Prompt 2 📰

💬 Two serious-looking adult men in tailored suits playing a card game, sitting at a small round table, opposite of each other but facing each other in the center of a dimly lit room. The room has minimal furnishings, with a vintage hanging lamp casting shadows across the scene. The image should be a simple, less detailed black and white illustration in the style of mid-20th-century newspaper cartoons, with bold lines and exaggerated facial expressions.

Rankings are based off a point system scored by how much it followed the prompt, how realistic the images (it can be mistaken as a human creation work) and general aesthetic/composition/design.

Disclaimer General art design is my subjective opinion

👑 Rank 1 DALL-E

Followed Prompt = 5/5

Realism = 4/5

Inconsistent overhead lighting shape that curves around subjects in an unnatural manner
two exact looking characters
card design looks a bit out of place

General Art Design = 5/5 Score: 14

Followed Prompt = 5/5
- - - Realism = 4/5

duplicate character design
bad lighting

General Art Design = 4.5/5

Score: 13.5

Rank 2 - Microsoft Copilot

Rank 3 - Google Labs

Followed Prompt = 4/5

not in black and white

2. not in mid-20th-century newspaper cartoon style

- - - Realism = 4/5

same character design

General Art Design = 5/5

Score: 13

Followed Prompt = 4.5/5

The art style of the scene seems to be a bit more realistic compared to a mid-20th-century newspaper cartoon

- - - Realism = 4/5

same character design

2. The cards on the table look over-saturated

so it makes the cards look less detailed or distinguishable from actual cards

General Art Design = 4/5

Score: 12.5

Rank 4 - Midjourney

Rank 5 - Deep AI

Followed Prompt = 5/5
- - - Realism = 4/5

cards are generated badly

General Art Design = 3/5

Score: 12

Rank 6 - Grok 2

Followed Prompt = 4.6/5

Doesn't look like they’re playing a card game due to major distortions

- - - Realism = 3.5/5

Distorted cards & hands
lamp looks out of place
lighting shape looks odd

General Art Design = 3.5/5

The subjects take too much space in the scene
the background details of the image looks odd.

Score: 11.6

Followed Prompt = 4/5

No background shading to convey dimly lit room

- - - Realism = 4/5

Distorted faces, same male character design

2. Same male character design

General Art Design = 3/5

Score: 11

Rank 7 - Adobe Firefly

Rank 8 - PicLumen

Followed Prompt = 4/5

only two cards are placed on the table
doesn’t seem like they’re necessarily playing a card game since they have no cards in hand

- - - Realism = 3/5

Distorted faces, same male character design

2. Same male character design

General Art Design = 3.5/5

Score: 10.5

Followed Prompt = 4/5

not in black and white

- - - Realism = 4/5

same character design

General Art Design = 2/5

Score: 10

Rank 9 - NightCafe

Rank 10 - Hugging Face

Followed Prompt = 4/5

not in mid-20th-century newspaper cartoons style

- - - Realism = 3/5

same character design

2. distorted hands

3. cards standing upright which looks odd

General Art Design = 2/5

Score: 9

Followed Prompt = 3/5

not in mid-20th-century newspaper cartoons style

2. not playing cards

3. not in black and white

- - - Realism = 3/5

Composition is very odd

2. eyes and hands are distorted

General Art Design = 1/5

Score: 7

Rank 11 - Art Breeder

Rank 12 - Stable Diffusion

Followed Prompt = 2.6/5

Their facial expression seems more neutral rather than exaggerated

2. not directly facing or even looking each other

3. not an illustration

4. no vintage lamp

5. not playing cards

6. not in black and white

- - - Realism = 3.5/5

eyes are uncanny, cards are distorted
hands are slightly distorted
watch on the wrist is distorted

General Art Design = 2/5

Photo isn’t really aesthetically pleasing, or interesting

Score: 6.1