IBDP Design Technology - 2.5 Green Design

Resource management and sustainable production / 2.5 /
Green Design

Green design integrates environmental considerations into the design of a product without compromising its integrity. The starting point for many green products is to improve an existing product by redesigning aspects of it to address environmental objectives. The iterative development of these products can be incremental or radical depending on how effectively new technologies can address the environmental objectives. When newer technologies are developed, the product can re-enter the development phase for further improvement

2.5.1 | Strategies for green design

Green design and eco-design are two similar terms that are often used interchangeably, but they have some subtle differences.

Eco-Design is a holistic approach to design that aims to reduce the environmental impact of products and services throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction to disposal. Eco-design considers factors such as energy efficiency, water conservation, waste reduction, and the use of non-toxic materials. Examples:

A building that is designed to be energy-efficient by using passive solar heating, natural ventilation, and recycled materials.
A product that is designed to be durable and repairable, so that it can be used for a longer period of time.
A packaging system that is designed to be recycled or composted.
A manufacturing process that is designed to reduce waste and emissions.

Eco-design requires multiple strategies to be applied at the same time. For example

Reduce: Use recycled materials in packaging and products, design products to be durable and repairable, and minimize waste during manufacturing and transportation.
Renewable energy: Use solar panels, wind turbines, and other renewable energy sources to power buildings and factories.
Energy efficiency: Use energy-efficient appliances and lighting fixtures, and insulate buildings to reduce heating and cooling costs.
Water conservation: Use water-efficient fixtures and appliances, and collect rainwater for irrigation.
Waste reduction: Design products that can be composted or recycled, and avoid using single-use plastics.
Non-toxic materials: Use non-toxic materials in products and packaging, and avoid using hazardous chemicals in manufacturing processes.

Green design is a more focused approach to design that focuses on the environmental impact of products and services during their use phase. Eco design considers factors such as energy consumption, water consumption, and emissions. Examples:

A refrigerator that uses less energy than conventional refrigerators.
A car that emits fewer pollutants than conventional cars.
A light bulb that lasts longer and uses less energy than conventional light bulbs.
A water faucet that uses less water than conventional faucets

2.5.2 | Green legislation

Green legislation usually encourages incremental rather than radical change.

Incremental change is more politically feasible. Radical changes to the status quo are often met with resistance from powerful interests, making them difficult to implement. Incremental changes, on the other hand, are often more politically palatable and can be achieved through consensus building.
Radical changes can have unintended consequences and disrupt existing systems. Incremental changes, on the other hand, can be implemented more gradually and in a way that minimizes disruption.
Incremental change allows for learning and adaptation. As incremental changes are implemented, policymakers and stakeholders can learn from their experiences and adapt their approach accordingly. This makes it more likely that successful policies will be sustained over time.

Here are some specific examples of how green legislation encourages incremental rather than radical change:

Regulations that phase in stricter emissions standards for vehicles. These regulations allow automakers to gradually improve the fuel efficiency of their vehicles, without having to make radical changes to their designs or manufacturing processes.
Policies that promote renewable energy development. These policies can include tax credits, subsidies, and renewable portfolio standards. They encourage the gradual deployment of renewable energy technologies without requiring a complete overhaul of the energy grid.
Building codes that require energy-efficient appliances and insulation. These codes gradually improve the energy efficiency of new and existing buildings, without requiring homeowners and businesses to make radical changes to their properties.

While incremental change may not be as fast-paced or transformative as radical change, it is often the most effective way to achieve long-term sustainability goals. Green legislation that encourages incremental change can help to build consensus, minimize disruption, and allow for learning and adaptation. This makes it more likely that sustainable policies will be implemented and sustained over time.

It is important to note that incremental change is not always mutually exclusive of radical change. In some cases, incremental change can lead to radical change over time. For example, the gradual adoption of renewable energy technologies could eventually lead to a complete transition away from fossil fuels.

2.5.3 | Timescale to implement green design

The average timescale for implementing legislation for green design is between 2 and 5 years. This timeline can vary depending on a number of factors, including:

The complexity of the legislation
The level of government at which it is being implemented
The resources available
The level of public support for green design
The opposition from certain industries or groups
The availability of new technologies and materials

Here is a breakdown of the typical steps involved in implementing incremental legislation for green design:

Legislation is passed: This is the first step in the process and can take several months or even years, depending on the political climate.
Regulations are drafted: Once the legislation is passed, government agencies must draft regulations that explain how the law will be implemented. This process can also take several months or years.
Stakeholders are engaged: Once the regulations are drafted, government agencies will typically engage with stakeholders, such as businesses, environmental groups, and consumers, to get feedback and make revisions. This process can also take several months.
Regulations are finalized and implemented: Once the regulations are finalized, they are implemented and businesses and other organizations must begin to comply with them. This process can take several months or years, depending on the complexity of the regulations and the resources available.
Compliance is monitored and enforced: Government agencies will monitor and enforce compliance with the new regulations. This process can be ongoing.

It is important to note that the timescale for implementing incremental legislation for green design can be accelerated or delayed depending on a number of factors. For example, if there is a strong public outcry for green design, or if the government provides financial incentives for businesses to comply with new regulations, the implementation process may be accelerated. Conversely, if there is strong opposition to green design from certain industries or groups, or if the government does not provide adequate resources for implementation, the process may be delayed.

The typical timescale for implementing incremental green design is 2-5 years. This timeline can vary depending on a number of factors, including:

The complexity of the green design changes being implemented
The size and complexity of the organization or project
The level of resources available
The level of stakeholder engagement and support
The regulatory environment

Here is a breakdown of the typical steps involved in implementing incremental green design:

Planning and assessment: The first step is to identify the opportunities for green design and assess the costs and benefits of each opportunity. This may involve conducting a green building assessment or life cycle assessment.

Design and development: Once the green design changes have been identified and assessed, the next step is to develop detailed designs and specifications. This may involve working with architects, engineers, and other consultants.
Implementation: Once the designs and specifications are complete, the next step is to implement the green design changes. This may involve construction, renovation, or changes to operational procedures.
Monitoring and evaluation: Once the green design changes have been implemented, it is important to monitor their performance and evaluate their effectiveness. This may involve collecting data on energy consumption, water use, and other environmental impacts.

The timescale for each of these steps can vary depending on the factors mentioned above. For example, if the green design changes are complex or involve a large number of stakeholders, the planning and design process may take longer. Additionally, if the organization or project has limited resources, the implementation process may take longer.

Here are some examples of incremental green design changes that can be implemented on a relatively short timescale:

Switching to energy-efficient lighting
Installing water-efficient fixtures
Improving insulation and air sealing in buildings
Planting trees and other vegetation on site
Recycling and composting office materials

Here are some examples of incremental green design changes that may take longer to implement:

Upgrading to renewable energy systems
Installing green roofs or living walls
Renovating buildings to improve their energy performance
Developing new products or services that are more sustainable

Overall, the typical timescale for implementing incremental green design is 2-5 years. However, the actual timeline can vary depending on a number of factors, such as the complexity of the changes being implemented, the size and complexity of the organization or project, and the level of resources available.

2.5.4 | Drivers for green design

The main drivers for green design are:

Environmental concerns: Green design is a way to reduce the environmental impact of products and services. This includes reducing energy consumption, water consumption, and pollution emissions. Green design can also help to conserve natural resources and protect biodiversity.
Economic benefits: Green design can lead to economic benefits for businesses and consumers. For example, energy-efficient buildings and appliances can save businesses and consumers money on their energy bills. Green design can also help businesses to attract and retain customers who are interested in sustainable products and services.
Government regulations: Governments around the world are increasingly enacting regulations to promote green design and construction. For example, many countries have energy efficiency standards for buildings and appliances.
Consumer demand: Consumers are increasingly demanding sustainable products and services. Many consumers are willing to pay a premium for green products, and they are more likely to do business with companies that are committed to sustainability.
Technological advances: New technologies are making it easier and more affordable to design and produce green products and services. For example, the cost of solar panels and other renewable energy technologies has fallen significantly in recent years.

Designers play a critical role in driving green design. They are responsible for shaping the products, services, and environments that we interact with on a daily basis. By incorporating sustainable principles into their work, designers can help to reduce the environmental impact of human activity and create a more sustainable future. Designers should:

Educate themselves about green design principles and practices. Designers need to have a strong understanding of the environmental and social impacts of their work. They also need to be familiar with the latest green design technologies and materials.
Collaborate with other stakeholders. Green design is a complex process that requires input from a variety of stakeholders, including engineers, architects, scientists, and policymakers. Designers need to be able to collaborate effectively with these stakeholders to develop and implement green design solutions.
Design for the entire life cycle of a product or service. Green design is not just about reducing the environmental impact of a product during its use phase. Designers also need to consider the environmental impact of a product during its manufacturing, transportation, and disposal phases.
Use sustainable materials and processes. Designers should choose materials and processes that have a minimal environmental impact. This includes using recycled materials, renewable energy sources, and low-toxicity chemicals.
Design for durability and repairability. Designers should design products that are durable and easy to repair. This will help to reduce the amount of waste that is generated.
Design for user behaviour. Designers can help to promote sustainable behaviour by designing products and services that are easy to use and that encourage users to make sustainable choices.

In addition to these specific actions, designers can also drive green design by promoting awareness of sustainability issues and by advocating for policies that support green design.

2.5.5 | Design objectives for green products

Design objectives for green design can be organized into three categories: materials, energy, and pollution/waste.

Materials:

Use recycled and renewable materials whenever possible.
Choose materials that are low-toxicity and non-polluting.
Design products to be durable and repairable.
Design for easy disassembly and recycling.

Energy:

Reduce energy consumption throughout the life cycle of the product or service, including manufacturing, transportation, use, and disposal.
Use renewable energy sources whenever possible.
Design products to be energy-efficient.
Promote energy efficiency through user behaviour design.

Pollution/waste:

Reduce pollution emissions throughout the life cycle of the product or service.
Design products to minimize waste generation.
Design for sustainable disposal of products and waste.

2.5.6 | Strategies for designing green products

The best strategy to identify opportunities for green design is the use of Life Cycle Assessment (LCA). LCA is a tool that assesses the environmental impact of a product throughout its entire life cycle, from raw material extraction to disposal. By identifying the environmental hotspots of your product, you can focus your design efforts on reducing those impacts. It is important to involve stakeholders in LCA. This could include suppliers, customers, environmental groups, and government agencies. By getting input from stakeholders early in the design process, you can identify and address potential environmental concerns.

Strategies that will often resuslt from LCA are:

Improve durability and repairability. Products that are durable and repairable will last longer and generate less waste. Consider using high-quality materials and designing products that can be easily disassembled and repaired.
Use recycled and renewable materials. Recycled materials reduce the need to extract new raw materials, and renewable materials are grown or harvested in a sustainable way.
Improve energy efficiency. Energy-efficient products consume less energy over their lifetime, which reduces greenhouse gas emissions and saves consumers money. Consider ways to reduce the energy consumption of your product throughout its life cycle, from manufacturing to use.
Minimize waste. This includes designing products that use less material, packaging, and energy. It also includes designing products that can be easily recycled or composted at the end of their life.
Dematerialization: A packaging designer could reduce the amount of material used in a product package by optimizing the shape of the package and using lightweight materials.
Use low-impact materials: A building materials manufacturer could use recycled concrete and low-VOC paints to create durable and low-impact building materials.
Design for cleaner production: A clothing manufacturer could reduce pollution emissions from the manufacturing process by using renewable energy sources and water-efficient technologies.
Design for disassembly: A furniture designer could use standard screw sizes and make it easy to access internal components to make furniture easy to disassemble and recycle.
Design for longevity: A home appliance manufacturer could use high-quality materials and design appliances to be easily repaired to extend their lifespan.

2.5.7 | The prevention principle

The prevention principle states that it is better to prevent environmental problems from occurring in the first place than to try to clean them up after they happen. This principle is applied to green design by identifying and addressing potential environmental impacts at the earliest stages of the design process. Some examples of the prevention principle at work are:

Energy efficiency - The development of energy-efficient appliances, such as LED light bulbs and smart thermostats, helps to prevent greenhouse gas emissions and save consumers money on their energy bills.
Choosing low-impact materials - The use of recycled materials in packaging and other products helps to reduce the demand for virgin materials and conserve natural resources.
Waste reduction - The design of green buildings that incorporate passive solar heating and cooling, energy-efficient appliances, and renewable energy sources helps to reduce the building's energy consumption and pollution emissions.
Pollution prevention - The development of sustainable agriculture practices, such as crop rotation and integrated pest management, helps to prevent soil erosion, water pollution, and the use of synthetic pesticides.

2.5.8 | The precautionary principle

The precautionary principle states that (innovation in) green design should be carried out with caution, especially when there is a risk of serious or irreversible environmental damage. This does not mean that innovation should be halted altogether, but rather that it should be guided by a deep understanding of the potential risks and benefits of new technologies and materials.

There are a number of ways to apply the precautionary principle to green design. Some examples include:

Avoiding the use of potentially harmful materials and processes. This is especially important when there is scientific uncertainty about the potential risks of these materials and processes. For example, green designers may choose to avoid using certain chemicals or nanomaterials in their products, even if there is no definitive evidence that these materials are harmful.
Designing for flexibility and adaptability. This allows products and systems to be easily adapted to new information about environmental risks. For example, a green building may be designed with the ability to easily switch to renewable energy sources or to upgrade to more energy-efficient appliances.
Engaging in stakeholder dialogue and consultation. This helps to ensure that all stakeholders, including scientists, environmental groups, and community members, have a voice in the design process. This can help to identify potential environmental risks and concerns that may not have been considered by the designer alone.

By applying the precautionary principle to green design, designers can help to reduce the risk of serious or irreversible environmental damage. Here are some specific examples of how the precautionary principle has been applied to green design:

The development of safer alternatives to hazardous chemicals, such as lead-free paint and water-based paints, is an example of applying the precautionary principle to green design.
The use of biomimicry, which is the design of products and systems inspired by nature, is another way to apply the precautionary principle. Biomimicry can help designers to identify and implement sustainable solutions that have been proven to work over millions of years of evolution.
The development of precautionary design guidelines and tools, such as the Cradle to Cradle Design Framework, can help designers to apply the precautionary principle to their work. These guidelines and tools can help designers to identify and address potential environmental risks at the earliest stages of the design process.

Page updated

Report abuse