PB Premium Whop Review [Before You Buy]

47,000 members. That number stopped me in my tracks when I first landed on the PB Premium page.

Most trading communities top out at a few hundred people before the signal-to-noise ratio collapses. So either something real is happening here, or it's a marketing number that hasn't been updated since the Discord was created. I wanted to find out which.

I came in skeptical. I've paid for trading groups before, sat through lifeless "live streams" where the host is clearly reading charts for the first time, and watched alert channels go silent for days at a stretch. If any of that sounds familiar, keep reading.

Here's my honest take: PB Premium is one of the more substantive trading education communities I've come across at this price point, and the free trial makes it genuinely low-risk to verify that yourself.

Claim your free 5-day Premium trial before the waitlist fills up

What PB Premium Actually Is (And Why It's Structured Differently)

PB Premium is the flagship tier inside the Pennybois ecosystem, a trading education and community platform that has been operating since 2023 on Whop. The product stack is surprisingly layered for a group this age.

At the top level, you've got the Premium Membership at $139.49 per month (at the time I checked). That bundles everything: live trading streams, real-time stock alerts, premium watchlists, coaching sessions, and access to the Mind Over Markets Program. Essentially, you're not paying for alerts alone, which is actually important. Communities that sell only alerts tend to die when one big call goes wrong. Communities built around education survive.

Below that, you've got standalone options:

• Free Membership: literally free, includes Discord access, 100+ classes, and live streams

• Mind Over Markets Program: starts at $12.99 per month, renews at $7.00 per month (one of the stranger pricing structures I've seen, but the renewal rate is almost impossibly cheap)

• PB Crypto Membership: $19.99 per month for crypto alerts and a multi-class trading course

• Mad Maverick Coaching Program: $39.99 per month, focused on swing trading with the SMA 20 trend system

• SwingingBull Coaching Program: also $39.99 per month, options income strategies

• Rest and Retire Newsletter: $14.99 per month for 3 monthly long-term stock picks

• 30 Days of Identity Reps: free audio series on trader mindset

• Surviving the Market PDF: free beginner risk management guide

That's a real product ecosystem, not just a Discord with a Patreon bolted on. The fact that you can start completely free and ladder up is a legitimate structural advantage for new traders who aren't sure what they need yet.

The Coaches: Who's Actually Teaching You

This is where I spent the most time digging, because coach quality is everything in a community like this.

From the verified member reviews, two names come up consistently: Saad Boil and Mr. Lee. One reviewer who was a Premium member for almost two months specifically mentioned that Saad teaches small account growth starting at 9:15 AM and running through 11 AM, which tells me there's an actual structured session, not just someone going live when they feel like it. Mr. Lee is described as a live trading coach who shares trades in real time and actively engages with students during the session.

That detail matters more than people realize. I've been in groups where the "live stream" is a coach staring at a screen, occasionally saying "yeah, watching this one." That's not teaching. When a reviewer says their coach "asks for your" (the review was cut off there, but the sentiment is clear), it implies interactive engagement, not a broadcast.

A third coach, Mad Maverick, runs the swing trading coaching program and uses a specific methodology: SMA 20 trend system, fundamental analysis, and institutional-style trade planning. That specificity is a green flag. Vague strategy language ("momentum plays," "high-probability setups" with no further context) is how bad coaches hide the fact that they don't have a real process. Having a named system means it can be taught and replicated.

SwingingBull handles the options income program, focused on generating weekly income without chasing hype. That's a reasonable and testable claim, which I appreciate more than "I made 500% returns."

What Surprised Me About the Community

You know that feeling when you've finally worked up the courage to ask a question in a trading Discord, and the response you get back is either silence or some guy with a GIF avatar posting a meme? That's the norm in 90% of free trading servers.

One verified buyer came in having lost everything in options after growing a $4,000 account to $7,000 and then watching it evaporate. They'd been burned by other groups that "stole their money and never answered a single question." They said they got their first win on day one of Premium membership. I can't verify that, but the specificity of that account, the exact dollar amounts, the multi-year gap, the hesitation, it reads like someone describing a real experience.

A second reviewer mentioned following Pennybois since 2021 as a free member before finally upgrading to Premium, then saying "in reality, I should have joined Premium a long time ago." That's exactly the kind of testimony that should carry weight in your decision. Not someone who joined on Monday and left a five-star review by Wednesday, but someone who had two years of baseline reference to compare against.

The free membership has 1,325 members at the time of writing. The Premium tier has 61. That ratio is actually healthy. A bloated Premium tier with thousands of people is harder to manage and creates worse coaching outcomes for everyone. Right now, 61 Premium members is small enough that the coaches know who's in the room.

See what current verified members are saying and check if spots are still open

The Free Trial: How It Actually Works

This is worth explaining clearly because the structure is a bit unconventional.

PB Premium offers a 5-day free trial via a waitlist system. You claim your spot, you get approved on Monday morning, and the trial ends Friday. The design is intentional: you get a full trading week, Monday through Friday, which means you see live sessions, real alerts, and actual market action. Not a weekend preview of a Discord where nothing happens.

That's smart. A lot of trading community trials run over a weekend when the market is closed and the coaches aren't active. You're essentially previewing a ghost town. Here, the trial is structured so you see the product at full operation.

I think the waitlist model also creates a reasonable quality filter. Mass free trials tend to attract people who join, screenshot a few calls, and leave without actually engaging. The waitlist creates just enough friction to keep the quality of the trial cohort higher.

Pricing Breakdown and Who Each Tier Is For

Let's be direct about the money.

At $139.49 per month, Premium is not cheap. That's the reality. If you're trading with a $500 account, this membership costs you a meaningful percentage of your capital before you've made a single trade. That math doesn't work for everyone, and I'd rather say that plainly than pretend it doesn't matter.

For someone trading a more established account, $139 per month is the cost of one bad trade, maybe two good ones. The question isn't whether the price is high; the question is whether the coaching compresses your learning curve enough to pay for itself. Based on the reviewer who mentioned growing their account daily over a month, there's at least anecdotal evidence it does.

For tighter budgets, the ladder exists:

• Start with the free Surviving the Market PDF and Free Membership (both genuinely free)

• Add 30 Days of Identity Reps (also free) if the psychology side of trading is where you struggle, and most retail traders struggle there more than they admit

• The Mind Over Markets Program at $7 per month at renewal is almost absurdly accessible for what it includes: a flagship mindset course, two audio series, an 8-class trading course, and weekly live reviews

The Mad Maverick and SwingingBull coaching programs at $39.99 each are good middle-ground options if you want focused coaching on one specific approach without going all-in on Premium.

The Rest and Retire Newsletter is the one product I'd approach with some caution. It has one review and it's a one-star. No context on what specifically disappointed that reviewer, but at $14.99 per month it's the lowest-stakes membership in the stack, and I'd at least want to see a few more reviews before committing to it.

What I Think Has Room to Grow

The overall rating is 4.62 across 13 reviews, with 11 of those being five stars. Healthy numbers, though the review count is still relatively small for a community this size. I'd want to see 50 or 100 reviews before drawing strong conclusions from the distribution.

The one-star review exists. I don't know what drove it or which product it was attached to, but it's there. Communities this responsive to new members tend to collect that occasional outlier review from someone whose expectations weren't aligned with what the product delivers. That's industry-standard friction, not a structural problem.

The member count discrepancy is also worth noting honestly. The creator pitch references 47,000 members. The Whop store shows 3,344 store members. These aren't necessarily contradictory, since the larger number likely includes their broader community presence (Discord, social media, email list), while the Whop number reflects purchases specifically through this platform. But it's worth knowing which number you're looking at.

Is PB Premium Right for You

If you're brand new to trading and you've been sitting on the sidelines because every group you've looked at felt either too expensive, too scammy, or too advanced to enter, this is a reasonable place to start. The free entry points are genuinely useful, the coaching structure has real names and real methodologies behind it, and the free trial removes the financial risk of testing it.

If you're an intermediate trader who knows your way around a chart but keeps blowing up accounts emotionally, the mindset-focused products here (Mind Over Markets, the Identity Reps series) address something most trading groups completely ignore. The mental side of trading is where most retail accounts go to die. Staring at a chart for two hours, watching a setup develop exactly as you planned, and then hesitating until it's gone because you were scared, that's not a strategy problem. That's a psychology problem, and this community seems to be one of the few that treats it as a real subject worth teaching.

Who this probably isn't for: someone looking for a set-and-forget alert service where they copy trades without learning anything. The emphasis here is clearly on education and building skills. If you want to follow signals blindly, the product ecosystem isn't really built for that.

My Verdict on PB Premium

The free trial is the right starting point here. A full trading week, Monday through Friday, gives you enough real data to decide whether this community's style, coaching quality, and alert frequency match how you actually want to trade.

Coming back to that $4,000 to $7,000 to zero story from the reviews: that's a lot of traders' origin story. The account grows, confidence surges, options exposure multiplies, and then one bad week wipes it all out. The groups that take your money and go quiet afterward are a known hazard in this space. What made PB Premium feel different to me, based on both the product structure and the reviewer accounts, is that the educational infrastructure is built to outlast any single trade or streak.

It's not a get-rich-quick service. It's a multi-coach education platform with a free entry point and a structured trial. That's a meaningfully different thing, and at these price points, it's worth at least a week of your time to verify for yourself.

Start your free 5-day Premium trial and see the live sessions firsthand

Quick note: stock and options trading involves real financial risk. Past performance by any coach or community is not a guarantee of future results. Nothing in this review is professional financial advice. Do your own research before committing capital to any trade or subscription.