In Tamilnadu, Temples, Temple property, Idols and Artefacts were good sources of loot for many.
While the common people value the temples and the history behind each, some well connected individuals unscrupulously have been looting the Idols, Deities, and almost everything possible.
The atheist culture promoted in the state by some groups, who are devoid of any sense of heritage, could not see anything reverential in the temple treasures and have been plundering them to sell them to the highest bidder.
Many responsible Hindu activists have been at the forefront in documenting and retrieving these thefts.
This is our effort to feature them so that the public are informed of how their heritage can be robbed and sold,
right under their nose, unless they are aware and watchful.
Police case diaries of 41 thefts of temple idols and invaluable artefacts had gone missing. We would not have known about this, until Lawyer/Temple activist ‘Elephant’ Rajendran petitioned the Chennai High Court in Feb ‘20. for a court-monitored investigation by a retired police officer into the missing of the case diaries. He has filed this petition based on RTI reply in 2018. S Vijaykumar, co-founder of Indian Pride Project and author of the book ‘The Idol Theft’ clears the aspersion being cast on Idol Wing IG Pon Manickavel, who retired in November 2019.
The case diaries relate to idol thefts from the period DMK came to power in Tamilnadu. Idol thefts have been rampant during the period from 1967 when either DMK and ADMK were in power in Tamilnadu. Right from the 1950s, idol theft cases have been closed saying the missing idols were "untraceable" as per Vijayakumar.
We hear of a Feb ‘19 newspaper report of a police case being filed 47 yrs after theft of 7 idols worth Rs 110 Crs in 1971-72 belonging to Natanapureeswarar Temple in Thandanthottam near Tanjore. The complaint and further running from pillar to post made by the then Trustees Subramanya Iyer and Venkatarama Iyer was of no avail.
The precious idols stolen in May ‘71 were two Krishna idols, Agasthiar idol, Ayyanar idol and Devi idol. A repeat theft occurred a year later of Natarajar and the Golu Amman idols. It appears that Idol Wing Police have traced Natarajar idol in a museum in USA. Now we can imagine why the Govt was keen to close the services of IGP Pon Manickavel in 2018 and shift idol wing cases to be handled by CBI.
The State has neither regard for Court Orders nor fear of law. Chennai High Court bench was monitoring idol theft cases investigated by Idol wing IGP. Temple activist R Venkataraman’s petition says “ancient idols from Chola-era temples in Thanjavur district were moved and stocked unofficially in Pandanallur against security norms. HR&CE department created records that idols are secure, when factually six precious idols were missing. Instead of keeping the idols at the Icon Centre, they were kept in an unauthorised tunnel and also in a scrap room belonging to the Public Works Department.”
In another case, filed by Activist Elephant G Rajendran, it was alleged that a senior police officer, I Khader Basha, now DSP, and two other police personnel, who were earlier part of the Idol Wing, came into possession of six idols while investigating a case involving one Arokiaraj.
Two of these were allegedly sold to a noted smuggler in Chennai for Rs 15 lakh, who then resold them for an alleged sum of Rs 6 crore. But despite an FIR being filed against the police officials concerned, they were promoted, and “no further action, either by way of arrest or by departmental proceedings, was initiated.”
The High Court Order of July 21, 2017 by Justice R Mahadevan had reprimanded HR&CE Dept. for their total failure to protect priceless heritage assets. After noting that Indian temples had been ravaged by invaders for centuries, he added:
“For the past several years, a new form of attack is carried out by smuggling the ancient idols. Foreigners and disbelievers see the idols as antiques worth only in terms of money, but the people of this country see them in the semblance of god, culture and identity. HR&CE is the custodian of most of the state’s temples and their properties, but has clearly failed to do so despite controlling large revenues. “It is startling to find that the HR&CE department, with all its income from major temples, has not been able to maintain historical temples and safeguard the idols … many temples constructed at least 1,500 years ago or much before … are in ruins. Even the daily rituals are not performed. Some temples remain closed throughout the day with no one to even light (sic) the lamps … this has also come to the advantage of the miscreants, who have laid their hands on the idols.”
It was later revealed that more than 350 bronze idols belonging to temples in 73 neighbouring villages were being kept in custody at the Pandanallur icon centre. It was found that several ancient icons had been stolen and were replaced by duplicate ones. The culprits were repeat offenders in other similar cases as well. The accused who were arrested in Nov ‘17 have been released on bail in 2018. Do you think that the harsh Court Order earlier mentioned would have any impact on strengthening idol security by the Govt.? If you think so. you will be in for a rude shock.
The same HC Judge in Jul ‘18 admonished the Govt for their delayed affidavit claiming that 3000 strong rooms will be built by 2021 in addition to such rooms in 11252 Temples and seeking time till 2021. The Chief Secretary will be summoned, the Judge warned. The Govt. revised its stand and undertook to the Court to build these strong rooms by end of 2019. But knowing the sincerity of the Govt., we know it is yet another white lie. 1,200 ancient idols are reported to have been stolen from Tamil Nadu temples in 25 years from 1992 to 2017. When custodians of rare artefacts are accomplices this happens. It's not just inefficiency. State does not want to instal State-of-the-Art security systems, inspite of huge incomes from Temples.. Read Full article in ToI
It is shocking to know from newspaper reports of Nov ‘19 that idols and antiquities seized by Idol Wing Police are lying abandoned in an open car park in Chennai. They are in CB - CID Economic Wings’ Office in Guindy, Chennai, with just a wall separating them from the Adyar river.
The Court directed the state government to fast track investigations under a special Chief Judicial Magistrate against the accused employees of the HR&CE department and the conniving police officers, who together attempted to smuggle them out of India by forging a paper trail while hiding the idols in a tunnel and then in a safe-house, all the while pretending that the idol has been secured in an ICON centre by them.
Justice R Mahadevan also ordered moving all idols to strong-rooms or Icon Centres, creation of a list of all temples managed by the state and the number of priests they employ, computerisation of records and 24×7 video and electronic surveillance of these idols and other valuables. The strength of the mafia was such that it took court orders to reinstate Pon Manickavel, the crack officer in-charge of idol theft in the state, to the investigation. http://indiafacts.org/bringing-antiquities-home-implications-hrce-judgment-madras-high-court/
The artefacts which include centuries-old stone sculptures and idols, carved stone pillars, intricately worked wooden pieces, temple cars, vahanas or ritual vehicles for idols, among others are stored in a haphazard manner.
These include 800 stone idols/artefacts seized from antique dealer Deenadayalan in Alwarpet, Chennai, 200 wooden artefacts seized from Lakshninarayanan, Deenadayalan’s associate in East Coast Road, Chennai, 244 antique idols seized from businessman Ranvir Shah in Saidapet, Chennai and 23 idols seized from business woman Kiran Rao in Poes Garden, Chennai.
“Efflorescence can result in deterioration of the surface through expansion and flaking. Bird droppings too are a threat. It may need treatment to remove salt by poultice using paper pulp,” said Professor Sharada Srinivasan, an expert in archeological science with the National Institute of Advanced Studies in Bangalore.T. Satyamurthy, former Superintending Archaeologist of the ASI, said stone idols, pillars lose their features such as carving if they are exposed to sun and rain.
Tamil Nadu Govt's fight with IGP Pon Manickavel was out in open, when Chennai High Court had to intervene to extend his services for yet another year till Nov ‘19. This is the environment in which Idol wing IGP Pon Manickavel was operating. He was not given proper office and he had to use his car as his office. HR&CE employees have been pampered to such an extent that they staged protests against idol wing IGP and even submitted a complaint against him to the Director General of Police.
Systematically precious emerald lingams from reputed Siva Temples have been burgled. ‘Gomethaga Lingam’ of Thiyaraja temple, Thiruvarur and ‘Maragatha Lingam’ of Kayarohaneswarar temple, Nagapattinam were stolen in 1990s. In 2016, 'Maragada Lingam' in Sundareswarar temple Thirukkuvalai was stolen. Incidentally it is pertinent to note that Thirukkuvalai is former Chief Minister of Taminadu, M Karunanidhi's village!
Idol thefts in Tamilnadu have now become everyday news in newspapers. As per a news report of Feb ‘20, 5 antique idols were seized in Pudukottai by idol wing IGP by setting up a contact and busting the racket. They were trying to sell it to them for Rs 20 Crs. As per another report of Mar ‘20, Karur police recovered 7 stolen panchaloha idols from a gang. In spite of the High Court directing the Govt to take strong measures to prevent idol thefts, the idol thefts continue unabated. So it is for us to connect the dots and understand the truth. The only way to end this is to take our precious Temples out of Govt. control.
We should realise that perpetrators can never be protectors.
13 July 2020
This article has been written by Ramanan P Ranganathan, a Chartered Accountant and a Member of Temple Worshippers’ Society.