Problem Formulation

1. Generate problem statements that focus on the function to be achieved by any viable design solution.

Players, fans, and coaches are frustrated with incorrect calls from referees due to their limited observation capacity

Referees do not have enough live data to make the most effective call every time in a game.

Coaches do not have enough data to determine whether a  player would be a good addition to their team or not.

Coaches and medical personnel cannot determine possible injuries to players, during a game, quickly enough

2.  Apply a number of techniques and strategies such as the statement-restatement technique, the source/cause approach, the revision method, present state-desired state (PS-DS) strategy, and Duncker diagrams

3. Perform Kepner-Tregoe (KT) situation analysis to evaluate various aspects of a situation in terms of three criteria (timing, trend, and impact), thereby determining what is known, which tasks should be performed, and in what order these tasks should be completed

Issue 1:

 Players are frustrated with incorrect calls from referees due to their limited observation capacity.

Timing: The timing here suggests that this issue is ongoing and immediate, as players are currently experiencing frustration.

Trend: The trend indicates that incorrect calls from referees have been a recurring problem, possibly worsening player frustration over time.

Impact: The impact is significant, as it affects the quality and fairness of the game, potentially influencing outcomes and player morale.

Analysis:

• Given the immediate timing, recurring trend, and significant impact, addressing this issue should be a top priority. Immediate action is needed to improve referee decision-making and reduce player frustration.

Task:

• Implement technology solutions, such as VAR (Video Assistant Referee) or sensor-based systems, to assist referees in making accurate calls. This should be done as soon as possible to address the immediate impact on the game.

Issue 2:

 Referees do not have enough live data to make the most effective call every time in a game.

Timing: The timing suggests that this issue has been ongoing, but it may not be as immediate as player frustration.

Trend: The trend indicates that referees have consistently lacked live data, which may lead to less effective calls.

Impact: The impact can affect game quality and fairness, but it may not be as directly visible or immediate as player frustration.

Analysis:

• While this issue is important for the long-term improvement of refereeing, it may not require immediate action compared to the first issue.

Recommended Task:

• Develop and implement a long-term plan to provide referees with more live data through technology solutions. This task can be pursued concurrently with addressing the first issue but may have a longer time frame.

Issue 3:

Coaches do not have enough data to determine whether a player would be a good addition to their team or not.

Timing: The timing here suggests that this issue is ongoing, especially during player recruitment.

Trend: The trend indicates that coaches consistently lack sufficient data to make informed decisions about player recruitment.

Impact: The impact can affect team performance and success, making it a critical issue for teams.

Analysis:

• Given the ongoing timing, consistent trend, and significant impact, addressing this issue should be a priority for teams seeking to make better player recruitment decisions.

Recommended Task:

• Develop a comprehensive player performance analysis system that provides coaches with detailed data on potential recruits. This task should be initiated as soon as possible to improve team-building processes.

Issue 4:

 Players do not have enough tools to independently improve their performance in a sport.

Timing: The timing suggests that this issue is ongoing and may impact player development.

Trend: The trend indicates that players consistently lack tools for independent performance improvement.

Impact: The impact affects player development and competitiveness in the sport.

Analysis:

• Given the ongoing timing, consistent trend, and significant impact on player development, addressing this issue is crucial for player growth and overall sport improvement.

Recommended Task:

• Develop and provide players with access to training resources, such as online tutorials, performance tracking apps, or personalized coaching tools, to help them improve independently. This task should be initiated promptly to support player development.