis which were based on rare remains of part of the skull from an smaller specimen than the other two species of Inostrancevia, located in Ural River, Orenburg Oblast. In 2023, the fourth species of Inostrancevia is called I.Africana which were based on two specimens found between 2010 and 2011 by Nthaopa Ntheri and John Nyaphuil at Nooitgedacht farm in the Karoo Basin, South Africa. The Two specimen found in Balfour formation were called "holotype NMQR 4000 and paratype NMQR 3707". In the same year, Christian F. Kammerer and his colleagues publish a revision on which confirms the two specimens of genus Inostrancevia were related to each other but, the Russian and African specimen were different enough to class themselves as their own valid species.Â
Vladmir Prokhorovich Amalitsky (1860-1917)Â
Leonid Petrovich Tatarinov (1926-2011)
Henry Neville Hutchinson (1856-1927)
Gorgonopsia is an extinct clade of sabre-toothed stem mammals that existed around middle to late Permian.Â
Inostrancevia has typical features of gorgonopsid: large and long sabre-teeth like canine on the upper and lower jaw used to bite down on prey during hunting, slender quadruped that have short legs which helped them to be more agile than their prey which still restrain their reptile like body type which showed on how predators and prey evolve together to survive and, they also posses long and narrow skull. Inostrancevia were the largest gorgonpsid species as there were size of tiger which makes them the apex predator of Pangea during Permian period. Inostrancevia posses mammalian like characteristics that are similar to modern mammals like large canine like sabre teeth that are found in sabre tooth mammals like famous sabre-toothed cat, limbs that were oriented underneath the body than sideways like reptile and they were warm blooded.
There is no evidence that Inostrancevia lived or cooperate in groups so it most likely that there were solitary hunters. They possess smooth like skin similar to hairless mammal and frog. Perhaps they may have primitive fur like structures that would evolve further to create new group of animals called mammals.
Triassic:
Erythrosuchus is an extinct genus of erythrosuchid archosauriform that existed around the Olenekian to Anisian stage of Early to Middle Triassic. Erythrosuchus remains can be found in South Africa. They are estimated to be around 5 metres long and weigh around 2 tonnes. There is only one species of erythrosuchus called E. Africanus (described by Broom in 1905).Â
Erythrosuchus remains can be found in the Omingonde formation as part of the Cynognathus Assemblage Zone in the Karoo Basin of South Africa in Namibia. It is located in the western Otjozondjupa Region and north-eastern Erongo Region of north-central Namibia. The formation also contains therapsids (Kannemeyeria and Cynognathus) and group of prehistoric amphibians called Mastodonsauridae.Â
Skull of erythrosuchusÂ
Fragmentary remains of erythrosuchus limb bones
Fragmentary remains of erythrosuchus vertebrae
The first erythrosuchus fossils were discovered by Robert Broom in 1905 as holotype of the specimen called SAM 905 had fragmentary remains which contained limbs, pectoral, pelvic girdles, skull and a few vertebrae. In 1911, the genus of the animal was described by German palaeontologist Friedrich Von Huene before he housed the remains in Natural History museum in London. In 1963, a complete skull was found in South Africa known as BPI 5207 that showed the true appearance of the animal head. The skull remain was sent to the Bernard Price Institute for Paleontological Research in South Africa as part of the collection.Â
Robert Broom (1866-1951)
Erythrosuchidae is an extinct family group of large basal carnivorous archosauromorph that lived around the Olenekian to Anisian stage of the early to middle Triassic.Â
Erythrosuchus had similar body anatomy characteristics that can be found in reptiles like crocodilians and lizards. However, it had massive head compared to its body size with a short neck that can be used to attack prey or competing with rivals in mating season. Its head and teeth (sharp and conical) were also resembled of theropod dinosaurs that would dominate in the Mesozoic era. Also, erythrosuchus had upright posture unlike sprawling posture similar to lizards so, it can gallop to chase down prey like Cuban crocodiles.Â
Erythrosuchus was bulky animal so it probably hunted its prey similar to komodo dragons where it ambush its prey after making short burst of sprint. It kills it's prey similar to its modern relatives of crocodilians where they torn apart their prey into chunks with a death roll on land or holding down on their prey while tearing it apart. There is no evidence that they were social animals so, it most likely to be solitary hunter while showing some cooperative hunting behaviours similar to modern crocodiles and komodo dragons. Erythrosuchus may been warm blooded unlike modern crocodilians so it can always stay active while still requiring food to sustain its body like most archosaurs in the triassic (including dinosaurs/birds as they are also its close relatives).Â
Cretaceous:
Edmontosaurus is a extinct genus of hadrosaurid dinosaur that existed around Campanian to Maastrichtian stage of Late Cretaceous (73- 66 million years ago). Its remains can be found in Western side of North America such as Montana, Colorado and southern Alberta. Edmontosaurus was one of the largest hadrosaurid as it is 9-12 metres in length and weigh around 4 tonnes. There are two species of edmontosaurus called E. Regalis (described by Lambe in 1917) and E. Annectens (described by Marsh in 1892). Also, there were four invalid genus of edmontosaurus: Anatosaurus (described by Lull and Wright in 1942), Anatotitan (described by Chapman and Brett-Surman in 1990), Claosaurus annectens (described by Marsh in 1892) and Ugrunaaluk (described by Mori in 2015).Â
Edmontosauurs remains can be found in the Hell Creek formation, Horseshoe Canyon formation and the Prince Creek formation.Â
Hell Creek formation is located near Jordan, Montana. It contains theropods (tyrannosaurus and Dromaeosaurus), ceratopsians (Triceratops and Torosaurus), Ankylosaur (Ankloysaurus), ornithomimid (Struthiomimus and Ornithomimus), pachycephalosaur (pachycephalosaurus and sphaerotholus), small mammals and vegetation.Â
Horseshoe Canyon formation is located in southwestern Alberta around Red Deer River near Trochu and along the North Saskatchewan. It contains ankylosaurs (Anodontosaurus and Edmontonia, and Euoplocephalus), other hadrosaurs (Hypacrosaurus and Saurolophus), ceratopsians (Pachyrinosaurus, Eotriceratop and etc,.) pachycephalosaur called sphaerotholus, theropods (Daspletosaurus, Atrociraptor and more), ornithomimid (Ornithomimus and Struthiomimus), small mammal called Didelphodon, reptiles and fish.Â
Prince Creek formation is located in Alaska. The formation contains theropods (Dromeosaurus, Nanuqusaurus and more), ceratopsian called Pachyrinosaurus, pachycephalosaur called Alaskacephale, mammals (Cimolodon, Sikuomys and more) and vegetations.Â
Hell Creek formation
Horseshoe Canyon formation
Prince Creek formation
Skeletal restoration of C.annecten (E.annecten) holotype by Othniel Marsh
C.annecten (E.annecten) paratype YPM 2182 at the Yale university museumÂ
John Bell Hatcher (1861-1904)
The first species and fossils of edmontosaurus were discovered and named by Othniel Charles Marsh in 1892, edmontosaurus was originally named claosaurus annectens. The holotype specimen was based on USNM 2414 which contained partial skull and skeleton while the second specimen was classified as paratype which contained second skull and skeleton (YPM 2182). These specimens were found in Lance formation of Niobara county in Wyoming. These specimens were one of the most complete hadrosaurid dinosaur skeletons in United States. They were taken and collected by John Bell hatcher in 1891, YPM 2182 specimen was displayed in 1901 while USNM 2414 was displayed in 1904. The genus of claosaurus annecten was generally widely accepted as a species for claosaurus, trachodon and thespesius duet to poor understanding and fossil material for hadrosaurids at the time. Â
Othniel Charles Marsh (1831-1899)
In 1908, two specimens of C.annectens were discovered by Charles Hazelius Sternberg and his sons in Lance formation rocks near Lusk, Wyoming. One of the most specimens was the first mummified hadrosaurid dinosaur called AMNH 5060 that shows its true skin impression for extinct animals. The second specimen called SM 4036 was also recovered in the same formation with skin impressions in 1910 but, they were not well preserved as AMNH 5060. He took his specimens to the British muesum of Natural history where Henry Fairfiled osborn later purchased the AMNH 5060 specimen for $2000 to add to the American Muesum of Natural history. Sternberg sold the second specimen to the Senckenberg muesum in Germany. in 1910.
Charles Hazelius Sternberg (1850-1943)
AMNH 5060 E.annecten specimen with skin impressions
Henry Fairfield Osborn (1857-1935)
Lawrence Lambe (1863-1919)
Levi Sternberg (1894-1976)
George Sternberg (1883-1969)
New discoveries of these new specimens changed palaeontologists understanding about hadrosaurs and the valid genus that would help them to better understand about edmontosaurus. The genus of edmontosaurus was officially described by Lawrence Lambe in 1917. In 1912, Levi Sternberg found two partial skeleton in the Horseshoe formation along the Red Deer River of southern Alberta, one of the specimens called NMC 2288 which consists of skull, articulated vertebrae up to the sixth tail vertebrae, ribs, atrial hip, an upper arm bone and most of a leg. The fossil remains were named as new species of edmontosaurus called E.Regalis after Lambe. The second specimen called paratype NMC 2289 was discovered by George Fryer Sternberg in 1916, it. consisted of a skull, skeleton lacking a beak, most of the tail and part of the tail. Lambe noticed on how robust and size of E.Regalis compared to another invalid hadrosaur species called Diclonius mirabilis (which would be renamed as E.annecten) to demonstrate on how large these animals were in life.
Holotype specimen CMNFV 8399 of E.annecten
Edmontosaurus is part of the hadrosaurid subfamily called saurolophinae which are group of large non crested hadrosaurs that lived around the Maastrichtian stage of Late Cretaceous. Saurolophinae are largest non sauropod animals in Mesozoic as, they can reach up to massive sizes that are almost tall to some sauropods species such as brontosaurus and diplodocus.Â
They are usually characterised of single hoof like claw in their front limbs, duck like beak and teeth that help them to digest and grain their food, upright posture, long flattened tail and lack of crests that makes these hadrosaurs stand out compared to other hadrosaur family groups. Like most hadrosaurs, they can move and run in bipedal and quadruped stance to help them move around their environment and run away from predators. They may not be the most armoured animals in the Mesozoic but, they heavily relied on herd members and size to help them survive and combat against predators or rivals. They may act extremely aggressive or territorial that were similar to modern herbivores as they need to be aggressive towards attackers since they are more likely to be attacked more than other herbivores. These hadrosaurs either run away or attack their attackers through biting, stomping or kick with their limbs and charging towards them, they wouldn't hesitant to kill or critically injured their attackers.  Â
Edmontosaurus is an social animals that lived in massive herds that consisted of hundreds or thousands members that vary of adults, sub-adults and juveniles. Like most hadrosaurs, edmontosaurus were good loving and protective parents as they deeply cared for their young to support themselves until they reach aduthood. Paleonotlgists found skin impressions of mummufied edmontonsaurus that showed it had pebbly scaley skin that were coverd throughout its body and even its feet. Also, paleonotligists also found mummufied hoof like claw that bare resmembeld of ungulate mammals but, the purpose of these structures were compeletely different opposed to ungulate mammals as it most likely to help edmontosaurus to have a quadraped posture.Â
Edmontosaurus and Brontosaurus size comparison
Edmontosaurus skin impressions
Edmontosaurus fossil that contained skin impressions
Mummified edmontosaurus front limbs
Pleistocene (North America):
 Mastodon is part of the extinct genus called Mammut who are extinct relative of modern elephants and mammoths that existed around Early Oligocene to Late Calabrian stage of Early Miocene to Late Pleistocene (23- 11,000 years ago). They roamed world-wide throughout North America before they went extinct with the rest of the megafauna. There are eight species of mastodon: M. Americanus (described by Kerr in 1792), M. Matthewi (described by Osborn in 1921), M. Vexillarius (Described by Matthew in 1930), M. Raki (described by Frick in 1933), M. Nevadanum (described by Stock in 1936), M. Cosoensis (Described by Schultz in 1937), M. Furlongi (described by Shotwell and Russell in 1963) and M. Pacificium (Described by Dooley in 2019).
Mastodon remains can be found in the Big Bone Lick State Park which is located at Big Bone in Boone County, Kentucky. The Park contains mammoths, bison, caribou, deer, elk, horse, moose, musk ox, peccary, ground sloths, wolves, black bears, stag moose, sabre-toothed cats and North American tapir fossils.Â
femurs of M.Americanum in the middle, modern elephants in the top and mammoths in the bottom
Fossil of M.Americanum molar tooth
In 1739, a French military expedition that was lead by Charles III Le Monye where they excavated in Big Bone Lick (located in state of Kentucky), they ere able to excavate fossil bones and teeth. In 1762, These fossils were taken to French naturalist Louis Jean-Marie Daubenton to be examined and analysed on on what these fossils belonged to, he noticed that there were similar to modern elephants and mammoths. In his conclusion, he proposed that the femur and tusk belonged to an elephants while the molars/cheek bones belonged to hippopotamus. In 1767, Peter Collinson credited Irish trader George Croghan for sending fossils evidence for him and Benjaim Franklin that proves the existence of North American proboscideans relatives. Collinson concluded that the peculiar grinders/molars were built for herbivorous diets which shows these mysterious North American proboscideans relatives were strict herbivores.  Â
In 1768, Scottish anatomist William Hunter and his brother John Hunter analysed the fossil tooth and tusk of mysterious North American proboscideans relatives after they took the fossil collection from Franklin and Lord Shelburne. Both the Hunter brothers noticed that they were not like those of modern elephants. Weirdly, Hunter proposed that these remains belonged to carnivorous elephant relatives that were completely separate from modern elephants and mammoths. Although, Hunter discovery was bit extreme and absurd about mastodon behaviours and diet, he was right that mastodon was complete separate lineage of proboscideans from modern elephants and mammoths.
Charles III Le Monye (1687-1755)
Louis Jean-Marie Daubenton (1716-1800)
George Croghan (no further information on him)
Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790)
Peter Collinson (1694-1768)
William Hunter (1718-1783)
John Hunter (1728-1793)
In 1785, Reverend Robert Annan wrote an account based on the fossils that contained four molar (another that was broken and thrown away and vertebrae that the workers excavated and thrown away after they broke it . These findings were at Annan farm near Hudson River in New York in 1780. Much like Hunter, Annan thought that these molars belonged to carnivorous animal while also speculating that these monstrous beasts went extinct at some point in the past. After these findings and the scientific community accepting that these ancient proboscideans relatives were carnivorous, this led to American statesmen Thomas Jefferson to speak his thoughts about these discoveries on Notes on the State of Virginia in 1785. Â
In 1799, labourers excavated a thighbone from the marl pit at John Masten's farm in Newburgh, new York. The labourers continue to excavated and found more fossil material that helped to complete the first skeleton of mysterious carnivorous proboscideans . In 1801, American painter and exhibitionist Charles Wilson Peale visited the farm to sketch illustration of the mysterious carnivorous proboscideans complete skeleton and, he purchased and owned the fossil collection from Malten's farm for his own personal collection. After the first skeleton discovered was excavated, the second skeleton was drilled in deep marl pit and assembled by Peale so he can present the specimen in his museum in Philadelphia in 1804. He opened his exhibit to the members of the American Philosophical Society on December 24th while Peale opened his exhibit publicly in December 25th. Peale exhibit has attracted thousands of visitors to see his monstrous proboscideans which helped to boost his museum into popularity and profitable while also making mastodon the symbol of US national symbol. Â
Painting of the Exhumation of the Mastodon by Charles Wilson Peale in 1806-1808
State of Virginia published in 1785
Colored lithograph of the Mastodon skeleton created by Charles Wilson Peale in 1845
Charles Wilson Peale (1741-1827)
Cuvier sketch of the mastodon skeleton
George Cuvier (1769-1832)
In 1806, an French naturalist and zoologist George Cuiver made extensive research on extinct elephant relatives that were found around Eurasia and North America while comparing their anatomy to modern elephants. He said that the extinct North American proboscideans fossils weren't not close to modern elephant anatomy as it differs by jaws with large tubercles. Cuvier call these particulr North American elephant relatives as "mastodonte", "mastodon" or "the animal of Ohio". He suggested that mammoth and carnivorous proboscideans (mastodon) to be invalid or discontinued described species name so Cuvier can create new genus for this North American proboscideans species, he officially called this genus known as mastodon based on its fossil teeth and Greek words that translate to "nipple tooth". Cuvier differentiate mastodon and modern elephants because he noticed that it had similar body type to modern elephants but had different molar structures that were similar to hippopotamus and pigs to digest on vegetation. Also, Cuvier was able to officially described several species of mastodon genus based on its different shapes and sizes of molars and body anatomy in 1824. He named M.Giganteum where he noticed that it had equal size but different proportions compared to modern elephants with diamond-shaped points of the molars and M.Angstidens has narrower molar, smaller than M.Giganteum and lived around Europe and South America. Cuvier official genus name for these North American elephant relatives were the most accepted and commonly used genus name in the 19th century-21st century.Â
Mastodon is part of extinct proboscideans family group called mammutidae that can be found in North America, South America, Eurasia and Africa. They existed around Late Miocene until the Late Pleistocene and beginning of Holocene about 11,000 years ago.Â
They usually characterised by having similar anatomical features of modern elephants but, they were shorter and bulkier than modern elephants, smaller ears, thick coat, straight forward tusks than curved, molars that were pointed cones than flat surface and low domed heads as opposed of high dome heads that are found in mammoths and modern elephants. Mammutidae were specialised wood eaters or xylophagy as opposed to grazer specialists, their diet consists of twigs, leaves, shrubs and trees in swampy and wet areas of woodland and coniferous forests. They also use their tusks to strip off the bark of trees to digest their food. Mammutidae possess broad feet and stubby, wide-splayed wide toes so they an walk on soft, waterlogged ground in wetter environments. Palaeontologists argued on whether they had thick coats like mammoths or hairless similar to modern elephants but, new discoveries helped to prove that they had shaggy coats to help them survive in colder climate.Â
Mastodon share behaviours of modern elephants and mammoths as they were highly intelligent and social herding animals. The herd is lead by matriarch/older female mastodon and, consisted of females and calf while the bull lives in solitary lifestyle. Although, bulls may lived in unstable herds to support younger bulls. Much like modern elephant bulls, they will go through high levels of testosterone called musth where the bull is looking for a mate but, they become too aggressive and destructive to animals and rival bulls. Mastodon fur would have shaggy and thick coat to help them to stay warm in cold climate, the fur would have been reddish brown.Â
Titanis bird is a extinct genus of phorusrhacid or popularily known as terror birds who were large carnivorous flightless bird that roamed around South America. However, Titanis migrated to southern part of North America in Florida and Texas, it existed around Hemphillian to Blancan stage of Early Pliocene to Early Pleistocene (5- 1.8 million years ago). There is only one species of Titanis called T. Walleri (described by Brodkorb in 1963).Â
There was no official formation in Santa Fe River, Florida near the border of Gilchrist and Columbia Counties where Titanis fossils were discovered. There were also equids (Nannippus), proboscideans (mastodon) and prehistoric bone crushing dog called Borophagus that also found alongside with Titanis remains.
Holotype of Titanis bird tarsometatarsus (UF 4108) in anterior and posterior views
Holotype of Titanis bird pedal phalanx (UF 4109)
Left carpometacarpus of titanis bird (UF 30003) in left, right, lateral, medial and anterior views
Proximal phalanx of Titanis bird in top, middle and bottom views (UF 30001)
Around 1961 to 1962, an amateur archaeologists Benjamin Walter and Robert Allen were searching for architects and fossils in the Santa Fe River on the border of Gilchrist and Columbia Counties in Florida, United States. Surprisingly, they also found new fossils of bird species so they donated their findings to the Florida Museum of Natural History. The specimens were called under UF 4108 and 4109 containing distal tarsometatarsus (lower leg bone) and a pedal phalanx (toe bone). The fossils were analysed by palaeontologists Clayton Ray in 1962 where he notice that it had avian features that were similar to large flightless birds, he suspected that the fossils belonged to new species of phorusrhacid or terror birds. Furthermore, Ray presented these new findings to ornithologist Pierce Brodkorb but, Brodkorb wanted to assign it as relative of South American relative of rhea which did got mentioned in his final publication. However, Ray still argued and tried to convince Brodkorb to assign these new fossils as new phorusrhacid species.
In 1963, the new phorusrhacid specimen was officially described as Titanis Walleri which makes it the first phorusrhacid to be discovered outside of South America. Throughout 1960s to 1970s after Brodkorb description was published, more Titanis remains were discovered as palaeontologists discovered 40 Floridian specimens (27 specimen unearthed) in the Santa Fe River. These specimens contained vertebrae, limb bones and even parts of the skull. More specimens were found in 1967, over 18,000 fossils were discovered by Floridian university students where they found 12 specimens of Titanis containing cervical vertebrae, a carpometacarpus and a metatarsal. In 1995, an isolated pedal phalanx was discovered near Odem along the Nueces River in San Patricio County, Texas where it was dated back around 5 million years old. This makes this discovery the oldest finding for Titanis and shows that its range wasn't limited in US.
William Pierce Brodkorb (1908-1992)
No further information on Robert Allen
 Benjamin Waller (no further information on his birth)
Clayton Ray (born on 1933)
Phorusrhacidae are extinct family group of large, flightless carnivorous birds that existed around the Early Eocene to Late Pleistocene (53- 0.1 million years ago). They are usually found in South America but, palaeontologist discovered that other phorusrhacid relatives can be found in Antarctica, Africa and southern parts of United States.Â
They are infamously characterised for having large and pickaxe like beak, sickle claws on each of their foot, strong legs that help them to deliver powerful kicks and small wings due to the consequence of having terrestrial lifestyle. Similarly, terror birds use their powerful beaks similar to theropod dinosaurs such as allosaurus and giganotosaurus to repeatedly stab large prey so they can die from blood loss or shock. Terror birds also possess sickle like claw on each toe that bare resemblance toward dromaeosaurs such as velociraptor to constrain smaller prey so they don't escape and use their powerful beaks to smash on the prey head. Also, they can use their environment such as rocks or logs to smash their prey head to finish them off before being digested similar to their modern relatives, the seriema bird that are also found in South America.Â
These large flightless birds were apex predators for their time before climate change and perhaps competition with placental mammals that caused the decline of their extinction before modern humans exist. The last surviving member of phorusrhacid that existed before they went extinct in Pleistocene was Titanis. They lived in Florida and Texas as these environments were similar to the ecosystem of South America so they thrived and dominated as apex predator despite the presence of sabre-toothed cats and other carnivorous mammals. In fact, Titanis was capable enough to kill or injured one of North America top predator, smilodon, despite the myth that these big cats can take down a full grown Titanis because of their cunning and agility. Terror birds were probably the closest that manage to share the same status as the non avian dinosaurs that dominated the planet in Mesozoic era.
Harvard References: