Module 2: Community Genre Analysis
In module 1, you must have decided on one of your communities and one of the social issues that you want to work with or study. But do you think your study will be the first of its kind? Of course not. Are there any resources or sources of information about the community or agency? Have some other scholars already researched your topic, issue, community, or agency? Probably, yes. Do they exist as research papers, YouTube videos, websites, social media posts, or any other? Perhaps, they exist. Do they exist as visuals, audio, multimodal, digital multimodal, written, oral, etc.? Perhaps, yes. Research always begins with what already exists. In asking all these questions, my purpose is to make you familiar with genres and genre conventions that we did in RWS 1301, module 3.
In literature, some genres are novels, poems, and short stories. In music, some genres include country, jazz, blues, hip hop or rock. In this RWS class, genre refers more to rhetorical forms such as articles, books, fliers, videos, emails, blogs, or comics. The genre an author uses dictates a great deal of what the author can or cannot do when they write. (p. 305)
Hence, community genre analysis, in this module, means a rhetorical analysis of two distinct genres that already exist on your community, topic, and agency:
Students will identify two distinct texts in different genres (written, visual, and/or oral) created by their organization or related to their selected issue. Students will write an explanatory genre analysis of the two texts and how they operate rhetorically. Students will engage in peer review activities during the writing process. (p. 305)
Thus, again, the rhetorical situation comes into play when you conduct research. As an RWS student, you are highly encouraged to think of rhetorical situations of research: “this module focuses on strategies such as target audience of a communication, the rhetorical situation from which the issue and organization come, and the use of various writing strategies” (p. 305).
Now, the question is how to conduct genre analysis, then? UTEP FYCH has clear instructions about it:
Once you become comfortable identifying genres, your major purpose for this module is to analyze and consider the ways in which your chosen organization or agency reaches its target audience(s). Organizations often rely on the support of other institutions, businesses and citizens like you who receive emails, links to websites, or maybe letters with return address labels. This group of recipients constitutes an important audience because this audience helps to support the mission and goals of the organization. Other audiences that organizations reach are community members in need of support. This audience may not use email if they do not have access to the internet, for example; they must be reached other ways.” (p. 306).
It means the genre analysis revolves around an analysis of the audience. However, audience entails all other components of effective communication. They are motive or purpose, message, ethos, pathos, logos, structure, delivery, form, content, diction or word choice, etc. All these elements enhance each other and help the communicator (community, agency, researchers, etc.) to pass the message across effectively, producing an intended result. Hence, community genre analysis means an analysis of all these elements.
Discussion Questions:Literary Genres
Film and Poetry: Sub-genres
Genres and Genre Analysis in RWS 1302
RWS 1302,
Module 2: Community Genre Analysis
Peer-Review Sheet
(NB: There are many ways to do peer review, but you can tentatively follow the following prompts, but feel free to add something that you feel needs to be reviewed...)
Name of the Reviewer:_______________
Name of the Author:____________________
The Title of the Essay:____________________
Review Date: _________________________
1. Does the essay have a suitable title? Do you suggest a better title?
Write Your Review:
2. Does the essay have an introduction? Does the introduction clearly explain a purpose and process of doing the community genre analysis? Do you have any suggestions for making the introduction better?
Write Your Review:
3. How many sub-titles or paragraphs are there in the entire essay? Are they logically connected? Do you have any suggestions for revising the overall structure of the essay?
Write Your Review:
4. How many points or issues or elements (for example, purpose, context, audience, ethos, pathos, logos, etc.) have the writer analyzed? Do you suggest the writer add some more sub-titles to make the analysis more substantial?
Write Your Review:
5. What citation style has the writer followed, APA or MLA? Does the writer follow the correct citation styles? Does the essay have some quotes from the texts along with in-text citations? Please point out some errors.
Write Your Review:
6. Does the essay have uniformity in the length of paragraphs? Are some paragraphs too long and some paragraphs too short? If so, please point out them and suggest for revision.
Write Your Review:
7. Has the writer added ‘References’ (APA) or ‘Works Cited’ (MLA) at the end? Are they correctly formatted? Point out some errors if any.
Write Your Review:
8. Are there some grammar and word choice (diction) issues? If so, please point them out and suggest revisions.
Write Your Review:
9. Please, give an overall evaluation for the paper. Don’t give a letter grade, but describe what you liked the most about the paper, and what issues are to be addressed or revised before final submission.
Write Your Review:
10. Anything you want to add...? Please write....
Write Your Review:
Thank you!