Design Tips 7
Topics
Fired Equipment
No of Burners on turndown: Below 20-30% load on start-up or steam:air decoking or refractory drying switch off a few burners, still maintaining heat release symmetry. With N operating burners, theoretically you can go down to single burner, 5N:1 or 3N:1. Using bigger than standard pilot burners, one can switch to pilot burners only to provide more turndown. It doesn’t matter if BWT is below auto-ignition temperature of fuel. Your kitchen or room heating gas burner operates with room at ambient temperature. Heater refractory is dried at low firebox temperature
No of Burners: Do rotate switched off burners. Remove or keep their guns cooled, as once fuel flow stops, the guns are not internally cooled. Keep their air registers totally blanked-off to avoid tramp air. Reduced flue gas flow during part load, reduces draft loss, increases available draft, leading to more Xs and tramp air. Modulate stack damper to keep arch draft low. Read about tramp air + unfired burners in ‘Fired Heaters - Operations’ in Training
No of Burners: Even after you cut-off a few burners, the control valve hunting may impact fuel flow and flame out. Control valve may have minimum stop and charts may be developed for firing on minimum stop + a smaller number of burners. Don’t rely on min stops - clamp-on stop or welded one may break loose - after chattering-hits. As fuel composition changes over a day in plants that make their own fuels, go for a small parallel FCV / PCV and bring it online at part load
Heater treaters Vs Stabilizers: Treaters heat heavy / high viscosity oil forming stable emulsion with water to break the stable emulsion. Stabilizers strip off of light ends from a condensate to maintain RVP
Emulsion Heaters: Go for a direct fired heater with emulsion in tubes. Avoid firetube bath heaters. Salt deposits on firetubes lead to overheating and failure. Case study
Equal Flow Vs Equal COT: Go for equal flow in all passes. Usually, pass inlet FCV keeps equal flow. Minor variations in coil outlet temperatures (COT) are OK, fouling or coking in one or two tubes. If you reduce flow to a coked pass on manual control to increase its COT, it will coke more, a vicious cycle
Draft Control: Read in ‘Fired Heaters - Operations’ in Training on adjusting both stack and burner/FD Fan damper step by step. Duct/ stack are designed for 120% design load. At operating and part loads, draft losses are low. Partially close stack dampers to maintain arch at 1-2 mm WC. Instead of single blade, multiple blade stack dampers provide better control
Draft Control: Some adjust stack damper alone, make arch pressure +ive to reduce burner draft and Xs air, as it is a pain to adjust individual burners. Some believe that by +ive draft, you can force heat into tubes. Firebox heat is by radiation. Sun is far way and its radiation reaches us across space without any huff and puff. +ive firebox pressure makes the flue gas flow thru arch refractory, heat its supports, warp roof casing and brings down the “roof”. Case study. Tale-tale brown spots on casing. No need for arch PAHH set at 0 mm WC. Alarm should do
Draft: On part load operation, lower stack exit velocity may result in air incursion via stack tip. This recirculation may reduce stack gas temperature - reducing stack effect + acid gas condensation. Stack heat loss may also cool part load flue gases
Draft: Prevailing wind Vs Draft Gauge orientation impacts draft reading by ±5mm (0.2”WC), especially in coastal areas.
Tramp Air: Tramp air gets in via unlit burners, open peep holes and tube sheet holes around tubes header boxes. Seal all openings to cut tramp air. Fire box has the highest draft or tramp air pulling capability. While O2 probe at arch is better than in stack, unless combustibles (CO/ HC) are measured, cutting Xs air on O2 alone will result in unburnt fuel and/or potential explosion due to tramp air
Flame Impingement: Lower Xs air leads to longer flames. Longer flames or closely located burners lead to flame interaction causing flame lick on tubes. Most flame licks are due to bad burner maintenance. A coked oil tip not regularly cleaned can result in directed flames and hot gas. Gas guns also coke when there is liquid carry over. Missing or broken burner tile directs flame towards tubes. Mostly, it is hot gas rather than flame impingement. You can observe with saw or coal dust thrown in air. (Courtesy: Dr RD Reed, "Furnace Operations"). Use sodium bicarbonate, Daniel Gonnet in LinkedIn. Sparklers show flue gas path and impingement, if any
Tube Hot Spots: Can occur in any configuration, VC/ Box/ Cabin or vertical/ horizontal tubes, single/ double fired. Heater construction, coil layout, misdirected burner throw from dirty tips. Keeping burner tips clean is a dirty job but essential. Read revamps.com/Revamps/documents/170.pdf, Tony Barletta. A few skin thermocouples may read higher, due to poor pad welding with an air gap between the tube and thermocouple. Hot gas impingement causes overheating/ coking. See ‘Fired Heaters - Operation’ in Training. In vertical heaters, tubes are equally exposed, even if you have 8 passes. In box heater with 4 passes, 2 on top and 2 at bottom of side walls. Bottom passes receive more heat + coking. Downward flue gases recirculation behind tubes - between tubes and wall, promotes good mixing. Tall fireboxes promote higher flue gas recirculation
Finalize tube internal cleaning (decoking/ pigging/ turbining) and external cleaning options - robotic or water jetting of convection external surfaces. Ask for access provisions
FD Fan Air Inlet: Specify minimum air intake height to suck air free of hydrocarbon from plant leaks. See LNG Plant blown off on Safety Alerts
Flame Scanning: An air swept flame scanner will keep it cool and have its scanning face free of dust
Coastal or plains location: Firebox puffing due to wind induced momentary air starvation, as wind ebbs and flows. Case study. Wind barriers or FD Fans help
Fuel Supply SDVs: Adding a SOV on FCV/PCV to make it a SDV is no longer allowed. No protection against “control valve stuck open” scenario. A FC (Fail Closed) valve can still get stuck open. FCV/PCV is not a TSO valve. Its control action results in seat wiredraw damage. Frequently operated valves such as control valves, wear easily and are a source of gas leak. Soft seated SDV offers better TSO. Quarter-turn ball and plug valves, used as block valves are better than gate and globe valves. Eventually all valves leak, including SDV. That’s why a DBB is provided, to vent any leak past the first valve. SDV is wired to SIS/ESD system, a separate and independent layer of protection