This is so late that I might as well have scrapped the review entirely, but I had no choice but to come to terms with one of my favorite video games turning into something…unintelligible. And it’s a scary movie! Happy belated Halloween!
I write this game bogged down by a years-long history with this movie, and the entirety of my opinion stems from my view of this movie as an adaptation of that beloved game. I understand that this will soil my thoughts, but I believe this is what most of the audience pressed play envisioning—a fresh interpretation of their favorite choice-driven video game. Thus, I have no qualms tearing into this project as thoroughly as I do below.
Let’s start with an introduction to the cast, accompanied by notes taken as I watched the movie for the first, and only, time:
Nina: Bisexual, likes to be in a relationship
Abe: Nina’s bf, idiot, jealous of Max, selfish/wuss baby
Mel: Dead
Clover: The sister of the dead one, determined in a main character/leading lady way
Max: Man #2. Has a crush on Clover…? Nina’s ex
Megan: Psychic? Possessed?
What a diverse group of individuals! I bet their interactions, motivations, and personal growth will make a compelling movie!
Off the jump, I defined Until Dawn as a ‘question movie.’ This isn’t a concept unique to me, nor can it only be applied to this movie, but it summarizes the first third of Until Dawn perfectly.
“Did you hear that?”
“Is that my car?”
“Did you turn that over?”
Etc. etc.
It’s an unscary horror movie, so I understand mystery and questions drive the plot, but, jeez, does it make this cast look silly. They’re too occupied with ‘phone’ and ‘relationship’ to comprehend the horror fest they’ve found themselves in. I can’t blame them: the horror isn’t even that daunting! The missing posters don’t have heights, so what? There are windows underground…okay? There is a water wall…uh, deal with it? They took the (mostly) great cast from the video game, threw them away, and cast Things One through Four, plus Main Character Nina, to stumble through scenarios that did nothing to terrify me.
I will say that the sand clock and the Groundhog Day concept were, initially, very thrilling, especially when combined with the ever-growing number of names on the sign-in sheet. That was really fantastic, especially when one of the characters didn’t say, “Oh, why did she sign her name multiple times, blah blah blah?” and let the audience think about it themselves. Because I had so few expectations of foreshadowing, I didn’t think twice about Mel’s name being written a dozen times, but it rushed back to me as soon as Nina’s name appeared again. However, I only felt that rush once the entire runtime. What a shame: they had something and immediately lost its charm.
Jumping to character, I acknowledge the choice that Clover is so willing to use suicide as an easy reset due to her active suicidality in her day-to-day, contrasting her friends’ hesitation to do the same. Well, they’re quick to kill each other, not necessarily themselves, which is another layer to their differences. Not only does it actually differentiate these white wall characters, but it explores the impact Mel’s disappearance had on Clover in a way less basic than, “she’s been changed for the worse.”
One last note on character, and I’ll move on to little tidbits and smaller critiques and praises, though this may be the most important paragraph in this entire review:
I fear Megan’s character was greatly mishandled. She is the most underutilized of the cast, serving as a death introduction and possession material, and doesn’t have a single emotional monologue. She doesn’t even witness one! In the best case, this is just poor writing from a film that already has shitty writing. In the worst case, which I fear is more likely, one of two characters of color—the other, Max, is also given a fairly short stick—is literally left alone in a room to die in the finale so the white lead could save her after pursuing character growth. I don’t think I have to spell out how bad that is.
This is such a nagging problem in horror and film in general, and should not be happening in the 21st century, let alone a year ago. As a white person, there’s not much more I can confidently say on this topic, but it is very easy to hire people to help you highlight marginalized voices. Yoo Jiyoung is a strong actress who has had some fantastic roles despite being so young, and her strengths were muddied because of poor writing. I would say I hope her career takes off, but it certainly already has, despite this blotch on her resume.
I have very little to say about the horror itself. This is a classic low-ball horror movie, so I can’t pick out too much that thrilled me. There was one sequence I thought was decently smart: the video’d montage.
I absolutely loved the two seconds where that tall, SCP-looking creature popped out of the door in the video the cast watched. Those video sections were actually really intelligent as a storytelling tool and a great way to effectively showcase a young person’s horror. This is how we’d view repeating, soon-to-be-normal disasters: by filming. Both as a record and a coping mechanism; it is much easier to deal with horrible things when you can filter them through a camera, a screen, and then into your eyes. Not that it’s pushed this far, but commentaries on this exact topic—screens showing us horrible things we will likely never experience ourselves—have been decently successful and provocative. There was an attempt here. One that may not fit this film, but definitely aided the believability of these young people’s experiences.
On the horror note, I wish the concept of retaining injuries into following lives were more prominent. Meg had some bruising on her face after her head was bashed in, and Abe started growing spine spikes after being stabbed in the back. That’s cool! Not exactly a genius premise, but it makes their actions feel more weighted. Like, if they were to kill themselves just to move on and have another chance, how they committed would affect their performance in the next life. Maybe the ailments stack up and dull their performance? That would have been so engrossing.
All in all, the game was much scarier. I haven’t played it myself, but I’ve watched so many playthroughs that I could save the entire cast without a guide and with one hand tied behind my back. That being said, there was never a point where I knew where the movie’s story was going based on my prior knowledge. That can be a pro and a con. I saw it as a con because I expected to understand what was happening, to bridge gaps of knowledge using my familiarity with the video game, but that was hardly the case.
Because they tried to teeter on the line between adaptation and original plot, the story was so fragmented that it had no connection to the game. Like, this has just as much in common with “The Hunger Games” (both have mine collapses) as it does with the original Until Dawn.
Why make the fake serial killer the primary antagonist? Why add supernatural magic? Why introduce the creature over halfway in? These choices make zero sense when so much else has already changed.
They even vaguely referenced the scene where Jessica drops into the mineshaft when the creature drops Meg into the house (hole?), and Max, similarly to Mike in the video game, watches helplessly. Why would you do that instead of having the actual characters perform the actual scene far better than these randos?
Additionally, they quote “DON’T MOVE!” the iconic Until Dawn mechanic! That’s what I want more of! More references and direct translations of the game to film, please! Pander, pander, pander!
This would have been a different product if it was released soon after the original game rather than after multiple entries in The Dark Pictures Anthology, which the Until Dawn movie has much more in common with. This is most notable not only in the premise itself, but also in the sand clock and the skull attached to it. Very Man of Medan. Very Mid of Movie.
As a standalone film, I cannot recommend this to anyone. As an adaptation of the game, I’d actually urge fans to run far, far away and never look back. It’s been quite a decade of video game adaptations, all of which have been mediocre at best, inflammatory at worst. Should directors cut their losses and avoid the genre? No. They should listen to consumers, fans, and new watchers’ responses to the old to pave the way for a better new. In the case of Until Dawn, there was a great movie with lots of roadblocks keeping it from being made. Only the strongest, most driven of directors would have made our wildest dreams come true, and, unfortunately, Sandberg may not have been the man for the job.
Dan and Phil, British Youtube sensations. They have been making videos collaboratively for seventeen years now. Just one year ago they hard launched their relationship—one that has been heavily speculated about and investigated since their very first video together. Twelve years ago they launched their joint channel, Dan and Phil Games (which has now been turned into Dan and Phil following the hard launch). They have a Halloween tradition entitled “Spooky Week” in which they post scary gaming videos. They also have a longstanding tradition of doing baking videos for holidays like Halloween and Easter. In honor of the Halloween season, here is my list of the five best Dan and Phil Halloween videos (in no particular order):
Dan and Phil Play SLENDER – This is one of their videos from their first ever Spooky Week and I still love it to this day. It is the right amount of comedy and fear to have you ready for the holiday, but not falling out of your chair in fear.
Halloween Baking - PUMPKIN SPICE PUMPKIN COOKIES – This is quintessential Dan and Phil baking, honestly. They somehow manage to make a tasty treat, but there are a lot of hiccups along the way and some of the cookies are definitely a little ugly. I have yet to try this recipe, but it looks absolutely fire.
Dan and Phil Play FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY’S – They played Five Nights at Freddy’s mere months after it came out as their very first Spooky Week video. For anyone familiar with FNAF, you might not get scared, but it is most assuredly a laugh. The way they play the game is so agitating but endearing. Also the ending is just hilarious and a classic Dan Howell moment.
Halloween Baking - RADIOACTIVE MUG CAKES – I would say this is one of my favorite Dan and Phil videos to date. It is so fun, lively, and funny; it is so peak. This video is pre-hard launch, but I think you can just see how free they feel to be themselves, which makes it even better. Also, this recipe is such a simple one to follow if you as a viewer wanted to make one as well. Who doesn’t love a mug cake!
Dan and Phil’s Traumatic Golf Incident – In this video, they play the game Greener Grass Awaits. They have a series where they play Golf With Friends so this choice of game was a throwback, as well as an amazing choice for Spooky Week post-hiatus (because they went on a hiatus in 2018 </3). It’s an indie horror game, which I think makes it a little scarier because of the visuals. You could very well be scared while watching this (I know I was), but you will also be laughing purely because of their reactions.
Whether you are a veteran phan, a new gen, or someone that enjoys watching gaming and/or baking videos, I think these are the best ones to get you ready for Halloween. You should listen to me and watch them because I am always right!
Fuck the 1-Star Good Reads review
that suggests just because a character is evil
the author must be too.
Haven't you ever read something
more than mediocre?
I would hope you could see past
a surface level analysis
& wonder why
an author made that choice.
But, these days, people seem more interested in
skipping past
descriptions & flipping straight to "dialogue".
As if nothing meaningful happens in the
[in between].
While I'm here
[unfortunately still on twitter]
watching reactions to Anne Carson's
prize winning poetry
trickle
in:
user42069
Anyone can write gibberish
"My personal poetry is a failure."
Did it ever occur to you to consider subtext
in a line of fucking poetry?
The poetry that constitutes her humanity is failing.
She is failing
at being
a person.
I would think that you could relate.
I'm sorry they killed
your inner child.
I'm sorry you never had a chance
to look up at the sky.
Because how can you witness
a rosy-orange sunset,
& not call it a poem?
This blog post is a poem
because I said so.
Art is what you make it, so
I would love for you
to pick up a pen.
Or better yet
to pick up a book.
Or better yet
learn to rub two brain cells together.
This is what they want.
Us dumb & arguing
while that fuckwad racks in
another trillion off of the platform
I can't quite
get
off
yet.
There is a literacy crisis
because they want us
¿un-questioning?
Give them something to answer to.
Don't let them tell you
that art is meaningless.
Pick up that pen,
& construct
your own narrative.
During my tenure as a student at our one and only Arcadia University, I have attended a lot of concerts (twenty-six to be exact). Surprisingly though, only eight of those concerts have been in Philly. I come from southern Maryland and go to a lot of concerts with my sister, so a lot of times I will go back home for a concert. I very recently had a three day concert bender (concerts three days in a row), and it made me realize something: in all of the cities I have gone to, there has never been a city culture like there is in Philly.
One of the concerts on my bender—Phoebe Bridgers at Xfinity Mobile Arena—was a hometown show for the opener, Alex G. Obviously he is going to be Philly proud, but Phoebe (who is from California) pulled her own “go birds!” at one point and even mentioned LeBron James’s move to the 76ers. In response, the crowd cheered loudly both times, as they tend to do. It wasn’t until the last concert in my bender, though, that I realized just how common this is and how much it brings a crowd together.
I was standing in the crowd at the Franklin Music Hall, watching the opener for Julia Wolf perform. Right before starting another song, the bassist said, “Oh and go birds.” And again, the whole crowd cheered. This “go birds” in particular was what made me reflect on this trend as a whole. For the concerts I’ve gone to in Maryland or DC, artists will do the typical “hey [city] what's up,” but sometimes they even get the city wrong. In Silver Spring, Maryland, artists will often call it “Silver Springs” or more shockingly, they’ll call it DC… Stuff like this never happens in Philly. Philly is Philly. Maybe it’s because Silver Spring is not a big city and it’s close to DC, but still.
In the summer of 2025 I saw My Chemical Romance at Citizen Bank Park. During the show, the Phillie Phanatic came onto the stage with the members of the band and he threw cheesesteaks into the crowd. As far as I am aware, this was the only time they brought a mascot onto stage. I saw the band again this summer at Nationals Park in DC, but Screech the bald eagle most definitely was not brought on stage during the concert. This time with the Phillie Phanatic was truly a Philly special, all because of the pride the city feels, especially around the sports teams.
All of these examples, and the other instances of a “go birds” that I have not mentioned, illustrate the one thing Philly has that not many other cities have. Whether you are from the city or not, you can truly feel your Philly pride. There is no community like the one built on the love for Philly sports teams. I am not even a sports fan but when I watched the Eagles win the superbowl my sophomore year, I was feeling proud! I don’t know if I’ll ever go out of my way to watch a Phillies or a Flyers or even an Eagles game on TV, but if my roommates put it on or I get invited to go to a game, I see no reason to turn away. The culture of Philly pride is one that is so welcoming and such an easy way to connect with the city, it truly something I’ve never seen anywhere else.
While I am not a native, I really do love my country Philadelphia.