John Hinckley Jr. being detained after attempting to shoot Reagan, 1981. (New York Times)
Early Life & Upbringing
John Hinckley Jr. was born May 29th, 1955, to his father John Hinckley Sr., founder of Vanderbilt Energy Corporation, and his mother Jo Ann Hinckley, a stay-at-home wife and homemaker. Although his father’s wealth gave Hinckley a great deal of privilege, he offered little emotional support, leaving Hinckley’s emotional needs to his mother. Hinckley was born in Ardmore, Oklahoma, but by the age of four, he and his parents had moved to the University Park neighborhood in Dallas, Taxes, an area known for its affluent residence as well as their high esteem.
Through his school years, Hinckley’s father held high expectations for his son, ones that seemed impossible to reach. His mother was also emotionally withdrawn, leaving Hinckley to fend for himself in the complicated family dynamic. High school was a social nightmare for a young Hinckley. With social stigma from peers, Hinckley became more and more reclusive; he rarely spent time with friends, opting to spend hours alone. By the time he left University Park High, fellow students had begun to refer to Hinckley as a “non-guy”, someone who almost didn’t exist in society. After high school, Hinckley enrolled in Texas Tech University, though his academic performance was lackluster. His enrollment was intermittent; from 1974 to 1980, he would enroll and drop out multiple times. This constant failure left Hinckley feeling lost and frustrated, prompting him to look for fulfillment elsewhere.
In 1975, Hinckley left his family home for Los Angeles in hopes of finding a music career as a songwriter. However, he would not find success and quickly became disillusioned with the city. He would frequently write to his parents about his hardships, asking for final assistance. During his time in LA, Hinckley also wrote his parents about a new girlfriend, Lynn Collins, who turned out to be a complete fabrication, a character manifested from the women from John’s favorite movie, Taxi Driver.
By the end of 1976, Hinckley’s disillusionment brought him back to his family home in Colorado, and his hopes and dreams of a music career shattered. By 1980, Hinckley began to shift. His emotional troubles deepened, and he began to purchase firearms before becoming increasingly fixated on historical acts of violence.
Jodie Foster
Hinckley's obsession with Jodie Foster began in LA when he saw her in his favorite movie, Taxi Driver; at the time of filming, she was just age 14. Foster portrayed Iris, a young girl who was a victim of sex trafficking. Foster's portrayal had a profound effect on John. Hinckley soon began to mirror the character of Travis Bickle (Robert De Niro), the protagonist of the film and Iris's savior. Hinckley imbrued the character's clothing style and even some aspects of his anti-hero personality. As his distorted comfort in his new persona grew, so did his obsession with Jodie Foster. Hinckley gradually lost the ability to separate Iris's character from Foster's performance. He viewed Foster as a vulnerable young woman in need of rescue.
In 1980, when Foster began at Yale University, Hinckley saw this time as an opportunity to act on his love. In the hope of giving their son some direction, Hinckley's parents agreed to fund writing courses for him at Yale. However, Hinckley had no intention of holding his promises to his parents. Rather, he moved to New Haven in an attempt to meet with Foster face-to-face. John would send Foster his original poetry. He found her dorm's phone number and began to call her frequently, leaving countless messages. Despite these attempts, Foster refused to respond to him. Agitated by her dismissal, Hinckley contemplated tragic action in order to earn her attention and admiration. He contemplated hijacking a plane or even taking his own life in front of her; certain such actions would finally earn her love. Ultimately, Hinckley decided that he would need to commit a grand, extreme act that would secure him a place in history.
Assassination Attempt
Hinckley took months to plan his assassination attempt on Ronald Reagan. He truly believed that this brave, historic act would get her attention, though it is pure historical significance. Hinckley’s actions, in no short terms, were highly inspired by Bickle’s actions in Taxi Driver, where the protagonist plots his political assassination.
The morning of March 30, 1981, Hinckley traveled to Washington D.C with a .22-caliber Röhm RG-14 revolver hidden in his jacket; he had spent months practicing with the firearm. Hinckley arrived at the Hilton Hotel by 9:30 AM and positioned himself among the crowd of onlookers waiting for the president’s arrival. After hours of waiting, around 2:30 PM, Reagan and the Secret Service exited the hotel, crossing the sidewalk to his motorcade. Hinckley, only a mere 20 feet from the president, acted quickly and fired six rounds.
The first round stuck Secret Service agent Timothy McCarthy, who stood in front of the president. The second struck press James Brady in the temple; the wound would take his life four days later. The third round hit police officer Thomas Delahanty in the neck, leaving him with lasting complications for the rest of his life. The fourth shot ricocheted off the pavement, striking Reagan in the chest. The fifth and sixth shots did not hit a target.
The assassination attempt had a surprising effect on the population. While, at first, the nation was horrified, Reagan’s calm demeanor and strength in the face of the danger blustered his popularity. His speedy recovery and ability to joke over the matter were resented deeply by the public. Instead of demising his status, the attempt only led to an outpouring of support for Reagan; some political scholars claim that the shooting may have played a large factor in Reagan’s re-election in 1984.
Trial
The trial quickly became one of the most informed cases in U.S. history, due to both the high-profile nature of those involved and the controversial defense. The prosecution opened with clear evidence proving Hinckley was responsible for the attack on Reagan, as well as the other victims of the shooting outside the D.C. hotel. The shooting was very public and viewed by many eyewitnesses, and the event was even captured on video. However, the defense argued that Hinckley could not be held responsible for his actions under reason of insanity. Hinckley was put under psychiatric evaluations; government psychiatrists determined that Hinckley was legally sane at the time of both the crime and the trial. Psychiatrists from the defense, however, diagnosed him with schizophrenia, stating that he was legally insane.
The defense would continue their focus on Hinckley's mental state, claiming that his infatuation with Jodie Foster led to his emulation of the character Travis Bickle From Taxi Driver, ultimately leading to his actions. This legal strategy painted a picture of a young man who had "lost touch with reality" and whose "delusions were proof of his unfit mental state." On the other hand, the prosecution argued that Hinckley was not insane but rather just a spoiled, manipulative man who had the mental capability to plan and execute the shooting meticulously.
Jodie Foster's filmed testimony, something Hinckley had been insistent on, proved pivotal in his defense. Foster's testimony was not what Hinckley had expected and left him emotionally destroyed as he watched her claim that she did not know him personally and never encouraged or acknowledged his advances. The emotional hit left Hinckley in hysterics, leading to a dramatic outburst in the middle of the courtroom. The defense used this outburst to further prove Hinckley's instability and inability to understand the wrongs of his actions.
On June 21st, 1982, after over three days of deliberation, the jury found Hinckley "not guilty by reason of insanity" on all counts.
Impact on Insanity Defense Reform
Hinckley's trial was perceived by the public as an abuse of the insanity defense, stating that they believed it allowed a person who had committed a tyrannical act to go free. The outcome of the trial had led to significant changes in this examination and its handling in the U.S. judicial system.
Just weeks after the verdict was issued, Congress held multiple hearings to discuss the role of 'insanity' in the court room. Senator Arlen Specter proposed a bill that stated that the defense would have to prove mental illness, rather than the prosecution having to argue that the perpetrator was sane. Reagan supported this change, arguing that proving someone's sanity should not have been as difficult as it had been through Hinckley's trial. Because of much outcry from the public, many states ended up reforming their own defense laws in relation to the insanity verdict. By the mid-1980s, two-thirds of the U.S. had shifted their burden of proof in these cases; states like Utah went even further, completely redacting the defense as valid. Other states took up a "guilty, but mentally ill" verdict, where a defendant would receive treatment for their illness while facing the punishment for their crime.
Federally, Congress enacted the Insanity Defense Reform Act of 1984, which heavily narrowed the scope of the insanity defense. This would require a defense team to prove that their defendant was suffering from severe mental illness or defect that made them incompetent to understanding the nature of their actions on the world around them. The act also deemed defendant claims of their own inability invalid.
An original painting by John Hinckley, depicting one of his cats. (ArtPal)
Publicity shots of Hinckley after signing a record deal for a folk album. (Fortune)
Why He Did It
A deep, complex web of emotional isolation, narcissistic delusions, and a compulsive, obsessive pattern of behavior influenced Hinckley’s actions. His childhood was marked by a distance put in place by his father, forming a strict, overly formal relationship with his parents, ultimately negating his alertness to connect to others in the school. The lack of emotional connection, as well as a growing alienation and detachment, left Hinckley more and more vulnerable to fixation.
At the center of his delusions was his obsession with actress Jodie Foster and her Character Iris on Taxi Driver, which, left unchecked, evolved into an all-consuming fixation. Iris’s desperate situation leads to Hinckley’s composition to “rescue” the very real Jodie Foster from a very fictional circumstance. Hinckley deeply believed that by emulating her savor from the film Travis Bickle, he would prove his worthiness to Foster and establish a connection between the two of them.
Life After Release
In the years following his release from psychiatric care in 2016, after over 41 years of inpatient treatment, Hinckley was determined to build a new life away from his criminal past. While he remained under certain restrictions, such as media limitations and strict no-contact orders from Foster, Hinckley has sought to pursue his original passions. In recent years, he has focused on creating music and has expressed interest in opening a record shop in Williamsburg, where he currently resides. Though he has managed to maintain a fairly low profile, he has continued to sell his original art pieces online, as well as produce ordinal folk music on his YouTube channel.
As of recent, he has attempted to gather a somewhat cultic following through his "John Hinckley Community Church", where he flaunts an official flag as well as a list of supporters on his website (find the link below). "The John Hinckley Community is a refuge from this wicked world. We are a place where you can feel safe and cherished. The world will laugh at you and mock you and disown you. But the John Hinckley Community will embrace you and give you all the love you need."
"He died so that our love could live."
Additional Resources
His apology: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k46rWLMXoHc
On Hinckley’s release: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UdNyYGmkx6o
Finally Living Free: An original song by John Hinckley: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXb-MZjJ_Hg
John Hinckley's website, his Community: https://www.johnhinckleycommunity.com/
Parasocial relationships: https://www.findapsychologist.org/parasocial-relationships-the-nature-of-celebrity-fascinations/