201 out of 205 reviews are five stars. Zero one-star reviews. Zero two-star reviews. That's not a typo.
When I first pulled up InTheCircle on Whop, that number stopped me cold. In the forex education space, where reviews are often bought or gamed, a 4.98 average across 205 verified buyers is either the most suspicious thing I've ever seen or the most impressive. I had to find out which.
Short answer: it's impressive. And I'll tell you exactly why, plus what you should know before you join.
If you want to skip ahead and check it yourself, see what 205 verified members are actually saying before reading another word. Whop shows buyer-verified tags on every review, so you can filter out noise instantly.
Join InTheCircle today and see if the discount popup is live on your first visit
InTheCircle is a forex trading education community built around one specific framework: market manipulation and the Interbank Price Delivery Algorithm, commonly called IPDA in institutional trading circles.
For anyone unfamiliar, IPDA is the idea that price delivery in major forex pairs isn't random. It follows an algorithmic sequence tied to interbank liquidity delivery, with predictable manipulation windows where large players engineer moves to grab retail liquidity before heading in the real direction. This is the conceptual foundation of a lot of what gets called "smart money" or "ICT-style" trading, though InTheCircle has clearly built its own specific model around it.
The creator is named Salman, and he's the person teaching, calling, and running the community directly. This isn't a faceless brand with rotating coaches. One person, one methodology.
At the time I checked, the product is called Premium University, and it runs at $99 per month.
Here's the thing about learning forex from YouTube. You watch four hours of content, you think you understand support and resistance, you take a trade Monday morning, and it stops out by Tuesday. Then someone in a Discord server says "bro you got manipulated." And you have no idea what that means.
That cycle is exhausting. The deeper problem is that most retail traders are learning a model that was designed to be on the wrong side of institutional moves. You're not learning to trade. You're learning to be the liquidity.
I've been in communities where the "mentor" posts trade setups an hour after price already moved, claims wins they didn't call in advance, and then disappears when members ask hard questions. The accountability is zero.
What Salman seems to have built here is the opposite of that model. Multiple reviews mention him being active daily, holding members accountable for their own mistakes, and giving personalized feedback on calls. One member described him as behaving like "a drill sergeant" who "comprehensively explains his market manipulation techniques and gives us critical and personalized feedback." That's not the vibe of someone who posts a chart and dips.
Based on what was available when I reviewed this, Premium University delivers:
Daily market recaps with trade analysis and specific guidance on setups
24/7 community access with 463 active members, described as a community of profitable traders
Live calls and lectures where Salman walks through his IPDA model in real time
Trading psychology content that goes beyond charts, addressing the mental side of execution
Personalized feedback on trades and mistakes, not just generic commentary
The daily recap element is one I want to emphasize because it's underrated. The hardest part of retail trading isn't finding a strategy. It's consistently applying it across market conditions that shift week to week. Having someone pull up that day's price action and explain what the algorithm was doing, in real time with hindsight context, accelerates the pattern recognition process faster than almost anything else.
The psychology component also gets called out repeatedly in reviews. One member wrote that Salman's "teachings go beyond the charts" and provides "eye-opening psychology content that makes us question ourselves as traders and people." That's not a small thing. Bad psychology is the single biggest reason profitable strategies fail in live accounts.
Start building real market context inside the community
InTheCircle launched in 2024 and has grown to 680 store members in that time. That's a relatively young operation, which is worth being honest about if you're comparing it to longer-running communities.
But the review velocity tells a different story. 205 reviews with a 4.98 average from a community that size means a very high percentage of buyers are voluntarily leaving five-star feedback. That doesn't happen in mediocre communities. It happens when people feel like their money is being respected.
The reviews name Salman directly, repeatedly. They describe him as "always active," "super consistent," "never slacking." One reviewer specifically mentioned trusting him because of his personal values and character, not just his trading knowledge. Another said the strategy is "simple and actually PROVEN with data" and that "people who have different skill levels come in and do well extremely quick."
What I notice across the reviews is consistent specificity. Nobody's writing "great mentor, highly recommend." They're writing about specific things: the model working, the psychology content shifting their mindset, being held accountable for bad trades. That's the texture of genuine feedback from people who are actually inside something.
I also want to note: the creator pitch says Salman has "dedicated his career" to understanding market manipulation and IPDA. That's a focused claim, not a broad "I trade everything" pitch. Focused expertise in a narrow methodology tends to produce better outcomes for students than generalist content.
Check the full review page and read verified buyer feedback yourself
At the time I checked, the only plan available is $99 per month. There's no annual plan, no lifetime option, and no free trial listed.
Let me put that in context. The forex education space ranges from free YouTube channels to programs charging $3,000 to $10,000 upfront for "mentorship" that turns out to be pre-recorded videos and a Discord server with a few hundred members who are just as lost as you are.
$99 monthly with an active mentor running daily recaps and live calls is, frankly, on the more reasonable end. One useful trade setup per month would cover the cost. The break-even math on a $99 education subscription is not complicated if you're already trading real capital.
The monthly structure also means you're not locked in. If it doesn't deliver value in month one, you cancel. That's actually a form of accountability in itself, because a community that doesn't retain members will die. The fact that this one has 463 active members inside Premium University and is still growing suggests retention is happening.
One thing I'd suggest: check the Whop page directly when you visit for the first time. Whop occasionally surfaces welcome discount popups for new visitors on some products, and it's worth landing on the page fresh to see if anything is available before you commit at full price.
Verify the current pricing and check for any available discount
This is for you if:
You've already spent time learning basic forex concepts and you're tired of setups that don't work in live market conditions
You're specifically interested in institutional or algorithmic market structure, not pattern trading or indicator-heavy strategies
You want a community where the mentor is visibly present and accountable, not a passive resource library
You're at any skill level but willing to learn a specific model from scratch rather than patching together fragments from different approaches
This is probably not the right fit if you want a fully self-paced experience with no community interaction, or if you're looking for signals without wanting to understand why the trades work. The educational focus here seems genuine, not signal-service disguised as mentorship.
The member who wrote "People who have different skill levels come in and do well extremely quick" is a useful signal. That suggests the model is being taught in a way that's actually translatable, not gatekept behind jargon.
The one area with room to grow, from my external view, is transparency around track record documentation. Published performance data with verified statistics would give prospective members even more confidence in the methodology. That's not a dealbreaker by any measure, especially for a community this new, and the review volume partially fills that gap. But it's something I'd push for as the community scales.
What stands out positively:
Near-perfect review score across 205 verified buyers, which is exceptionally rare in this niche
Active, named mentor who provides daily recaps and live personalized feedback
Specific methodology (IPDA and market manipulation) rather than generic trading education
Monthly pricing with no long-term lock-in
Psychology content included alongside technical education
What's worth knowing before you join:
Launched in 2024, so the track record is shorter than older programs
Only one pricing plan at the time of this review, no trial or annual option visible
The methodology has a learning curve if you're entirely new to institutional concepts
Think about the last time you sat through a webinar that promised to teach you "the secret the pros use," paid a few hundred dollars for a course, and then never opened module three because the first two were just rehashed basics you already knew. That's the standard experience in this space.
InTheCircle is operating in a different category. The review signal here is genuinely unusual. 205 reviews, 4.98 average, zero one-stars, and real people naming the mentor by name and describing specific outcomes. Eight months in the community and still not wanting to leave. One week in and already seeing results. That's not manufactured social proof.
At $99 a month with no long-term commitment required, the cost of finding out is low relative to what's at stake in your trading.
Join InTheCircle and start learning the IPDA model from a mentor who shows up daily
Quick note: forex trading involves real financial risk. Nothing in this article is professional financial advice. Results described in member reviews represent individual experiences and are not guaranteed. Do your own due diligence before committing capital to any trading strategy or education program.