There were four different counters that came up with the numbers behind the claim that Reddit got phased out of ChatGPT after GPT-5.6. And each counter was counting a different thing. This page is the page where we line them all up. It accompanies our write-up of the Reddit and listicle numbers. We re-read the Promptwatch and Peec AI and OpenAI pages on 11/11/2026. The Nectiv numbers below pass through an article that Lily Ray wrote on 8/17.
All 4 measured GPT-5.6. On August 6, 2026, OpenAI announced in their release notes that they upgraded the GPT-5.6 Sol for Plus/Pro users and set GPT-5.6 Luna as the default for Free and Go users that week. GPT-6 Astra was released to a select set of organizations on September 3 and GPT-6 Sol and Luna on October 7. So, none of these numbers reflect the most popular model currently in use.
Counter 1: Promptwatch counts a share of citations. On August 18 they said that reddit.com had averaged 3.83% of ChatGPT Search citations between July 18 and August 7 and 0.52% of citations between August 14 and 17, a relative drop of 86.4%. Search Engine Journal wrote about it on August 19 and mentions that Promptwatch says the magnitude of the drop is provisional and they can't exclude a data collection issue on their part. By the way, a percentage also drops when others get cited more.
Counter 2: Peec AI counts retrieved pages. David Konitzny at Peec AI has been tracking (by indexing the weekly counts from ChatGPT's own interface) for a single set of unchanged prompts. The average for July is 100. In the September 11 post, the number of retrieved pages from Reddit is 31. From listicles is 92. From all sources, 175. The other Peec AI cut (for buying questions, Aug 10) shows listicles dropped from 15.47% of retrieved pages to 8.19%.
Counter 3: Nectiv counts searches through the API. Chris Long from Nectiv ran 4000ish prompts against GPT-5.6 Sol through OpenAI's api and benchmarked this against 2025 baseline. They saw background searches/prompt increase from 2.17 to 7.61. 64% of queries used the site: operator. Lily Ray has an article which implies the gap between 64% and Peec AI's 23% and Promptwatch's ~17% use of searches through it might be the data source (the api repeats, the app is what people see).
Counter 4: one account. On July 24 & 25, 2026, Suganthan Mohanadasan had 57 conversations in one chatGPT Plus account in Dubai. For this, chatGPT fetched 3,554 pages, cited 110 (about 3.1%), but the researcher says every percentage on this experiment is directional.
Before trusting a report, what are the 3 things you need to question? 1) Is it percentage or number? 2) Is it number of cited pages or number of retrieved pages? 3) Is it from API? or the app? So, a report saying listicles dropped half of its share is true. A report that says listicles retrievals were still 92 of 100 is true too.
Ram writes about this for RankControl, an AI SEO and AEO platform. RankControl's AI visibility tracker tracks citations across 7 AI engines: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews.