Figure 1. Relative morphological changes in C2C12 cells on the coated and uncoated plates. Phase-Contrast microscopy used for cell morphology imaging at Myoblast (MB), Day 0, Day 4 and Day 7 in 2.0% Gelatin and 50 Β΅g/ml Fibronectin. C2C12 cells show more proliferation (particularly, on MB stage and on Day 0) and appear to form more elongated myotubes on both fibronectin and gelatin-coated plates on day 4 and day 7 as compared to cells cultured on uncoated (control) plates. The least growth is observed on uncoated dishes as lots of empty spaces are shown among the cells, particularly on MB stage. (Scale bar = 100 Β΅m).
ATP Synthase control transcript levels increase in early differentiation, decrease around D7, and then increase again at D12. This late spike is most likely due to cells obtaining their contractile functions around this time. Surprisingly, fibronectin treatment showed down-regulation on the expression levels compared to the control sample, although there could be spikes during days that were not tested. Gelatin results are interesting due to very high expression levels during D0. Although this was apparent in both trials, an explanation is difficult to arrive at. This could simply be a result of mitochondrial biogenesis being upregulated during gelatin-coated differentiation, or perhaps a more abstract reason which would need to be tested further.
Figure 3. Relative Gene expression of MyoD normalized to GAPDH
The overall change in MyoD gene expression on both coated plates and on control. Fibronectin protein coating shows a steady increase in MyoD gene expression until day 4. In contrast, both control and gelatin plates display an increase in MyoD gene expression on day 0 (D0) and then a substantial drop (more than 50%) for control and less than 50% drop for gelatin plates on day 4 for MyoD gene expression. All data were normalized to the reference gene, GAPDH. Myoblast was used as a calibrator for each corresponding plate. n = 2 for Myoblast (MB) and D0; n=1 for day 4 (D4).
Figure 4. Relative Gene expression of M-Cadherin normalized to GAPDH.
(TOP)The change in M-cadherin expression from day 0 to 4 saw gelatin coated plates having a higher degree of expression relative to the myoblast stage. In contrast, fibronectin plates saw a dip in expression levels before rising but still being lower than both control and gelatin plates. (BOTTOM) However when the relative expression is calibrated to control myoblast plates, it can be seen that the expression of M-cadherin on fibronectin coated plates sees a nearly 30-fold increase in expression versus control and gelatin plates. This could potentially indicate that peak M-cadherin expression occurs earlier in fibronectin plates than in gelatin or control plates. All data points were normalized to the reference gene, GAPDH. n=2 for Myoblast and D0; n=1 for D4 and D7.
Interestingly, it appears as if fibronectin enhances mitochondrial biogenesis, while 2% gelatin inhibits relative mitochondrial biogenesis (DNM1L) genetic transcription is directly correlated with this process). Expected trends of increased prevalence of mitochondrial biogenesis during myoblast stages qPCR data has been normalized to the relative expression of GAPDH (reference gene) for all samples; r-squared < 0.01, data values calculated using the Pfaffle Method, where respective primer efficiencies (E) are E (GAPDH) ~87%, E (Drp-1) ~70.8%. Error bars are representative of relative standard deviation values; all qPCR experiments were conducted in triplicate.
Our data suggest that fibronectin is most suitable for C2C12 cell culturing to study myogenesis due to the increase in MyoD gene expression, supporting the other studies which emphasized that fibronectin promotes cell adhesion and proliferation.
It is interesting that MyoD gene expression was dropped on both gelatin and control plates on day 4 which were expected for MyoD expression as it is mainly required for myoblast and day 0 stage; However, gelatin maintains a relatively high gene expression on both day 0 and day 4 as compared to control, indicating that it also promotes cell adhesion and proliferation but to a lesser extent.
In terms of M-cadherin, gelatin conditions promoted the expression level of this protein during the course of myogenesis. This indicates that gelatin may contribute a role in cell adhesion of myoblast to myotubes during the course of myogenesis.
In Addition to myogenic markers, mitochondrial biogenesis such as the Γ-Subunit of ATP Synthase, Control transcript levels increased in early differentiation, decrease around D7, and then increased again at D12. This late spike is most likely due to cells obtaining their contractile functions around this time. Surprisingly, fibronectin treatment showed down-regulation on the expression levels compared to the control sample, although there could be spikes during days that were not tested. Gelatin results are interesting due to very high expression levels during D0. Although this was apparent in both trials, an explanation is difficult to arrive at. This could simply be a result of mitochondrial biogenesis being upregulated during gelatin-coated differentiation, or perhaps a more abstract reason which would need to be tested further.
Moreover, DNM1L, the gene coding for DRP-1 and indicative of mitochondrial biogenesis, also witnessed a significant increase in expression in the early (myoblast) stages of myogenesis with the fibronectin substrate. Interestingly, gelatin appears to have a significant effect on DNM1L genetic expression, in that transcription is downregulated across all myogenic stages.
As our data was only from two trials for MB and day 0, while the day 4 data was from only one trial, further trials with more biological replicates would be required for a longer time frame to validate these findings in the future.
Fibronectin is commonly used in functionalizing plant scaffolds to replicate ECM conditions; however, our results also suggest gelatin could provide similar results. Thus, an experiment could be conducted in observing the myogenic markers' expression level of plant scaffold coated in gelatin.