Understanding the Reflections Review Criteria 

In Reflections, the review process allows PTAs to score and award student entries for each level of the Reflections program. To structure and guide a fair review process, specific PTA Reflections review criteria are used to assess entries:  

• Interpretation of Theme (40 pts.): How closely the piece relates to the theme, based on the artwork itself and the artist statement.

• Creativity (30 pts.): How creative and original the piece is in its conception of the theme and its presentation.

• Technical Skill (30 pts.): The level of skill demonstrated in the basic principles/techniques of the arts area. 

How to Use a Rubric to Make Your Art Shine

A rubric is like a treasure map—it shows you what reviewers are looking for and helps you make your artwork the best it can be! Here’s how to use it to guide your creative journey—and a few things to watch out for.

Smart Rubric Tips for Reflections Artists

• Look at the Rubric Together: Go over the rubric with a family member, teacher or friend to make sure you understand the criteria.

• Check Your Work: Use the rubric to score your own art. Ask yourself: “Are there ways I can improve within each area?”

• Focus on What Matters Most: Some parts of the rubric might be worth more points—like Interpretation of Theme. Spend extra time making those parts really strong!

• Ask for Help: Show your art and the rubric to someone you trust. They might notice something you can improve.

• Use the Rubric Words: If the rubric says “shows strong creativity,” think about how you can make your connection to the Reflections theme stand out even more.

Rubric Mistakes to Avoid for Smart Reflections Artists

• Forgetting the Rubric: Don’t just guess what the reviewers want. When in doubt, use the rubric to guide you.

• Messy Work: Even the best ideas can lose points if the artwork looks rushed or sloppy. Take your time! If something is especially unique about your piece, explain why you made that choice in your artist statement.

• Not Understanding the Rules: If you’re not sure what something means, ask! It’s okay to get help and its better to understand now, than miss out later. Double-check requirements and deadlines with your PTA. 

• Trying to Do Too Much: Don’t try to fit everything in. Keep your idea clear, focused and relevant to the Reflections theme.

• Skipping the Planning Step: Start with a sketch or a plan to guide your piece. It helps your final creation look more polished.

Please note that New Jersey PTA is following all National PTA guidelines for Reflections submissions. The information above is directly from the following National PTA website: https://www.pta.org/home/programs/reflections/craft-an-entry#criteria