Unit 6 - Global Conflict and Cooperation: Genocide and the Search for Justice
Unit 6 - Global Conflict and Cooperation: Genocide and the Search for Justice
February - March
Overview
This World Studies unit tackles the dark reality of genocide, examining its common motivations, processes, and consequences. Students will analyze the 10-step process of genocide and explore its global impacts. The unit investigates the international response to genocide, both ineffective and effective, at various scales, including local and global initiatives. Students will also explore the search for justice and reconciliation in the aftermath of genocide. The unit emphasizes the use of primary sources, including testimony, to understand the human element and the profound impact of genocide on individuals and communities. Given the sensitive nature of this topic, the unit will provide a trauma warning, along with guidance on pedagogical approaches for teaching this difficult subject. The unit will cover various genocides from the 20th and 21st centuries, such as the Armenian Genocide, the Cambodian Genocide, genocides conducted by governments, the ongoing genocide of the Uyghurs, and genocides in Darfur and Bosnia. Additionally, the unit will explore the role of the International Criminal Court, international agreements, political patterns, national boundaries, and the influence of cultural differences and conflicts over land in the occurrence of genocide. The unit will also focus on the theme of reconciliation and the challenges faced in the aftermath of genocide. In seeking Justice and Reconciliation, students will explore the search for justice and accountability in the aftermath of genocide, analyze mechanisms such as international tribunals and truth commissions, and examine the challenges and possibilities of reconciliation in post-genocide societies.
The focus of each unit could include one or more of the following:
Anchor Event: Armenian Genocide
Regional Focus: Varied
Concept: Genocide, International Response, and Reconciliation
1. Apply the process of inquiry to examine and analyze how historical knowledge is viewed, constructed, and interpreted.
2. Analyze historical time periods and patterns of continuity and change, through multiple perspectives, within and among cultures and societies.
3. Evaluate how scarce resources are allocated in societies through the analysis of individual choice, market interaction, and public policy.
4. Examine the characteristics of places and regions, and the changing nature among geographic and human interactions.
Grade Level Standard(s)
GLE: History 1: Apply the historical method of inquiry to formulate compelling questions, evaluate primary and secondary sources, analyze and interpret data, and argue for an interpretation defended by textual evidence.
GLE: History 3: Analyze and evaluate key concepts of continuity and change, cause and effect, complexity, unity and diversity, and significant ideas throughout the world from the Renaissance to the present.
GLE: Geography 2: Make connections among geographic variables that influence the interactions of people, places, and environments.
GLE Geography 3: Investigate patterns of the interconnected nature of the world, its people, and places.
GLE: Economics 2: Evaluate how mixed economic systems, market structures, competition, government policies, and the roles of producers and consumers affect market outcomes.
The highlighted evidence outcomes are the priority for all students, serving as the essential concepts and skills. It is recommended that the remaining evidence outcomes listed be addressed as time allows, representing the full breadth of the curriculum.
Students Can (Evidence Outcomes):
History: 1.1.b. Gather and analyze historical information to address questions from a range of primary and secondary sources containing a variety of perspectives. For example: Perspectives of historically underrepresented groups.
History: 1.1.c. Gather and analyze historical information from a range of qualitative and quantitative sources. For example: Demographic, economic, social, and political data.
History: 1.1.d. Construct and defend a historical argument that evaluates interpretations by analyzing, critiquing, and synthesizing evidence from a wide range of relevant historical sources.
History 1.3.a. Evaluate continuity and change over the course of world history. For example: the 19th, 20th and 21st century genocides such as the Armenian Genocide; the Cambodian Genocide; genocides conducted by governments; and the current genocide of the Uyghurs; as well as genocides that have taken place in Darfur and Bosnia.
History: 1.3.d. Examine and evaluate issues of unity and diversity in world history from the Renaissance to the present. For example: Migration and immigration (e.g., rapid global population growth), world conferences and international agreements (e.g., United Nations, International Criminal Court), and human rights issues.
Geography: 2.2.c. Examine patterns of distribution and arrangements of settlements and the processes of the diffusion of human activities.
Geography: 2.3.d. Analyze how culture, and cooperation and conflict influence both the division and unification of Earth. For example: International agreements, political patterns, national boundaries, and how cultural differences and conflict over land may lead to genocide.
Geography: 2.3.f. Examine geographic concepts through the lens of multiple diverse perspectives from various regions of the world and with consideration for indigenous, dominant, and marginalized populations. Including but not limited to: the Uyghurs in China.
Economics: 3.2.g: Explore how economic crises create an environment where genocide is allowed to occur. For example: Rationing, scapegoating, including the incremental dehumanization of minority groups, and mitigating conflict over resources.
Articulate thoughts and ideas effectively using oral, written, and nonverbal communication skills in a variety of forms and contexts, including multilingual (Interpersonal Communication).
Interpret, analyze, and draw conclusions using historical sources (Critical Thinking and Analysis).
Apply geographic knowledge and skills to implement sophisticated, appropriate, and workable ideas to address complex geographic interactions among multiple diverse groups using interdisciplinary perspectives independently or with others (Global and Cultural Awareness).
Apply a fundamental understanding of the ethical/legal issues in the interconnected nature of the world for effective civic participation (Social Awareness, Civic Engagement).
Historical thinkers use primary and secondary sources to evaluate and develop hypotheses and diverse interpretations of historical events and figures and patterns and trends.
Historical thinkers evaluate the credibility of a source by examining how experts value the source.
Historical thinkers use information and context to interpret, evaluate, and inform decisions or policies regarding such issues which societies find contentious or worthy of debate and discussion.
Historical thinkers consider what perspectives or information is left out of an argument and why that might be important to know.
Historical thinkers analyze historical, contemporary, and emerging means of changing societies, promoting the common good, and protecting rights.
Inquiry Questions
How might historical inquiry be used to better understand and make decisions about contemporary issues?
How are human rights violated and prosecuted in a world of different nations and cultures?
What role has censorship, propaganda, and media control played in modern genocides and other acts of mass violence?
What does it mean to support human rights?
Disciplinary, Informational and Media Literacy
Conduct short as well as more sustained research projects to answer a question (including a self-generated question) or solve a problem; narrow or broaden the inquiry when appropriate; synthesize multiple sources on the subject, demonstrating understanding of the subject under investigation.
Write content-specific arguments in which they state a claim, provide evidence from texts and sources to support the claim, and organize the evidence in well-reasoned, meaningful ways.
Integrate multimedia as effective tools for presenting and clarifying information.
Engage in civil discourse on historical topics using evidence as a basis for argument formation.
Academic Vocabulary and Language Expectations:
genocide, International Criminal Court, reconciliation, 10 stages of genocide (classification, symbolization, discrimination, dehumanization, organization, polarization, preparation, persecution, extermination, denial), human rights
Possible Assessments:
Memorials of Genocide: PBL assessment. Make a copy to change it to meet the needs of your students and community.
Why has the United Nations Failed to Prevent Genocide? C3 Inquiry with the summative task: Construct an argument (e.g., detailed outline, poster, or essay) using specific claims and relevant evidence from historical sources.
Instructional Resources
The Holocaust and Genocide Studies Implementation Guide
Multiday Lesson to introduce genocide studies - differentiated for MLs and Newcomers
Savvas EasyBridge
World History Interactive
Quest Inquiry DBQ: How should nations respond to genocide?
CDE Resource Bank
iWitness - Shoah Foundation
Watchers of the Sky: Documentary and Raphael Lemkin's Story
The Genocide Convention and War in Ukraine Lesson from Choices
Reasons for Humanitarian Intervention: CSPAN lesson plan
Genocide and Global Response Lesson Plan from ADL with four lessons
Can Social Media Posts Prove War Crimes? Podcast
Russian War Crimes in Ukraine - 60 minutes video
The International Criminal Court: The Process
How has the UN failed to prevent genocide? C3 Inquiry
DLMS Booksets
How Dare the Sun Rise by Sandra Uwiringiyimana (Burundi)
The Land of Permanent Goodbyes by Atia Abawi (Syrian)
As Long as the Lemon Trees Grow by Zoulfa Katouh (Syrian)
Butterfly Yellow by Thanhhá Lai (Vietnam)