Cast List

Abby Pletcher: Elizabeth Thatcher

Trent Garnaat: Wynn Delaney

Jon Wilson: Calvin Arnette

Adam Bradt: Tom Richmond

Chase Buher: Jack Jared

Brad Garnaat: Bill Laverly

Adam Shultz: Mr. Dickerson

Breilen Maybee: Townfolk (Mr. Pastachuk)

Cole Groot: Reverend Anderson

Owen Gelder: Townfolk (Mr. Blake)/Candidate

Matthew Mason: Townfolk (Mr. Peterson)/Santa

Eli Pletcher: Townfolk (Mr. Johnson)

Daniel Gilbert: Townfolk (Mr. Mattoch)

Elijah VanKampen: Townfolk

Brian Gelder: Townfolk (Mr. Clark)

Crew Wilder: Townfolk 

Veronica Hetke: Graduates/Townfolk (Lydia Delaney)

Kerri Shultz: Townfolk (Mrs. Anderson)

Jessica Doerr: Graduates/Townfolk (Mrs. Dickerson)

Whitney Mayer: Mrs. Pastachuk

Dawn VanKampen: College Staff/Townfolk (Matriarch)

Shawna Wilder: College Staff/Townfolk (Matriarch)

Jamie Gilbert: Townfolk (Matriarch)

Beckie Buwalda: Townfolk (Matriarch)

CJ Pletcher: College Head Mistress/Townfolk (Matriarch)

Casey Adams: Graduates/Townfolk (Mrs. Johnson)

Jessica Bradt: Graduates/Townfolk (Mrs. Clark)

Helen Persons: Graduates/Townfolk (Mrs. Mattoch)

Ally Garnaat: Graduates/Townfolk (Mrs. Peterson)

Rebekah Gilbert: Graduates/Townfolk (Mrs. Blake) 

Josie VanKampen: Ellie Clark

Jericho VanKampen: Andy Pastachuk

Mallory Wilder: Teresa Pastachuk

Ziah Groot: Phillip Delaney

Gideon VanKampen: David Dickerson

Alitza Groot: Sarah Dickerson

Avery Mayer: Else Peterson

Canaan VanKampen: Lars Peterson

Macy Wilder: Cindy Blake

Harper Mayer: Lindy Blake

Katie VanKampen: Mary Johnson

Evan Mayer: Harvey Johnson