Floppy ears

Item: 

Toy bone

[Location: Appeal, Explore]

Terrarium head

Item: 

Miracle Seed

[Location: Explore]

Bunny ears

Item: 

Painted egg

Butterfly ears

Item: 

Pink Pearl

[Location: Explore]

Axolotl ears

Item: 

Pearl

[Location: Explore]

Little bird ears

Item: 

Silver feather

[Location: Explore]

Bat ears

Item: 

Light Clay

[Location: Explore]

Tufted ears

Item: 

Balm Mushroom

[Location: Explore]

Star shaped ears

Item: 

Blue Star piece

[Location: Explore]

Wisp horns

Item: 

Flame essence

[Location: Explore]

Flowering horns

Item: 

Yellow Nectar

Terrarium Horns

Item: 

Purple Nectar

[Location: Crafting]

Antennas

Item: 

Fuzzy antenna

[Location: Explore]

Coral horns

Item: 

Heart scale

[Location: Explore]

Bunny tails

Item: 

Chocolate egg

[Location: Explore]

Pom tails

Item: 

Pale seed

[Location: Explore]

Curled tails

Item: 

Golden Bell

[Location: Explore]

Lavish tails

Item: 

Silky pearl

[Location: Explore]

Sentient tails

Item: 

Soul dew

[Location: Explore]

Deep sea tails 

Item: 

Red scale

[Location: Explore]

Axolotl tails

Item: 

Big pearl

[Location: Explore]

Little bird tail feathers

Item: 

Golden feather

[Location: Explore]

Comet tails

Item: 

Little Comet

[Location: Explore]

Star-cut tails 

Item: 

Yellow Star piece

[Location: Explore]

Reptile tails

Item: 

Grip Claw 

[Location: Explore]

Wispy tails

Item: 

Blue Flame essence

[Location: Explore]

Insect tails

Item: 

Honey

[Location: Explore]

Puff Tails

Item: 

Seedling

[Location: Crafting]

Shaped Tails

Item: 

Bottle Cap

[Location: Crafting]

Stardust Tails

Item: 

Mystic Orb

[Location: Crafting]

Water Tails

Item: 

Soda Pop

[Location: Crafting]

Body plant growth

Item: 

Luminous moss

[Location: Explore/Shop]

Terrarium body

Item: 

Grassy seed

[Location: Explore/Shop]

Water body 

Item: 

Lily pad

[Location: Explore/Shop]

Chibi wings 

Item: 

Pretty wing

[Location: Explore/Shop]

Full wings

Item: 

Clever wing

[Location: Explore/Shop]

Bat wings

Item: 

Bat wing

[Location: Explore/Shop]

Dragon wings

Item: 

Charcoal

[Location: Explore]

Insect wings

Item: 

Insect wing

[Location: Explore/Shop]

Butterfly wings

Item: 

Yellow Pearl

[Location: Explore/Shop]

Butterfly Growth 

Item: 

Blue Pearl

[Location: Explore/Shop]

Slime Body

Item: 

Black Pearl

[Location: Explore/Fishing]

Scales 

Item: 

Deep Sea scale

[Location: Explore/Shop]

Cosmic mane

Item: 

Cosmic essence

[Location: Explore]

Coral growth

Item: 

Prism scale

[Location: Explore]

Exposed insides

Item: 

Black Sludge

[Location: Explore]

Elemental Insides

Item: 

Green Sludge

[Location: Explore]

Bug Body

Item: 

Hard Shell

[Location: Crafting]

Frills

Item: 

Beach Glass

[Location: Explore]

Fins

Item: 

Deep sea tooth

[Location: Explore]

Body spikes

Item: 

Heat Rock

[Location: Explore]

Extra Limbs

Item: 

Smooth Rock

[Location: Crafting]

Aura

Item: 

Rainbow pearl

[Location: Explore/Crafting]

Crystalized Markings

Item: 

Never Melt Ice

[Location: April Showers Event/Shop]

Moodstones

Item: 

Moodstone

[Location: Shop]

Bead Body

Item: 

Beads

[Location: Shop]

Halo

Item: 

Broken Halo

[Location: Explore]

Elemental companions

Item: 

Stardust

[Location: Explore]

Body Eyes 

Item: 

Red Glowing Orb

[Location: Crafting]

Grass/Flower Path

Item: 

Green Candy

[Location: Spring Event]

Petal Path

Item: 

Pink Candy

[Location: Spring Event]

Cloud Path

Item: 

Yellow Candy

[Location: April Showers Event]

Rainbow Path

Item: 

Rainbow Candy

[Location: Shop]

Candle Horns

Item: 

Melted Candle

[Location: Fall Event ]

Glowing Eyes 

Item: 

Glowing Orb

[Location: October Event ]

Hooves

Item: 

Hard Stone

[Location: Fall Event ]

Leafy Ears

Item: 

White Herb

[Location: Fall Event ]

Saber Teeth

Item: 

Razer Fang

[Location: Fall Event ]

Leafy Fur

Item: 

Red Herb

[Location: Fall Event ]

Leaf Tails

Item: 

Dark Herb

[Location: Fall Event ]

Saber Claws

Item: 

Razer Claw

[Location: Fall Event ]

Bird Feet

Item: 

Sticky Barb

[Location: October Event ]

Tendrils

Item: 

Shed Shell

[Location: October Event ]

Bat Nose

Item: 

Dark Clay

[Location: October Event ]

Weather Tails

Item: 

Misty Seed

[Location: April Showers Event]

Cloudy Fur

Item: 

Small Blue Candy

[Location: April Showers Event]

Cloudy Ears

Item: 

Large Blue Candy

[Location: April Showers Event]