Cubic Equations
To the uninitiated, cubics would appear to be a simple step up from quadratics. However, they are not. The general method for
finding a real solution for a cubic equation was discovered by the Italians in the 16th century when algebraic methods were spreading
throughout Europe. Since a cubic equation always has at least one real root, this method was satisfactory for a while. However when
the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra was confirmed in the 18th century it became necessary to establish complete solutions of cubic
equations that took into account all real and nonreal solutions.
The next two problems allow you to play with the sum and difference of two cubes formulas and cubing a binomial.
Blue Question: (PHTST vol.1) If and , find an integer value .
Red Question: (PHTST vol.1) If
is a number which satisfies , find the value of .
If you can establish one root of a cubic for certain, you can use Synthetic Division to reduce the original equation to a linear factor
times a quadratic and then apply the Quadratic Formula to find the remaining solutions. The next two problems take advantage of this fact.
STEP 2007, Math I, #8: A curve is given by the equation
(*)
where
is a real number. Show that this curve touches the curve with equation
(**)
at . [Hint: a good place to start is by using an interactive drawing program like Mathematica to graph the function for
various values of a and to notice that the point (2,8) is always a point of intersection.]
Determine the coordinates of any other point of intersection of the two curves.
(i) Sketch on the same axes the curves (*) and (**) when
.
(ii) Sketch on the same axes the curves (*) and (**) when
.
(iii) Sketch on the same axes the curves (*) and (**) when
.
Rewriting a cubic by guessing its Final Form
The next problem involves a clever tactic frequently used when you know a little bit about a polynomial. The idea is to guess the form of the
factors and then work backwards. In this problem, we first remove the known factor of (x-3) then we guess that the two remaining factors are
linear in x and y and will take the form of (x + ay + b) and (x + cy + d). This is reasonable based on the shape of the cubic itself. Then we
multiply out these factors and solve some non-linear equations to find out what the a, b, c, and d are.
STEP 2004, Math I, #3: (i) Show that
is a factor of
(*)
Express (*) in the form where , , , and are integers to be determined.
(ii) Factorise
into three linear factors.
A solution to this problem is posted below.
Methods for Solving Certain Cubics
At a future date, we will consider a general method for solving cubics which takes into account all real and nonreal solutions.
However some ingenious methods exist for finding the real solutions of cubics as long as the cubic takes on a particular form. These
methods usually involve clever factoring and rewriting. Each of the following problems presents you with a cubic in a particular form
then shows you how to solve it.
STEP 2011, Math III, #3: Show that, provided the polynomial
can be written in the form
where
and are the roots of the quadratic equation in given by
and
and are constants which you should express in terms of and .
[Hint: Here we are using the familiar technique of trying to rewrite a polynomial into a different form that is easier
to handle. By guessing the form we want the equation to have we can get it into a form which can be solved.
The first part asks you to assume the equation can be written in the form of a sum of two cubes. You just need
to find the constants that make this possible. Of course, these constants will depend upon the coefficients
p and q that are in the original equation. Your first goal is to find some relationship between
and and p and q. That quadratic equation
mentioned in the question implies that you will be able to use p and q to create a quadratic whose solutions will be
and .
After solving that quadratic, you can then get a and b as functions of
and . That will enable you to completely rewrite the polynomial.]
Hence show that one solution of the equation is
[Special note: Later, when we discuss roots of unity, we will show that we can obtain similar expressions for the
other two solutions in terms of
where .]
A solution to this problem is posted below.
STEP 2007, Math I, #4: Show that
can be written in the form , where
is a quadratic expression. Show that can be written as the sum of three expressions, each of which
is a perfect square.
[Hint: You can accomplish this in several ways. Think about how to divide out the factor (x + b + c) from the cubic and then to examine what remains.
The rest of the problem involves rearranging terms into perfect square trinomials.]
It is given that the equations and have a common root .
The coefficients
, and are real, and are both non-zero, and . Show that
and determine a similar expression involving . Hence show that
and that . Deduce that either or the two equations are identical.
STEP 2010, Math II, #7: (i) By considering the positions of its turning points, show that the curve with equation
where
and , crosses the x-axis once only.
(ii) Given that
satisfies the cubic equation
and that
obtain a quadratic equation satisfied by
. Hence find the real root of the cubic equation in the case , .
(iii) The quadratic equation
has roots
and . Show that
.
It is given that one of these roots is the square of the other. By considering the expression
find a relationship between
and .
Given further that
, and is real, determine the value of in terms of .
The next problem does not discuss how to solve a cubic but how to gain certain information about the nature of its real solutions
without actually finding them explicitly.
STEP 2013, Math II, #3: (i) Given that the cubic equation has three distinct
real roots and
, show with the help of sketches that either exactly one of the roots is positive or all three
of the roots are positive.
(ii) Given that the equation has three distinct real positive roots show that
, , (*)
[Hint: Consider the turning points.]
(iii) Given that the equation has three distinct real roots and that
,
determine, with the help of sketches, the signs of the roots.
(iv) Show by means of an explicit example (giving values for
, and ) that it is possible for the conditions
(*) to be satisfied even though the corresponding cubic equation has only one real root.