Enantiodifferentiation by NMR

L.T. Kuhn, K. Motiram-Corral, T.J. Athersuch, T. Parella and M. Pérez-Trujillo

Angew. Chem. Intl. Ed., 59, 23615-23619 (2020). DOI

Simultaneous Enantiospecific Detection of Multiple Compounds in Mixtures using NMR Spectroscopy

Chirality plays a fundamental role in nature, but its detection and quantification still face many limitations. To date, the enantiospecific analysis of mixtures necessarily requires prior separation of the individual components. The simultaneous enantiospecific detection of multiple chiral molecules in a mixture represents a major challenge, which would lead to a significantly better understanding of the underlying biological processes; e.g. via enantiospecifically analysing metabolites in their native environment. Here, we report on the first in situ enantiospecific detection of a thirty‐nine‐component mixture. As a proof of concept, eighteen essential amino acids at physiological concentrations were simultaneously enantiospecifically detected using NMR spectroscopy and a chiral solvating agent. This work represents a first step towards the simultaneous multicomponent enantiospecific analysis of complex mixtures, a capability that will have substantial impact on metabolism studies, metabolic phenotyping, chemical reaction monitoring, and many other fields where complex mixtures containing chiral molecules require efficient characterisation.

A. Virgili, A. Granados, C. Jaime, R. Suárez-López, T. Parella and E. Monteagudo

J. Org. Chem., 85, 7247-7257 (2020). DOI

Evidence of enantiomers of spiroglycol (SPG). Distinction by using α,α'-bis(trifluoromethyl)-9,10-anthracenedimethanol (ABTE) as Chiral Solvating Agent and by derivatization with chiral acids.

Herein, we perform for the first time a preliminary NMR and computational study of the spiroglycol structure. Spiroglycol is a highly symmetrical molecule, but it should be chiral due to the presence of a chiral axis. The presence of two enantiomers was demonstrated performing NMR enantiodifferentiation experiments using α,α′-bis(trifluoromethyl)-9,10-anthracenedimethanol (ABTE) as a chiral solvating agent (CSA). The addition of 0.6 equiv of ABTE allows the differentiation of several spiroglycol proton signals. The lack of resolution observed in the proton spectrum can be tackled through the corresponding 13C NMR spectrum where a significant enantiodifferentiation at the spirocarbon atom was observed. In order to physically separate both enantiomers, a SPG derivatization with camphorsulfonic acid and Mosher’s acid was performed affording the corresponding diastereoisomeric ester mixtures. Computations performed with the Gaussian16 package showed that the enantiodifferentiation is mainly due to the different compound thermodynamics stability.

M. Pérez-Trujillo, T. Parella and L. T. Kuhn

Analytica Chimica Acta, 876,63-70 (2015). DOI

NMR-aided differentiation of enantiomers: Signal enantioresolution

NMR-aided enantiodiscrimination using chiral auxiliaries (CAs) is a recognized method for differentiating enantiomers and for measuring enantiomeric ratios (er). Up to the present, the study, optimization, and comparison of such methods have been performed based on the enantiodifferentiation of NMR signals via analyzing non-equivalent chemical-shift values (ΔΔδ) of the diastereoisomeric species formed. However, a poor and non-reliable comparison of results is often obtained via the analysis of ΔΔδ exclusively. In here, the concept of enantioresolution of an individual NMR signal and its importance for NMR-aided enantiodifferentiation studies is introduced and discussed. In addition, the enantioresolution quotient, E, is proposed as the parameter to describe its quantification. Complementary to measuring ΔΔδ, the experimental determination of E allows a more reliable interpretation of the results and opens up new possibilities for the study of enantiodifferentiation data derived from novel NMR experiments, setup improvements or new CAs. Finally, the different relationships between signal enantiodifferentiation, signal enantioresolution, and other main experimental issues of enantiodifferentiation experiments are addressed.

M. Pérez-Trujillo, L. Castañar, E. Monteagudo, P. Nolis, L.T. Kuhn, A. Virgili, R.T. Williamson and T. Parella

Chem. Comm., 50, 10214-10217 (2014). DOI.

Simultaneous 1H and 13C NMR enantiodifferentiation from highly resolved pure shift HSQC spectra

NMR enantiodifferentiation studies are greatly improved by the simultaneous determination of 1H and 13C chemical shift differences through the analysis of highly resolved cross-peaks in spectral aliased pure shift (SAPS) HSQC spectra.

L. Castañar, M. Pérez-Trujillo, P. Nolis, E. Monteagudo, A. Virgili and T. Parella

ChemPhysChem, 15, 854 (2014). DOI

Enantiodifferentiation through Frequency-Selective Pure-Shift 1H Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy

A frequency-selective 1D 1H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiment for the fast and sensitive determination of chemical-shift differences between overlapped resonances is proposed. The resulting fully homodecoupled 1H NMR resonances appear as resolved 1D singlets without their typical J(HH) coupling constant multiplet structures. The high signal dispersion that is achieved is then exploited in enantiodiscrimination studies by using chiral solvating agents.

M. Pérez-Trujillo, E. Monteagudo and T. Parella

Anal. Chem., 85, 10887-10894 (2013). DOI

13C NMR spectroscopy for the differentiation of enantiomerics using chiral solvating agents

The utility of 13C NMR spectroscopy for the differentiation of enantiomers using chiral solvating agents (CSA) is stated. Three examples involving the enantiodifferentiation of a drug, a metabolite and a reactant in aqueous and organic solutions have been chosen to show it. The intrinsic high dispersion of 13C nucleus, as well as the singlet nature of the signals in standard experiments makes 13C NMR experiments a powerful alternative or complement to 1H NMR experiments; specially, when studying pure compounds with complex proton spectra or mixtures of compounds, as in chiral metabonomics, where severe overlapping exists in proton spectrum. To evaluate and compare the quality of the enantioresolution of a NMR signal we introduce the enantiodifferentiation quotient, E, that considers the complexity of 1H multiplets (and in general the width) of the original signal. It has been observed that the error in the measurement of the enantiomeric molar ratio can be related to the E value. The sensitivity and experimental time of a wide range of chiral analyte concentrations were also assessed.

M. Pérez-Trujillo, J.C. Lindon, T. Parella, J.K. Nicholson, H.C. Keun, and T.J. Athersuch

Anal. Chem., 84, 2868-2874 (2012). DOI

Chiral Metabonomics: 1H NMR-based enantiospecific differentiation of metabolites in human urine via co-solvation with beta-cyclodextrin

Differences in molecular chirality remain an important issue in drug metabolism and pharmacokinetics for the pharmaceutical industry and regulatory authorities, and chirality is an important feature of many endogenous metabolites. We present a method for the rapid, direct differentiation and identification of chiral drug enantiomers in human urine without pretreatment of any kind. Using the well-known anti-inflammatory chemical ibuprofen as one example, we demonstrate that the enantiomers of ibuprofen and the diastereoisomers of one of its main metabolites, the glucuronidated carboxylate derivative, can be resolved by 1H NMR spectroscopy as a consequence of direct addition of the chiral cosolvating agent (CSA) β-cyclodextrin (βCD). This approach is simple, rapid, and robust, involves minimal sample manipulation, and does not require derivatization or purification of the sample. In addition, the method should allow the enantiodifferentiation of endogenous chiral metabolites, and this has potential value for differentiating metabolites from mammalian and microbial sources in biofluids. From these initial findings, we propose that more extensive and detailed enantiospecific metabolic profiling could be possible using CSA-NMR spectroscopy than has been previously reported.