Fritz Zwicky and Vera Rubin
In 1933, Swiss-American astronomer Fritz Zwicky observed the Coma Galaxy Cluster and calculated the total mass of all of its stars. After compiling the data, Zwicky made a surprising discovery: the mass of the stars was only a fraction of the total mass required to maintain the orbital speeds of galaxies in the cluster. Since he knew the data regarding the orbital speeds and the visible mass were correct, he inferred that the cluster had to have more mass than he was observing. Although Zwicky was the first to recognize the phenomenon of “missing mass” (as he called it), it would take decades before its existence became widely accepted within the scientific community.
In the late 1970’s, Vera Rubin, an American astronomer, made a similar discovery while observing the rotation of the Andromeda Galaxy. She found that the galaxy’s outermost stars were orbiting its center at a velocity much faster than gravitational force caused by its visible mass could allow. In fact, the observed mass of the galaxy was only about 10% of the amount necessary to keep the stars in the galaxy’s orbit. Rubin’s discovery confirmed Fritz Zwicky’s theory, and the existence of dark matter, as it is widely known, has become part of all leading cosmological models. However, despite spending decades searching for dark matter, scientists have been unable to observe it directly. This project will ask the question that continues to plague the world’s brightest minds: “What is dark matter, and how do we find it?”
We still don’t know very much about dark matter. The main pieces of knowledge that scientists have are that dark matter has mass and does not emit electromagnetic radiation, which means it cannot be detected by light-collecting telescopes. Its name comes from these two physical properties: it is dark because it does not emit light and it is matter because it has mass. There are two proposed types of dark matter: baryonic and non-baryonic. Baryons are a family of subatomic particles that includes protons and neutrons, which means that all matter composed of atoms is baryonic. If you would like to simplify, think of baryonic dark matter as being composed of atoms and of non-baryonic dark matter as being composed of other kinds of particles.
The most researched candidates for baryonic and non-baryonic dark matter are known, respectively, as MACHOs and WIMPs. MACHOs (massive astrophysical compact halo objects) are celestial bodies that emit little to no radiation, such as black holes and neutron stars. While there are certainly untold numbers of MACHOs that scientists have not observed, recent studies have shown that they are not nearly abundant enough to be the sole source of dark matter in the Universe. WIMPs (weakly interacting massive particles) are hypothetical particles that interact very weakly or not at all with baryonic matter and non-gravitational forces, making them very difficult to detect. While they are called “massive particles,” this refers to their property of having mass, rather than their size, which is smaller than an atom.
There are three main theorized types of non-baryonic dark matter, corresponding with the speeds at which these hypothetical particles move: hot dark matter (HDM), which moves near the speed of light; cold dark matter (CDM), which moves well below relativistic speeds; and warm dark matter (WDM), which has some properties of both other types. The next section will discuss recent and ongoing experiments to find dark matter, including the search for these particles.
Reaching the limits of our scientific knowledge
NASA simulation of a black hole
Artist's depiction of a WIMP (Forbes magazine)
The Axion Dark Matter Experiment
Diagram of the LZ experiment
Diagram explaining gravitational lensing
There are a number of experiments being performed in the attempt to detect dark matter both directly and indirectly. Most direct detection is focused on WIMPs, including the “hot” neutrino and the “cold” axion. Neutrinos, which have been observed by physicists, are very fast-moving particles with close to zero mass that only interact with one of the three fundamental forces other than gravity, the weak nuclear force. Recent experiments have cast doubt on neutrinos as a solution to the problem of dark matter, although hope remains for a hypothetical “sterile neutrino” that only interacts with gravity.
Axions are hypothetical particles that have very low mass and interact weakly with existing particles, especially photons (light). Two experiments searching for axions are the University of Washington’s Axion Dark Matter Experiment (ADMX) and the US Department of Energy’s LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) Dark Matter Experiment. The ADMX cools a chamber to very low temperatures and creates an extremely strong magnetic field in an attempt to make local axions convert into photons, causing the release of a tiny amount of energy that can be detected by a hypersensitive instrument. The LZ experiment hopes to observe collisions between axions or other WIMPS and cooled liquid xenon, which would release a flash of light, also detected by a hypersensitive instrument.
Observation of gravitational lensing is a method used for indirect detection of dark matter. Gravitational lensing occurs when light is bent by an extremely strong gravitational field, thousands of times stronger than that of our Sun. Predicted by Albert Einstein’s theory of relativity, it can be used to find areas with high concentrations of dark matter when light travelling to Earth is bent more than it should be by a gravitational field’s visible mass, implying the existence of more invisible mass.
There are many concurrent experiments seeking to detect hypothetical varieties of dark matter. It is likely that there will not be a single “Eureka moment” discovery where scientists find the composition of all dark matter in the Universe. However, we are constantly improving and refining our knowledge of dark matter by running experiments that rule out some theories and continue to pursue others. It may be a slow and frustrating journey at times, but we are well on our way to discovering one of the greatest mysteries of the Universe.
NASA: https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/science/questions/dark_matter2.html https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/educators/galaxies/imagine/dark_matter.html
https://www.nasa.gov/audience/forstudents/9-12/features/what-is-dark-matter.html
Dr. Fran Chadha-Day: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcF1BYfTudo
Encyclopedia Britannica: https://www.britannica.com/science/dark-matter
LZ Dark Matter Experiment: https://lz.lbl.gov/
https://www.symmetrymagazine.org/article/lz-preps-to-begin-dark-matter-search
Axion Dark Matter Experiment: https://depts.washington.edu/admx/