Someone on r/GEO_optimization on July 1, 2026 indicated that 73% of AI cited pages for a team were showing 0 measurable traffic over 90 days. We use that as our reality check for our 90-day AI SEO plan. This page will cover the remainder of the thread, which we read in its entirety on 11/13/2026. There were 31 upvotes, and 45 comments. We got 34 (3 removed) back from the public list.
The 3 patterns the poster mentioned for the 73%. 1) Engines pick up a stat or a definition often. So people read what they need without having to visit. 2) If a page is the 1st or 2nd source referenced by AI responses, you get 11x as many clicks as if you're the 3rd+ source. 3) Questions like "What is X" are rarely clicky. But questions involving comparison/pricing, "best X for Y" are still clicky since the AI response isn't complete for those questions. They switched from just reporting citation counts to reporting % of citations which converted to clicks (citation to click rate).
Responses brought additional data - all from poster.
On 07/04/2026 the poster wrote that they moved ~60% of their content budget from informational to comparison / evaluation type questions and saw qualified traffic from AI sources increase within 3 weeks.
On 07/04/2026 the poster reported that with the increased amount of citation the branded queries went up by 40%. AI referrals hardly moved.
On 07/03 the poster added that ~20% of their pages accounted for 80% of the heavy lifting in getting citations.
No data table included in any of the 3.
The thread also shows the limitations of 73%. On July 12, 2026, the poster admitted that Claude + Gemini referrals are almost negligible in GA, probably filed under direct / organic. They admitted the prompts they monitored might not be the actual prompts (i.e. user ask). On the same day in a second response the poster wrote "we don't have a perfect methodology either." On Aug 25, 2026, the commenter claiming to own product Limelit suggested a server logs check. The question is if the user initiated fetches (AI engine is reading the page live because user asked) reaches the same URLs in the same time frame as citations. If citations and user initiated fetches + no referrals, then there are visitors and we are losing them in the analytics.
There is no indication of the number of pages for which 73% is true, nor is there a division by engine or indication of which tool was used to count the citations.
Ram writes about this for RankControl, an AI SEO and AEO platform. RankControl's AI traffic analytics shows GPTBot, PerplexityBot and ClaudeBot visits and AI referrals per assistant.