Prompt 1🍂

💬 An adult girl with brown hair wearing a hiking uniform leaning against a tree at the top of a hill in the middle of the forest overlooking an abandoned building that is a few floors tall in the distance. The scene takes place during the season of fall in the middle of a sunny day. The scene takes place during the fall season, with vibrant orange and red leaves scattered around. Sunlight filters through the trees, casting dappled shadows on the ground. The style should be realistic but with a slightly cartoony touch, similar to Disney's art style.

Rankings are based off a point system scored by how much it followed the accuracy of the prompt, how realistic the images (it can be mistaken as a human creation work), and general aesthetic/composition/design.

👑 Rank 1

Midjourney

Followed Prompt = 4/5

a. Less detailed hiking outfit can be mistaken for casual outfit

b. scene seems to take place during sun down instead of middle of a sunny day

Realism = 4.5/5

a. Entire face is warped but from far away viewers can’t tell unless they zoom in

b. painting style is harder to distinguish from an actual artist

General Art Design = 5/5

Score: 13.5

Followed Prompt = 4/5

a. Not looking at building

b. not an adult character

Realism = 4/5

a. Mouth is off

b. leaves on the ground are distorted

General Art Design = 5/5

Score: 13

Rank 2

Google Labs

Rank 3

Deep AI

Followed Prompt = 4/5

a. Not looking at the building

b. is leaning but not against a tree so it’s anatomically wrong

c. not an adult character

Realism = 4.5/5

a. Aside from the distorted face

b. the art style/painting style looks natural which makes it hard to tell whether or not it’s AI

General Art Design = 4/5

Score: 12.5

Followed Prompt = 4/5

a. Not standing on a hill

b. Not looking at the building

Realism = 4/5

a. The eyes look weird and the hand in pocket is anatomically wrong

b. painting style people can tell it’s AI

General Art Design = 4/5

Score: 12

Rank 4

DALL-E

Rank 5

Grok 2

Followed Prompt = 4.3/5

a. Subject isn’t leaning against the tree

b. she isn’t overlooking let alone facing the building

Realism = 3/5

a. Unnatural hands

b. distorted eyes

c. hair/wind physics seem to be off

d. the abundance of leaves both on the ground and on the trees are unnatural

General Art Design = 3.5/5

a. Dull color palette such as the color of the hiking outfit

b. the orange leaves look too saturated and at the same time dark and dull

c. plain-looking hiking outfit

Score: 10.8

Rank 6

Night Cafe

Followed Prompt = 3/5

a. Not cartoon/disney style

b. Sun seems to be setting in the scene rather than middle of the day

c. not looking directly at the building

Realism = 4/5

a. Building looks unnatural

b. the pose seems unnatural

General Art Design = 3.5/5

Score: 10.5

Followed Prompt = 3/5

a. Not looking at the building

b. not leaning against tree

c. not in disney or cartoon style

Realism = 3.5/5

a. Distorted face

b. trees in the far background

General Art Design = 3/5

Score: 9.5

Rank 7

PicLumen

Rank 8

Adobe Firefly

Followed Prompt = 4/5

a. Not leaning against the tree

b. no leaf details

Realism = 2/5

a. Barely any proper details

b. flat colors and shading

General Art Design = 2/5

Score: 8

Followed Prompt = 1/5

a. Not on hill

b. not looking at building

c. no abandoned building

d. scene is set after sundown

e. not cartoon/disney style

Realism = 3/5

a. Airbrushed/smooth skin which makes it obvious that it’s AI generated

b. subject looks very unnatural looking, even uncanny

General Art Design = 1/5

Score: 5

Rank 9

Art Breeder

Rank 10

Stable Diffusion

Followed Prompt = 2.6/5

❌no building to be found

❌no sunlight filters through the trees

❌no visible shadows casting on the ground

❌not in a cartoon or disney style

Realism = 3.5/5

1. small distortion hands and face (specifically the eyes, mouth, nose and ears)

2. leaves on the trees have no detail or proper shape

General Art Design = 2.5

💭I wouldn’t consider this piece to be all that artistically beautiful or even interesting, it seems more like a plain photograph of someone simply in a forest

Score: 6.6

Rank 11

Hugging Face

Followed Prompt = 3/5

a. Not looking at the building

b. not in disney/cartoon style

c. sitting on a pile of wood rather than leaning against a tree

d. no proper lighting so it seems like a cloudy day rather than a sunny day

Realism = 0.5/5

a. Distorted face, hands, shoes and trees

b. very bad background blur

General Art Design = 0.5/5

Score: 4

Page updated

Google Sites

Report abuse