We are all on the developmental spectrum- some further along than others and some having to relearn things depending on what we learned or missed along our journeys. Before we talk about Student Developmental theory- recognizing that your own development impacts your advising, how you engage with students, and where you find areas of compassion or hard lines within conversations will help you become a better advisor. Introspective behaviors are important for your personal growth and development as an advisor.
Before we look at specific Student Developmental Theories, we need to examine Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs – the understanding that first the foundational needs must be met before a student can work on their identity development or self-reflective/actualization behaviors.
There are three main Student Development Theories we'll focus on in this section. Each section has either an overview or a short video to guide your understanding of these student developmental theories. Take notes along the way to help build your understanding of the student development theories below.
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs – the understanding that the foundational needs must be met before a student can work on their student and identity development or self-reflective/actualization behaviors.
The above graphic is a representation of Maslow's hierarchy of needs.
To apply it to our advising role- we have these high expectations for students and give them massive amounts of information but don’t realize that they don’t know where the dorms are, or they are worried about how to pay for food (their psychological needs). Or maybe the student is struggling with their safety concerns, or how to build a community of friends.
Before students can get to the self-actualization phase of other student development theories, they must meet their basic needs. Taking the time to check in with the student—asking how they're doing with building relationships, whether they feel confident about their classes and grades, and how they're adjusting to the new academic year—is an important first step, and an ongoing one, in building rapport.
Student Development theory looks at how students grow and develop through the years attending college. It’s important for you as an advisor to understand this so you can provide better advice, response, and help with student retention through these stages.
Within Student Developmental theory there are three sub categories:
Cognitive theories (the way a student thinks)
Psychosocial and Identity theories (the theories of student’s identity)
Environmental Interaction theories (how a student interacts with their environment).
Our focus will be more on the psychosocial portion of student development- specifically looking at three theorist: Chickeing, Dweck, and Erikson.
(a pop-up screen may appear & ask if you want to go to the link. Simply click the Youtube link to get to the video.)
College-age students are typically in the Identity vs. Role Confusion and/or Intimacy vs. Isolation stages. Their development up to and through these stages are significantly impacted by their college experience, their past experiences, and peer involvement. As an advisor, understanding Erikson's Identity Theory will help you guide the student along their journey.
Discover a deeper dive into the 8 stages of Identity Development
The challenge with Student Development Theories is that many of theses were first developed in the 1960's/1970's and come from a limited and narrow perspective of white male student development; in part, this is because of they were the biggest population pursuing higher education during that era. Over time and with new research, student development has incorporated Identity Development to include things such as racial identity, sexual identity, women's identity, etc., as notated in the PPT found in Erikson's Identity Development section.
The below resources are available if you're interested in finding out more on Identity Development: