On Sept. 17 2026, a question was raised in r/SEO asking about a blog which you had for 5+ years. Should you keep old posts? Re-write or remove them? The question received 21 upvotes and 55 comments. Our study of 260 dated pages cites it. Here we discuss the comments. We used the AgntData API to fully retrieve the thread on November 17 2026. It retrieved 41 of the 55 comments. 7 of them are AutoModerator messages that the CQS score is low. 7 comments are "[removed]" only. There are 27 comments which can be read. There are 15 top level answers.
15 top level answers and 8 of them are from data. u/WebLinkr and u/k4rm1c start from Search Console. u/BigMioWolf looks for backlinks before deleting anything. u/mnudu refreshes everything that has search demand or backlinks. u/ridddder looks at GA4. u/WxMan2201 crawls blog using screaming frog then combine the data with Search console and GA4. u/kemalios starts from posts in positions 5-15 that have impressions but no clicks. u/PMDevSolutions with the most detailed recipe: export 16 months of pages and top linked pages from Search console. Then compare with sitemap.
Two answers sort them into a few groups. u/BigMioWolf uses 4 groups: update (still getting impressions/links. Keep the URL), merge/301 (have multiple but thin posts on the same subject), leave (small but consistent traffic), delete (zero traffic, zero links. No point). u/PMDevSolutions just has 3 questions in that order: has it had any clicks/impressions in 12 months? Or has it had any legit backlinks? (keep and refresh), same topic as another post that's newer? (merge + 301), neither (410 or redirect to the closest category page 301). Their advice is always redirect to the closest thing rather than the homepage. They claim google thinks of the homepage as a soft 404.
Also, u/PMDevSolutions states that if you leave a year (such as Best X for 2019) in a title tag it will decrease clicks on a post that would otherwise be ranking. u/WxMan2201 mentions that the pages that are getting in Search Console crawled but not indexed are usually deeper/older blog posts.
One comment argues against updating just to update. u/WebLinkr on September 26, 2026 replies to u/TIPRock88 suggesting updating posts for search engine crawl and index. Old posts probably already indexed. No need to be current to rank or index. u/TheDiscountPrinter and u/odonnelldale: let them be history. u/ridddder: archive. Don't delete.
Looking through all 27 of the actually-readable comments there isn't a post count or before and after rank of what was retained, merged or lost per the commenter. We did a check on October 19, 2026, and found 85 of 260 dated pages that rank or are cited were at least 3 years old at the time we checked.
Ram writes about this for RankControl, an AI SEO and AEO platform. RankControl's AI traffic analytics shows GPTBot, PerplexityBot and ClaudeBot visits and AI referrals per assistant.