The Multimodal Research Project
The Multimodal Research Project: A Technology-Driven Argumentation Assignment
For many years in my freshmen rhetoric and composition college courses, I have required students to complete a series of multimodal research project assignments to create web articles that respond to real world issues; each web article is to forward an argument (arranged by a rhetorical mode) about a real world issue and is supported by research information from multimodal texts.
Using Multimodal Texts as Evidence to One's Ideas
A multimodal text refers to any text that contains 2 of the 5 semiotic systems: 1) linguistic; 2) visual; 3) audio; 4) gestural; 5) spatial. An example of a multimodal text is a tweet, which offers both the linguistic element (the text content of the tweet) as well as the visual element (images or videos shared in the tweet). Each student's project web article is designed to incorporate multimodal texts as evidence to their ideas.
To complete each project, students are asked to evaluate the credibility of multimodal texts prior to embedding the texts into a web article. Informal and formal sources may be used as long as the student is able to explain the purpose for using each source in the web article. For example, a student might explain that the reason she embedded into her web article a tweet from a general twitter user is to show a layperson's perspective on a given issue (as opposed to the scholarly perspective on the same issue). Capturing important conversations from the web and addressing those conversations using academic research and analysis are some of the goals of completing the multimodal research projects.
The Goals of the Project Are to Acquire Knowledge and Skills in the Following 5 Literacy Domains
- Critical Media Literacy (e.g. What are the media available for expressing speech? Does each type of media, such as podcasts, radio, television, film, webcomics, websites, blogs, virtual reality, augmented reality, social media, etc.), require users to customize their message in different ways to best reach the target audience? How does each type of social media platform, such as Twitter, Reddit, Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Skype, Wechat, Discord, Slack, Tumblr, Periscope, etc., influence our way of communication? What are the target audience for each type of media? How do people, such as activists, spread their social and political messages on different types of media?)
- Digital and Web Literacy (e.g. How are digital tools designed to influence our thinking? How can we use digital tools to express and broadcast our message? What is the difference between a blog and a microblog? How do digital tools store our information? What does it mean to be a digital citizen?)
- Information Literacy (e.g. Who is creating the information? From where is the information being spread? What is the authorial intention behind the content and the design of the information? How does the intended audience alter the way the information is expressed? How can we evaluate the information on its credibility and authorial intent?)
- Rhetorical Expression (e.g. Write long-form essays that are arranged (with a rhetorical mode) to best express an argument to the intended audience).
- Valid and Sound Argumentation (e.g. Offer arguments that are structurally valid and verifiable by evidence from credible sources).
Sample Student Projects
Below, I will feature a selection of my students' multimodal research projects (web articles) that are rhetorically significant and praiseworthy:
(Note: Students were asked to omit their names from the project to protect their identity and privacy. Also, students were given one week to complete each web article and continue to write a series of web articles on new topics throughout the semester)
Definition Arguments (Sample Student Projects)
- Lawnmower Parents Mowing Down Adversity (Definition Argument)
- What’s In an Engineer? (Definition Argument)
- Defining Antifa (Definition Argument)
- Is Racism a Mental Health Issue? (Definition Argument)
- Response to Racism Is a Mental Health Issue (Definition Argument)
- Redefining Race: An Idea Created By Society Or Proven By Genetics? (Definition Argument)
- What Really Is a Genius? (Definition Argument)
- Can Artificial Intelligence Be Legally Responsible For Itself? (Definition Argument)
- The Shepard Tone: A Musical Torque Wrench (Definition Argument)
- Climate Change and Cold Weather (Definition Argument)
- The Effects of Weather Change on Weather Patterns (Definition Argument)
- Hot Climate? Cold Weather? How Do They Relate to Climate Change? (Definition Argument)
- Hyperloop: The Future of Travel (Definition Argument)
- Ikigai: A Japanese Concept Americanized to Mean Much More (Definition Argument)
- What Is an E-Girl? What It Means and How It Empowers Today's Women (Definition Argument)
Evaluation Arguments (Sample Student Projects)
- Controversial New Technology Being Used By The LAPD (Evaluation Argument)
- Evaluating Film With A Single Criterion (Evaluation Argument)
- China's Social Credit Score...The New Dystopia? (Evaluation Argument)
- Evaluating Models (Evaluation Argument)
- Poorly Represented Culture (Evaluation Argument)
- Are Student Evaluations Gender Biased? (Evaluation Argument)
- The Future of Autonomous Vehicles Is Bright (Evaluation Argument)
- Evaluating Predictive Policing (Evaluation Argument)
- Dress Codes: To Be Discriminatory Or Fair? (Evaluation Argument)
- Would Standing Airline Seats Be Worth Cheaper Airfare? (Evaluation Argument)
- Am I Popular? (Evaluation Argument)
- STEM Education: Evaluating Its Possible Impact In Today's Society (Evaluation Argument)
- LifeStraw: The Easiest Method For Obtaining Clean Water (Evaluation Argument)
- Facebook's Content Conundrum (Evaluation Argument)
Causality Arguments (Sample Student Projects)
- Genetic Discrimination in Healthcare (Causality Argument)
- Opinions That Bend Reality (Causality Argument)
- Immigration & Crime: Do They Go Hand In Hand? (Causality Argument)
- Causes of Trust (Causality Argument)
- All Memories Are Not Created Equal
- How Google's DeepMind AI Learned To Be Mean: Self-Interest from Logical Reasoning (Causality Argument)
- How Trauma Affects the Body (Causality Argument)
- The Causes Behind Ossan Rentals (Causality Argument)
- Voluntourism: Does It Really Help? (Causality Argument)
- Fragile Sound Mediums (Causality Argument)
- All Memories Are Not Created Equal (Causality Argument)
- The Fallen Angels (Causality Argument)
- Main Causes of Exhaustion From a Day of Work (Causality Argument)
- Effects of Sleep Loss (Causality Argument)
- Will Overpopulation Bring the End of Life on Earth? (Causality Argument)
Visual Analysis Arguments (Sample Student Projects)
- The Overworking Crisis (Visual Analysis Argument) (Video) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Food for Thought (Visual Analysis Argument) (Photographs) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Analysis of Color (Visual Analysis Argument) (Photographs) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- A Pig, Ink, and a Disney Princess: Subverting Culture's Expectations (Physical Artwork) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- You Are What You Read (Physical Artwork) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- You Are What You Read Art Piece: Violence Against Animals? (Physical Artwork) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Features of Art: A Response to The Physical Impossibility of Death in the Mind of Someone Living by Damien Hirst (1991) (Physical Artwork) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Female Samurai Warrior in Japan (Photographs) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Hikikomori (Photographs) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Hikikomori: Reclusive Victims of Society (Photographs) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Hiding in Plain Sight: The Hikikomori (Photographs) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Ghosts Are Real: The Hikikomori of Japan (Photographs) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Analyzing Loved (Video Game) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- On a Plate (Webcomic) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Formulaic Grading: Discouraging Independent Thought pre-1985 (Webcomic) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Reversing the Roles (Photographs) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Comparison of School Lunches Internationally (Photographs) (Visual Analysis Argument)
- Think You Have a Good Lunch? Think Again (Photographs) (Visual Analysis Argument)
Rogerian Arguments (Sample Student Projects)
- ‘They’ Is Now a Singular Word (Rogerian Argument)
- Faulty Logic for UBI (Rogerian Argument)
- Criminally Underpaid: An Examination of Compulsory Labor (Rogerian Argument)
- Commodities in Flesh (Rogerian Argument)
- Should We Genetically Modify Food? (Rogerian Argument)
- Self Driving Car and Its Demerits (Rogerian Argument)
- Self Driving Drawbacks (Rogerian Argument)
- Costs and Benefits of Self-Driving Cars (Rogerian Argument)
- The Road to Self Driving Cars (Rogerian Argument)
- Robot Cataclysm: Are Our Jobs At Risk? (Rogerian Argument)
- Autonomous Armageddon: Will Robots Take Our Jobs? (Rogerian Argument)
- Slavery in the Prison Systems (Rogerian Argument)
- Slavery Is Still Legal in the United States (Rogerian Argument)
- Social Media and Democracy (Rogerian Argument)