JUDGEMENTS

LATEST JUDGEMENT

APRIL 2024

f953e2adfe5865c803aa5c77c82652b4.pdf

MARCH 2024

604091d41824a02186b26e39a9cb6d12.pdf

FEBRUARY 2024

04b122ebcb08987d22d9cde744f1876c.pdf
82b9759cc62710fc7acd6bd3870ce011.pdf
c736e30e1a868bcd3769eb000161a13f.pdf

DECEMBER 2023

c2425a5532ebe040c6b98bfc17843d54.pdf
1c5cfd743e53acb39839725bfe8a15cb.pdf

OCTOBER 2023

DOC-20231013-WA0028..pdf

AUGUST 2023

0878661f4273b1d69bbc98bec4f09280.pdf
08a2cfd99e0bbb6c7c6c5d6aafd30d40.pdf

JULY 2023

bfbd5367ccfb8fb101c5e9b0714ce3e1.pdf

MAY 2023

b9179db0cb8f71d6d18e47b9dde13e22.pdf

APRIL 2023

7ffb0e928946b65882edb0643860608f.pdf
f6b4f9789ed2a623cf8aae90ac7645d2.pdf

MARCH 2023

9fc402b03705de83ae24bf8a80358c63.pdf
8d38354ca2ae76294259e0f8ced9c22b.pdf

JANUARY-FEBRUARY 2023

650d312f59498908913c936d25e3f89c.pdf
8edc82d411c7a891d27de1c6b12470b5.pdf
4768_2020_31_1502_25082_Judgement_18-Dec-2020.pdf
f809b892499e5bb426e6b7acf3579d07.pdf
bc01617cfb5e4acef78a6d123b75c43b.pdf

Amit Malhotra & Anr vs Almond Infrabuild Private ... on 8 December, 2021 

Amit_Malhotra_Anr_vs_Almond_Infrabuild_Private_on_8_December_2021.PDF

M/S Bhatia Builders And ... vs Union Of India And Others on 31 December, 2022 

M_S_Bhatia_Builders_And_vs_Union_Of_India_And_Others_on_31_December_2022.PDF

09-DECEMBER-2022

c9ef77c4242b1dad8a61507fdd2787b6.pdf

26-November-2022

f18fca74b952995a52d8eb055c50bac8.pdf

02-November-2022

254033ac2c80131cc231909c7ec3881b.pdf

01-November-2022

7787383194a42b2090acf5cbfa599eed.pdf

31-October-2022

c1e580445f1659789a8022bfcc164e83.pdf

21-october-2022

e40c23d45abf7ada5e5c37db456ab2aa.pdf

05-OCTOBER-2022

858f464e816f7b2faaaa736799f9883a.pdf

15-SEPTEMBER-2022

d507e60b8d11fd50fcf750d63cd21f47.pdf

07-SEPTEMBER-2022

c1bd7d49a48ecfff8ac50960fe8de4d1.pdf

05-SEPTEMBER -2022

af6ba830c47c8ba4cdde65604984b90d.pdf

26-AUGUST-2022

f1ddd2e708f7b3f9c2674ab043a8e935.pdf

20-AUGUST-2022

e4a52c132210ccce16737c37fd90ab60.pdf

18-AUGUST-2022

3fab047d410908c085f3af11b17a83d9.pdf

18-AUGUST-2022

901ac07158df18faa732619f59b490aa.pdf

19-AUGUST-2022

959982e77776d6bd3288dc461e2b247c.pdf

26-JULY-2022

384aa1522757616abcad4f13980ccc14.pdf

23-JULY-2022

842f7a0b221ec115c8faf874b98e61bb.pdf

04-JULY-2022

4049f6f70017b0123bc5381e183376a9.pdf

12-JULY-2022

79f18d986c360cf1fc465ad46ff538aa.pdf

16-JUNE-2022

546282efa541854bc092c86bbc8a42b1.pdf

24-MAY-2022

575f209086b388f8c73e3a6ca2b912ac.pdf

26-MAY-2022

3bb68b4eb3ffe919b680ef8787fc9137.pdf

21-MAY-2022

956a7e42e65e7f7e003df073f51d632e.pdf

14-May-2022

7758b3af53276e1d00b42b24459c715f.pdf

14-May-2022 

721c4c67243e91ee0ddae44f1b3e7794.pdf
dc676a73b00b51af946445773ba2b09b.pdf

Jaguar Overseas Limited vs . Union Of India & Anr on 18 April, 2022 

Jaguar_Overseas_Limited_vs_Union_Of_India_Anr_on_18_April_2022.PDF
d839b3f2f084ac8f16a612e10079fc08.pdf
a08c5b80a16f11ea24cd095d53022704.pdf

Gyan Prakash Arya vs M/s Titan Industries Limited

Except correcting arithmetical or clerical errors, arbitrator has no power to modify the award under Section 33 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act. Supreme Court. 

49dfd1669ea0a7c589a10a72fc526308.pdf

Mohammed Masroor Shaikh vs Bharat Bhushan Gupta and others.

Civil Appeal 874 of 2022 decided on 2 February 2022.

Justice Indira Banerjee and Justice Abhay S Oka.

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. When contentions relating to non­ arbitrability are plainly arguable, the Court must refer the matter for arbitration by default. Supreme Court.

7d029f9f0fb289212d7c4a2d3b384c1c.pdf

M/S.PRASAD AND COMPANY (PROJECT WORKS) LIMITED vs BHARAT HEAVY ELECTRICALS LIMITED

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Dismissal of earlier arbitration proceedings is NOT a bar to initiate fresh arbitration proceedings under the same clause if the claims and disputes are different. Karnataka High Court.

eab2756092ecf567b0a4410a5735c392.pdf

WELSPUN SPECIALTY SOLUTIONS LIMITED (FORMERLY KNOWN AS REMI METALS GUJARAT LTD.) vs OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LTD.

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Illegality of a trivial nature could not be held to violate the public policy to invalidate arbitration award under Section 34. Supreme Court.


7343c172a7ce47099ff6477e6b58b1b3.pdf

DLF Home Developers Limited vs Rajapura Homes Private Limited & Anr.

Arbitration. Even when an arbitration agreement exists, it would not prevent the Court to decline a prayer for reference if the dispute in question does not correlate to the said agreement. 


af842f961ef3e35bc2fca141bf8c9642 (1).pdf

Delhi Airport Metro Express Pvt. Ltd. vs Delhi Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. 

Arbitration and Conciliation Act. Contours of the Court’s power to review arbitral awards explained. Every error of law would not amount to ‘patent illegality’ and erroneous application of law cannot be categorised as patent illegality. Supreme Court


Amazon Holding.pdf

Amazon.com NV Investment Holdings LLC vs Future Retail Limited & ors


58964a36e7cca135bc3dc6470e9574bd.pdf

Garg Builders vs Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited  

Arbitration. If the contract prohibits pre­reference and pendente lite interest, the arbitrator cannot award interest for the said period. Supreme Court reiterates.


9d011ec101a3b2d9931b083256be9c68.pdf

Psa Sical Terminals Pvt Ltd vs The Board of Trustees of V.O Chidambranar Port Trust Tuticorin And Others

Arbitral Tribunal is not a court of law and its orders are not judicial orders. Arbitrator's jurisdiction is confined to four corners of the agreement. Supreme Court reiterates. Also see; discussion on 'public policy of India.

08._Judgement_10-Mar-2021 Supreme court.pdf

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited vs M/S Nortel Networks India Pvt.

Period of limitation to apply under Section 11 is three years as per Article 137 of Schedule I Limitation Act 1963. The Limitation period runs from the date when there is failure to appoint arbitrator. 

Judgement_04-Jan-2022.pdf

Ellora Paper Mills Limited vs The State of Madhya Pradesh

Civil Appeal 7697 of 2021 decided on 4 January 2021

Justice M.R. Shah and Justice B.V. Nagarathna  

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Disqualification under Section 12(5) applies even to pending proceedings commenced under agreements entered prior to 2015 amendment. Supreme Court reiterates..


Judgment.pdf

The Project Director, National Highways No.45 E and 220 National Highways Authority of India vs M Hakeem & Another

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Power of court under Section 34 to set aside an award of an arbitrator does NOT include the power to modify such an award. Supreme Court.

23663_2020_33_1502_27307_Judgement_06-Apr-2021.pdf


Sanjiv Prakash Vs. Seema Kukreja



Whether an agreement with arbitration clause is novated or not cannot be decided in exercise of limited jurisdiction. Issue shall be referred to arbitrator.

11._Judgement_11-Jan-2021 suprme court.pdf

M/S N.N. Global Mercantile vs M/S Indo Unique Flame Ltd.


The civil aspect of fraud as defined by Section 17 of the Indian Contract Act can be adjudicated by an Arbitral Tribunal.



2818_2021_33_1501_27661_Judgement_20-Apr-2021.pdf

PASL Wind Solutions Pvt. Ltd. vs GE Power Conversion India Pvt. Ltd.

Two Indian companies can choose a forum for arbitration  outside india. an Arbitral award arising from such an arbitration would be a foreign award.

05. CIVIL APPEAL NO. 995 OF 2021_Judgement_19-Mar-2021 Supreme court.pdf

Government Of Maharashtra vs M/S Borse Brothers Engineers


 

On 19 March 2021 Supreme Court held that delay beyond prescribed period in filing appeal under Section 37 can be condoned by way of exception.


07. SUpreme court _Judgement_04-Mar-2021.pdf

Amway India Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. vs Ravindranath Rao Sindhia 


Individual party to arbitration agreement a national of or habitually resident in any country other than India then Arbitration becomes an international Commercial Arbitration though business is done in India.


3725_2010_39_1501_27758_Judgement_22-Apr-2021.pdf

M/s. Oriental Structural Engineers Pvt. Ltd. vs State of Kerala

Award of interest. blank portion left by the contractor in appendix to bid cannot be construed as zero or nil interest claim when the contract provides for payment of interest.

Arbitration and Conciliation Act.pdf
JUDGEMENT-.pdf
9c2eb0bc5b6ec04a31991eb756053d98.pdf
8a6aa6860ab0cb8dbc10bd4056af4422.pdf

Smt. Amalapooh Marry & others vs Sri V Ravindra & others on18th August, 2021

Mediation. Failure to appear before Mediation Centre or Lok-adalat on reference of matter to mediation. Court can impose costs to compel attendance of parties before Mediator. Karnataka High Court.


382a2d5683e2c4321e6692b5c60bbf42.pdf

Maya Traders Limited vs Shri Kirti Kumar Kabra and others

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Termination of agreement to sell by the vendor constitutes arbitral dispute under Section 11(6) of the Act. Karnataka High Court.


da0b800fbbbe4364de169bb473c81d30.pdf

M/s. Suresh Goel and Associates vs Indian Institute of Technology. 

Arbitration and Conciliation Act. Where contract empowers only one of the parties to appoint sole arbitrator, the person who has an interest in the outcome of the dispute can NOT appoint a sole arbitrator. Karnataka High Court.

06 Smt_Sushma_Swaraj_vs_M_S_Blue_Valley_Properties_Pvt_Ltd_on_17_March_2021.pdf

Smt. Sushma Swaraj vs M/S Blue Valley Properties Pvt Ltd on 17 March, 2021

Amendment to Section 8  of Arbitration and Conciliation Act if any application by any person claiming through or under the party to arbitration agreement is prospective and does not apply to suits instituted prior to 23rd October 2015.



04. Smt_Padma_Mahadev_vs_M_S_Sierra_Constructions_on_22_March_2021.pdf

Smt. Padma Mahadev vsM/S. Sierra Constructions 

Application under Section 9 is maintainable even after conclusion of arbitral proceedings and during Section 34 proceedings only in so far as the claim granted by the arbitrator.

CMP304-19-31-03-2021.pdf

Anheuser Busch Inbev India vs East Godavari Breweries Private

 

On 31 March, 2021: Even non-signatories will be bound by the arbitration agreement, if there is implied consent to be so bound and a direct relationship with the signatory.















f18fca74b952995a52d8eb055c50bac8.pdf