Freemasonary

Following the revolutionary disruptions in Europe and America, the British authorities became concerned that secret societies such as Freemasons, with their principle of brotherhood, might harbour radical dissidents. So, in the early 1800s, legislation was introduced to limit the secrecy of Freemasons. This concern seems strange, as Freemasonry in Scotland appears to have been quite open. This was a time when there was widespread interest in forming clubs and societies, and the masonic principles appealed as they appeared to reflect the Age of Enlightenment aspirations for a society of intellectual equality.

In 1889, William Fraser (Number 41), a solicitor, was invited to join the Supreme Council of the Sovereign Grand Masters; a special distinction as he is one of only 195 so honoured to this day. Fraser became involved in a long standing debate as to whether Robert Burns had been installed as the Masonic Poet Laureate. (Painting by unknown artist) Burns became a Mason in 1781, remaining active until his death, and it was partly because of his Masonic connections that Burns was so widely received when he arrived in Edinburgh in 1786. The claim that there had been a meeting at which Burns had been installed as Poet Laureate was dismissed by many as no minute of the event existed, but Fraser provided evidence in a letter he wrote from Albany Street: ‘ My Dear Sir and Brother, I have read the printed correspondence and all that has been said against the facts … and am surprised at so much being written against said facts to so little purpose. The following is a copy of the document you ask for, extracted from my private diary for 1853 - " On the 1st of March 1787, on the motion of Alexander Fergusson of Craigdarroch, Dumfriesshire, Master of Canongate Kilwinning Lodge, Brother Robert Burns was elected Poet-Laureate of the Lodge, an office which he held till his death in 1796. When I was Master of Canongate Kilwinning in 1853 I received corroboration of this well-known fact, from my brother-in-law, Mr James Veitch, Elliock, Dumfriesshire, and he had it direct from his cousin, Cutlar Fergusson, Younger, of Craigdarroch, who was present in the Lodge room on 1st March 1787."’ Whether or not the event did take place, Burns certainly celebrated freemasonry in his poetry:

Adieu, a heart warm, fond adieu,

Dear brothers of the mystic tie!

Ye favored, ye enlightened few,

Companions of my social joy!

Tho' I to foreign lands must hie,

Pursuing fortune's slidd'ry ba',

With melting heart and brimful eye,

I'll mind you still, though far awa'.

Dr Alexander Mudie (Number 35) had previously lived in Jamaica where he had owned an estate, and there he had been an active Freemason. Being the sugar capital of the world, Jamaica had become a valuable British colony, and by 1813 was at the height of its dominance. Its commercial importance had spawned a wealthy and influential business class, many with direct family and business ties to Britain. Therefore, the Freemasonry of the time was predominantly white, upper-middle class, though a number of masons were Jewish. Jamaica offered Jews a freedom not yet available in much of Europe, and so many who had fled persecution in Portugal and other parts of Europe were attracted to the colony. With the outbreak of the revolutionary wars, anti-Freemasonry sentiment resurfaced, especially from the Catholic Church. Due to Freemasonry being viewed with suspicion by the authorities for political as well as religious reasons, some West Indian Lodges had to meet under the guise of an educational organisation offering lessons in Spanish and English.

In the 1830s, James Graham (Number 50) (portrait by unknown artist) was the Principal of the Edinburgh Royal Arch Chapter. While there is often a perception that Masonic meetings consist solely of mysterious rituals, the minutes from the time show that the Chapter’s issues were actually ones familiar to anyone who has served on committees. There was an issue of where the Lodge might meet as The Royal Exchange Coffee House was not felt to be completely suitable. Alternative venues were discussed but the committee came to no resolution. There were on-going problems with finding members to stand for office holder posts and concerns over unpaid subscriptions and the need to raise more funds. It was reported, for example, that a meeting of the Committee on Subscriptions to the Burns Monument - about to be erected in the memory of Robert Burns on Calton Hill - had been summoned, but no one had turned up. Not all the frustrations were to do with internal Lodge matters. A request to have a procession at the laying of the foundation stone for the Burns Monument had been turned down by the Magistrates of Edinburgh as they would not sanction a public Masonic procession. Hopefully, the pleasures of social association alleviated the frustrations of committee membership. The Chapter members are recorded as ‘enjoying The Annual Celebration of the Vernal Equinox’ which took place at the Turf Hotel in Princes Street, and ‘following a Lecture upon the Mysteries of the Order, delivered by Alexander Deuchar, the Companions sat down to an excellent supper.’ Although the Masons had been stopped from parading at the opening of the monument to Burns, this was not the case at the unveiling of the Scott Monument, where they took front stage: ‘The masonic ceremonies applicable to such an occasion having been gone through, Lord Glenlyon, grand master of the Grand Lodge of Scotland, addressed the magistrates and committees in masonic phrase, declaring that it was now his duty to hand over the monument, duly finished, to the care of the Lord Provost and magistrates of Edinburgh.’