Come One Come All

My Review

This is my least favourite episode of the first season and one of my least favourite of the whole 6 years. I don't like that the story is being totally built around a guest star, particularly one that I hadn’t really heard of before. Presumably she was well known in America and the producers felt lucky to get her but over here I didn’t know who she was.

She seemed a little old to be playing Montgomery’s Mother and we don’t really get to explore their back story. Montgomery mentioned he was tired of being in the wings of her life. I always got the impression Montgomery lived alone and had grown up away from his family but the details are missing and therefore it’s hard to care about him. I assume that if PR had stayed in the second season they may have explored his story more but here it’s a little boring.

Compare this with Street Kid, where Valerie and the writers use every part of the story to showcase who Doris is, we learn very little about Montgomery.

In fact in one of the best scenes in this episode it is Doris’ character we see more deeply into, when she notices that Montgomery is unhappy with his Mother being there and she follows him to the Library to support and offer a shoulder to cry on.

In some ways the episode follows reality. Montgomery’s Mother is using the school and the Kids to showcase herself and it feels like that’s what the writers are doing with Gwen Verdon, letting her showcase herself and ignoring the cast.

I didn’t care much for Montgomery’s mime act and the ending of the story seemed a little un-fame like to me. Normally they would have had Montgomery’s Mother at least catch his performance and realise she was a bad Mother or get her to stay at least to see the finale of the show.

This is an unusual episode in the fact there are no songs. I remember when this series was originally screened in 1982 over here that my family was away on holiday when this aired and my step father wouldn't allow me to watch the TV while we were away. I was then confused when the albums came out because I knew I'd seen the episodes with all those songs in them, so thought maybe there was a song that I was missing. When I finally got to see the episode I was most disappointed that there wasn't a new song.

The dance routines were okay and Debbie is obviously having fun dancing with Gwen in their evolution of dance routine but most of the styles of music were a little dated for the audience Fame was attracting.

Gene should have been given a chance to sing when he was doing his audition or a much more modern song be used for the dance finale and have Coco and some of the others singing it.

PR obviously does sing at least a little as we hear him on “Starmaker” and “Do The Gimme That” so I wonder why they didn’t have him singing something in this episode. The scene with him playing guitar in the music cubicle would have been an ideal opportunity for him to sing something, perhaps quite an angry rock song to show his frustration.

Carol seems to be having a lot of fun in this episode and her scenes are funny which lifts things a little and makes it a little more interesting. Although in the School for the Art why Sherwood would be involved in casting, directing and putting on a show doesn’t make much sense. Lydia and Shorofsky yes but an English teacher? We see, particularly from season 2, that there are other dance and drama teachers so if Crandall is away surely there would be another drama teacher to step in for him.

The scene where the kids meet Montgomery’s Mother is also pretty funny where they try to trick her as to who is who. Although if she is such a bad Mother would she really have time to exchange and read letters from Montgomery and actually take in things about people she’s never met?

Interestingly in one of the scenes in the office a backdrop of other buildings can clearly be seen outside the windows which I don’t recall ever being seen in any other episode.

One final nit pick, why oh why are they performing the show in the cafeteria again? And the dressing room that Doris is using is a curtained off part of the dance class, why aren’t they using the proper make up room?

Episode Pictures